<!DOCTYPE html PUBLIC "yes" "xhtml1-strict.dtd">
<html xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml">
<!--GENDOC2XHTML # converter_version: 1.2.3-->
  <head>
    <title>2020-07-202007C109201902640-00-TRA-DOC-EN-CONCL-C-0264-19-202002149-07_00</title>
    <meta content="text/html; charset=utf-8" http-equiv="Content-Type"/>
    <meta content="" name="Gendoc_DGTGeneratedDate"/>
    <meta content="en-GB" name="Gendoc_Lang"/>
    <meta content="11/03/2020" name="CustomProvisoryEditionDate"/>
    <meta content="" name="Gendoc_GenerationDate"/>
    <meta content="" name="IsFlattened"/>
    <meta content="1" name="NumProc"/>
    <meta content="Final" name="Gendoc_EditionType"/>
    <meta content="0001" name="Gendoc_CaseNumberSuite"/>
    <meta content="22/07/2020 17:10:47" name="Gendoc_LastVerificationDate"/>
    <meta content="" name="Gendoc_ProcedureNumber"/>
    <meta content="en" name="Gendoc_LangCode"/>
    <meta content="CNC" name="TypeDoc"/>
    <meta content="jEIBhI/EMItQJO3G637MxtyGe5vfnYVkjQNMNLADR92XrrsMWmNrp1WykbXmmib4532bh43VxT7rReP+DB1DODQOzKoRAVw+6s7vUI51Go1QJXTmlzVp2d3B27bhPm9f0puLcp0sxuKQr97WrFDL+mqnIkUePDxIAGHITwygaAg=" name="GenDocUID"/>
    <meta content="P" name="TypeProc"/>
    <meta content="" name="CreateCustomParts"/>
    <meta content="OK" name="ReadyToPublish"/>
    <meta content="ikk" name="Gendoc_User"/>
    <meta content="" name="EP_Mode"/>
    <meta content="" name="Gendoc_DGTGenerated"/>
    <meta content="" name="Gendoc_Vademecum"/>
    <meta content="0264" name="NumeroOrdre"/>
    <meta content="2019" name="Annee"/>
    <meta content="P" name="Gendoc_ProcedureType"/>
    <meta content="" name="EP_Version"/>
    <meta content="EN" name="Langue"/>
    <meta content="ikk" name="Gendoc_DGTGeneratedUser"/>
    <meta content="FAST_document_go_ok" name="Gendoc_LastVerificationStatus"/>
    <meta content="CNC_C" name="Gendoc_GendocTemplateType"/>
    <meta content="TRUE" name="WithoutAuthorBlockFlatP"/>
    <meta content="GenDoc 11/03/2020 15:45:20" name="Created"/>
    <meta content="" name="Canevas3_Vademecum"/>
    <meta content="TRUE" name="WithoutAuthorBlock"/>
    <meta content="" name="Gendoc_CaseYear"/>
    <meta content="false" name="Generation_In_Progress"/>
    <meta content="C" name="Juridiction"/>
    <meta content="7c972f3624b945e0acd59ff99ffc0795" name="DocumentIdentifier"/>
    <meta content="0264" name="Gendoc_CaseNumber"/>
    <meta content="ImportedWithoutSource" name="SdlIdentifier"/>
    <meta content="RP" name="NatureAff"/>
    <meta content="RP" name="Gendoc_CaseNature"/>
    <meta content="0001" name="NumSuite"/>
    <meta content="C" name="Gendoc_Juridiction"/>
  </head>
  <body>
    <div style="header">
      <div id="rId25" style="first"/>
      <div id="rId21" style="even">Opinion of Mr Saugmandsgaard Øe — Case C‑264/19</div>
      <div id="rId22" style="default">Constantin Film Verleih</div>
    </div>
    <p class="C36Centre" id="para-1" title="page-1">
      OPINION OF ADVOCATE GENERAL
    </p>
    <p class="C36Centre" id="para-2" title="page-1">
      SAUGMANDSGAARD ØE
    </p>
    <p class="C36Centre" id="para-3" title="page-1">
      delivered on 2 April 2020  (<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="c-1" href="#t-1">1</a>
</span>)
      
    </p>
    <p class="C38Centregrasgrandespacement" id="para-4" title="page-1">
      Case C‑264/19
    </p>
    <p class="C37Centregras" id="para-5" title="page-1">
      Constantin Film Verleih GmbH
    </p>
    <p class="C37Centregras" id="para-6" title="page-1">
      v
    </p>
    <p class="C37Centregras" id="para-7" title="page-1">
      YouTube LLC,
    </p>
    <p class="C37Centregras" id="para-8" title="page-1">
      Google Inc.
    </p>
    <p class="C39Centreespacement" id="para-9" title="page-1">
      (Request for a preliminary rulingfrom the Bundesgerichtshof (Federal Court of Justice, Germany))
    </p>
    <p class="C71Indicateur" id="para-10" title="page-1">
      (Reference for a preliminary ruling — Copyright and related rights — Internet-based video-sharing platform — YouTube — Uploading of a film without the consent of the rightholder — Proceedings concerning an infringement of an intellectual property right — Directive 2004/48/EC — Article 8 — Rightholder’s right to information — Article 8(2)(a) — Concept of ‘names and addresses’ — Scope — Email address, IP address and telephone number — Not included)
    </p>
    <p class="C02AlineaAltA" id="para-11" title="page-1">
      
    </p>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">I.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Introduction</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">1.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">This request for a preliminary ruling has arisen in the context of a dispute between Constantin Film Verleih GmbH, a film distributor established in Germany, and YouTube LLC and its parent company Google Inc., both of which are established in the United States.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">2.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">The dispute concerns the refusal by YouTube and Google to provide certain information required by Constantin Film Verleih with regard to users who have placed several films online in breach of Constantin Film Verleih’s exclusive exploitation rights. More specifically, Constantin Film Verleih is asking YouTube and Google to provide it with the email addresses, telephone numbers and IP addresses used by those users.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">3.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">The Bundesgerichtshof (Federal Court of Justice, Germany) asks, in essence, whether such information is covered by Article 8(2)(a) of Directive 2004/48/EC,  (<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="c-2" href="#t-2">2</a>
</span>) in accordance with which the competent judicial authorities may order the disclosure of the ‘names and addresses’ of certain categories of persons who have a connection with the goods or services which infringe an intellectual property right.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">4.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">For the reasons which I shall set out in this Opinion, I am convinced that the concept of ‘names and addresses’, set out in Article 8(2)(a) of Directive 2004/48, does not include any of the information set out above.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">II.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Legal framework</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">A.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">EU Law</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">5.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Recitals 2, 10 and 32 of Directive 2004/48 are worded as follows:</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <p class="C09Marge0avecretrait" id="para-20" title="page-3">
      ‘(2) The protection of intellectual property should allow the inventor or creator to derive a legitimate profit from his/her invention or creation. It should also allow the widest possible dissemination of works, ideas and new know-how. At the same time, it should not hamper freedom of expression, the free movement of information, or the protection of personal data, including on the Internet.
    </p>
    <p class="C09Marge0avecretrait" id="para-21" title="page-3">
      …
    </p>
    <p class="C09Marge0avecretrait" id="para-22" title="page-3">
      (10) The objective of this Directive is to approximate legislative systems so as to ensure a high, equivalent and homogeneous level of protection in the internal market.
    </p>
    <p class="C09Marge0avecretrait" id="para-23" title="page-4">
      …
    </p>
    <p class="C09Marge0avecretrait" id="para-24" title="page-4">
      (32) This Directive respects fundamental rights and observes the principles recognised in particular by the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union.  (<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="c-3" href="#t-3">3</a>
</span>) In particular, this Directive seeks to ensure full respect for intellectual property, in accordance with Article 17(2) of th[e] Charter.’
    </p>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">6.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Article 2 of that directive, entitled ‘Scope’, provides, in paragraphs 1 and 3(a):</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <p class="C02AlineaAltA" id="para-26" title="page-4">
      ‘1. Without prejudice to the means which are or may be provided for in [EU] or national legislation, in so far as those means may be more favourable for rightholders, the measures, procedures and remedies provided for by this Directive shall apply, in accordance with Article 3, to any infringement of intellectual property rights as provided for by [EU] law and/or by the national law of the Member State concerned.
    </p>
    <p class="C02AlineaAltA" id="para-27" title="page-4">
      …
    </p>
    <p class="C02AlineaAltA" id="para-28" title="page-4">
      3. This Directive shall not affect:
    </p>
    <p class="C09Marge0avecretrait" id="para-29" title="page-4">
      (a) the [EU] provisions governing the substantive law on intellectual property, Directive 95/46/EC …’
    </p>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">7.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Article 8 of Directive 2004/48, entitled ‘Right of information’, provides:</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <p class="C02AlineaAltA" id="para-31" title="page-4">
      ‘1. Member States shall ensure that, in the context of proceedings concerning an infringement of an intellectual property right and in response to a justified and proportionate request of the claimant, the competent judicial authorities may order that information on the origin and distribution networks of the goods or services which infringe an intellectual property right be provided by the infringer and/or any other person who:
    </p>
    <p class="C09Marge0avecretrait" id="para-32" title="page-4">
      (a) was found in possession of the infringing goods on a commercial scale;
    </p>
    <p class="C09Marge0avecretrait" id="para-33" title="page-4">
      (b) was found to be using the infringing services on a commercial scale;
    </p>
    <p class="C09Marge0avecretrait" id="para-34" title="page-4">
      (c) was found to be providing on a commercial scale services used in infringing activities,
    </p>
    <p class="C02AlineaAltA" id="para-35" title="page-4">
      or
    </p>
    <p class="C09Marge0avecretrait" id="para-36" title="page-4">
      (d) was indicated by the person referred to in point (a), (b) or (c) as being involved in the production, manufacture or distribution of the goods or the provision of the services.
    </p>
    <p class="C02AlineaAltA" id="para-37" title="page-5">
      2. The information referred to in paragraph 1 shall, as appropriate, comprise:
    </p>
    <p class="C09Marge0avecretrait" id="para-38" title="page-5">
      (a) the names and addresses of the producers, manufacturers, distributors, suppliers and other previous holders of the goods or services, as well as the intended wholesalers and retailers;
    </p>
    <p class="C09Marge0avecretrait" id="para-39" title="page-5">
      (b) information on the quantities produced, manufactured, delivered, received or ordered, as well as the price obtained for the goods or services in question.
    </p>
    <p class="C02AlineaAltA" id="para-40" title="page-5">
      3. Paragraphs 1 and 2 shall apply without prejudice to other statutory provisions which:
    </p>
    <p class="C09Marge0avecretrait" id="para-41" title="page-5">
      (a) grant the rightholder rights to receive fuller information;
    </p>
    <p class="C09Marge0avecretrait" id="para-42" title="page-5">
      (b) govern the use in civil or criminal proceedings of the information communicated pursuant to this Article;
    </p>
    <p class="C09Marge0avecretrait" id="para-43" title="page-5">
      (c) govern responsibility for misuse of the right of information;
    </p>
    <p class="C09Marge0avecretrait" id="para-44" title="page-5">
      (d) afford an opportunity for refusing to provide information which would force the person referred to in paragraph 1 to admit to his/her own participation or that of his/her close relatives in an infringement of an intellectual property right;
    </p>
    <p class="C09Marge0avecretrait" id="para-45" title="page-5">
      or
    </p>
    <p class="C09Marge0avecretrait" id="para-46" title="page-5">
      (e) govern the protection of confidentiality of information sources or the processing of personal data.’
    </p>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">B.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">German law</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">8.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Under the first sentence of Paragraph 101(1) of the Urheberrechtsgesetz (Law on Copyright, ‘the UrhG’), anyone who, on a commercial scale, infringes copyright or another right protected by that law may be required by the injured party to provide immediately information as to the origin and distribution channel of infringing copies or other products.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">9.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">In the event of manifest infringement, without prejudice to Paragraph 101(1) of the UrhG, that right to information may also be exercised, under point 3 of the first sentence of Paragraph 101(2) of that law, against a person who, on a commercial scale, has provided services used to engage in infringing activities.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">10.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">The person who is required to provide the information must, under Paragraph 101(3)(1) of the UrhG, state the names and addresses of the producers, suppliers and other previous holders of copies or other products, the users of the services and the intended wholesalers and retailers.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">III.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">The dispute in the main proceedings, the questions referred for a preliminary ruling and the procedure before the Court</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">11.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Constantin Film Verleih is a film distributor established in Germany.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">12.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">YouTube, which is owned by Google and established in the United States, operates the internet platform with the same name.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">13.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">In Germany, Constantin Film Verleih has exclusive exploitation rights in respect of the cinematographic works Parker and Scary Movie 5.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">14.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Between the months of June 2013 and September 2014, those two works were posted online on the ‘YouTube’ platform without Constantin Film Verleih’s consent. On 29 June 2013, the cinematographic work Parker was uploaded in its full-length version and in German under the username ‘N1’. It was viewed more than 45 000 times before it was blocked on 14 August 2013. During the month of September 2013, the cinematographic work Scary Movie 5 was uploaded in its full-length version under the username ‘N2’. It was viewed more than 6 000 times before it was blocked on 29 October 2013. On 10 September 2014, another copy of the second work was uploaded under the username ‘N3’. It was viewed more than 4 700 times before it was blocked on 21 September 2014.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">15.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Constantin Film Verleih demanded that YouTube and Google provide it with a set of information for each of the users who had uploaded those works.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">16.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">The referring court found that the conditions for the right to information were satisfied. Consequently, the scope of the dispute in the main proceedings is limited to the content of the information that YouTube and/or Google must provide to Constantin Film Verleih. More specifically, the dispute concerns the following information:</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">–</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">the user’s email address,</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">–</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">the user’s telephone number,</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">–</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">the IP address used by the user to upload the files at issue, together with the precise point in time at which such uploading took place, and</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">–</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">the IP address last used by the user to access his or her Google/YouTube account, together with the precise point in time at which that access took place.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">17.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Ruling at first instance, the Landgericht Frankfurt am Main (Regional Court, Frankfurt am Main, Germany) rejected Constantin Film Verleih’s request that such information be provided.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">18.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">On appeal, the Oberlandesgericht Frankfurt am Main (Higher Regional Court, Frankfurt am Main, Germany) ordered YouTube and Google to provide the email addresses of the users concerned, rejecting Constantin Film Verleih’s request as to the remainder.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">19.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">By its appeal on a point of law, brought before the Bundesgerichtshof (Federal Court of Justice), Constantin Film Verleih requested that YouTube and Google be ordered to provide it with all of the abovementioned information, including users’ telephone numbers and IP addresses. By their own appeal on a point of law, YouTube and Google requested that Constantin Film Verleih’s request be rejected in its entirety, including in so far as it concerns users’ email addresses.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">20.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Taking the view that the outcome of the two appeals on a point of law depended on the interpretation of the concept of ‘addresses’ contained in Article 8(2)(a) of Directive 2004/48, the Bundesgerichtshof (Federal Court of Justice) decided to stay the proceedings and to refer the following questions to the Court for a preliminary ruling:</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <p class="C09Marge0avecretrait" id="para-66" title="page-7">
      ‘(1) Do the addresses of the producers, manufacturers, distributors, suppliers and other previous holders of the goods or services, as well as the intended wholesalers and retailers, mentioned in Article 8(2)(a) of Directive [2004/48] and covered, as appropriate, by the information referred to in Article 8(1) of [that] directive, also include
    </p>
    <p class="C11Marge1avecretrait" id="para-67" title="page-7">
      (a) the email addresses of service users and/or
    </p>
    <p class="C11Marge1avecretrait" id="para-68" title="page-7">
      (b) the telephone numbers of service users and/or
    </p>
    <p class="C11Marge1avecretrait" id="para-69" title="page-7">
      (c) the IP addresses used by service users to upload infringing files, together with the precise point in time at which such uploading took place?
    </p>
    <p class="C11Marge1avecretrait" id="para-70" title="page-7">
      (2) If the answer to Question 1(c) is in the affirmative:
    </p>
    <p class="C10Marge1" id="para-71" title="page-7">
      Does the information to be provided under Article 8(2)(a) of Directive [2004/48] also cover the IP address that a user, who has previously uploaded infringing files, last used to access his or her Google/YouTube user account, together with the precise point in time at which access took place, irrespective of whether any infringement [of intellectual property rights] was committed when that account was last accessed?’
    </p>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">21.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">The reference for a preliminary ruling was received at the Registry of the Court of Justice on 29 March 2019.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">22.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Constantin Film Verleih, YouTube, Google, and the European Commission submitted written observations.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">23.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Representatives of Constantin Film Verleih, YouTube, Google, and the Commission took part in the hearing held on 12 February 2020 and presented oral argument.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">IV.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Analysis</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">24.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Under Article 8 of Directive 2004/48, Member States are obliged to provide, in their legal order, for the possibility, for the competent judicial authorities, to order that certain information be provided in the context of proceedings concerning an infringement of an intellectual property right.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">25.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Accordingly, by its two questions, which it is appropriate to examine together, the referring court asks whether Article 8(2)(a) of Directive 2004/48 must be interpreted as meaning that the Member States are obliged to provide for the possibility, for the competent judicial authorities, to order, in respect of a user who has uploaded files which infringe an intellectual property right, that the email address, the telephone number, the IP address used to upload those files and the IP address used when the user’s account was last accessed be provided.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">26.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">YouTube and Google, as well as the Commission propose that those questions be answered in the negative, in contrast to Constantin Film Verleih.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">27.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">In accordance with the position maintained by YouTube, Google, and the Commission, and for the reasons set out below, I take the view that that provision does not cover any of the information set out in the questions referred for a preliminary ruling.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">28.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">As a preliminary point, I note that Article 8(2)(a) of Directive 2004/48 contains no reference to the law of the Member States. Consequently, and in accordance with settled case-law, the concept of ‘names and addresses’ is a notion of EU law which must be given an autonomous and uniform interpretation.  (<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="c-4" href="#t-4">4</a>
</span>)
      </p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">29.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Moreover, the concept of ‘names and addresses’ is not defined in Directive 2004/48. Again according to settled case-law, the meaning and scope of terms for which EU law provides no definition must be determined by considering their usual meaning in everyday language, while also taking into account the context in which they occur and the purposes of the rules of which they are part.  (<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="c-5" href="#t-5">5</a>
</span>)
      </p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">30.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Therefore, the usual meaning in everyday language must be the starting point in the process of interpreting the concept of ‘names and addresses’ used in Article 8(2)(a) of Directive 2004/48. There is little doubt that, in everyday language, the concept of a person’s ‘address’, about which the referring court asks in particular, covers only the postal address, as YouTube and Google have rightly submitted.  (<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="c-6" href="#t-6">6</a>
</span>) That interpretation is confirmed by the definition of the French word ‘adresse’ given in the Dictionnaire de l’Académie française, namely ‘la désignation du lieu  (<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="c-7" href="#t-7">7</a>
</span>) où l’on peut joindre quelqu’un’ (the designation of the place where you can reach someone).</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">31.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">With regard to the telephone number, the second item of information referred to in the questions referred for a preliminary ruling, I do not consider it necessary to discuss at length the fact that it cannot be included in the concept of persons’ ‘names and addresses’, as envisaged in Article 8(2)(a) of Directive 2004/48, whether in everyday language or in any other context.  (<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="c-8" href="#t-8">8</a>
</span>)
      </p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">32.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">The status of the other two items of information referred to in those questions, namely the email address and the IP address, warrants further consideration.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">33.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">As I have just noted, in everyday language, the starting point in the interpreting process, the term ‘address’ refers only to the postal address. Therefore, when it is used without any further clarification, that term does not cover the email address or the IP address.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">34.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">This is especially the case in a context which I would describe as ‘general’, that is to say going beyond the strict context of the internet, as is the case with Article 8(2)(a) of Directive 2004/48.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">35.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">An examination of other EU legislation that refers to the email address or IP address supports that interpretation. Where the EU legislature has intended to refer to the email address  (<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="c-9" href="#t-9">9</a>
</span>) or the IP address,  (<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="c-10" href="#t-10">10</a>
</span>) it has done so expressly by supplementing the word ‘address’, as noted by YouTube and Google. To my knowledge, there are no examples of EU legislation where the terms ‘names and addresses’, used alone and in a general context, refer to the telephone number, IP address or email address.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">36.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Consequently, it follows from a literal interpretation of Article 8(2)(a) of Directive 2004/48 that the terms used by the EU legislature, namely the terms ‘names and addresses’, do not include any of the information set out in the questions referred for a preliminary ruling, as YouTube, Google, and the Commission have submitted.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">37.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">That interpretation is confirmed by the historical interpretation set out by the Commission. The travaux préparatoires which led to the adoption of Directive 2004/48  (<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="c-11" href="#t-11">11</a>
</span>) contain nothing to suggest, even implicitly, that the term ‘address’, used in Article 8(2)(a) of that directive, should be understood as referring not only to the postal address, but also to the email address or the IP address of the persons concerned.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">38.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">The Commission explained, in that regard, that, when Directive 2004/48 was adopted in 2004, the EU legislature had never intended to include more modern forms of an ‘address’, such as the email address or the IP address.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">39.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Accordingly, it follows from a historical interpretation that Directive 2004/48 must be interpreted as referring to only the traditional meaning of that term, namely the postal address.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">40.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">It follows from the foregoing that, according to a literal and a historical interpretation, Article 8(2)(a) of Directive 2004/48 does not include the email address, the telephone number and the IP addresses used by the persons covered by that provision.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">41.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Constantin Film Verleih contests that interpretation, focusing on the purpose of Article 8 of Directive 2004/48 and, more generally, the objectives of that directive.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">42.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">According to Constantin Film Verleih, the purpose of Article 8 of Directive 2004/48 is to enable the holder of intellectual property rights to identify the persons mentioned in that provision. Accordingly, and irrespective of its wording, Constantin Film Verleih takes the view that paragraph 2 of that article should be interpreted as referring to ‘any information that makes it possible to identify’ those persons and such information may include, depending on its availability, the telephone number, the email address, the IP address or even bank details.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">43.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">In my view, to adopt that interpretation would be tantamount to the Court rewriting that provision. I understand of course that a rightholder such as Constantin Film Verleih would like Directive 2004/48 to be amended to enable it to identify possible infringers more easily in the specific context of the internet. However, rewriting that legislation falls not to the Court, but to the EU legislature.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">44.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">It was open to the legislature, if that had been its intention, to include, in Article 8(2) of Directive 2004/48, ‘any information that makes it possible to identify’ the persons concerned. At the hearing, the Commission emphasised that the EU legislature had expressly chosen to provide for minimum harmonisation limited to names and addresses, without including other items of information which enable a person to be identified, such as a telephone number or social security number.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">45.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">I should point out that a ‘dynamic’ or teleological interpretation of that provision, as Constantin Film Verleih has called for, must be ruled out in this context. The terms used in Article 8(2)(a) of Directive 2004/48 do not offer sufficient room for interpretation to enable a dynamic or teleological interpretation with a view to including the information set out in the questions referred for a preliminary ruling.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">46.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">In that regard, I agree wholeheartedly with the reasoning developed by Advocate General Bobek in points 33 to 35, 38 and 39 of his Opinion in Commission v Germany. In accordance with the prohibition of contra legem interpretation and the principle of the separation of powers, a dynamic or teleological interpretation is only possible where ‘the text of the provision itself [is] open to different interpretations, presenting some degree of textual ambiguity and vagueness’.  (<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="c-12" href="#t-12">12</a>
</span>)
      </p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">47.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">However, that is not the case in this instance. As I explained above, literal and historic interpretations preclude any ambiguity as to the scope of the terms ‘names and addresses’ used in Article 8(2)(a) of Directive 2004/48.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">48.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Constantin Film Verleih also refers, more generally, to the objectives pursued by Directive 2004/48. In my view, that line of argument cannot call into question the interpretation of the abovementioned provision, given the lack of ambiguity in its wording. Nevertheless, for the sake of completeness, I will examine that argument below.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">49.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Admittedly, it cannot be disputed that Directive 2004/48 seeks to ensure a high level of protection of intellectual property in the internal market, as stated in recitals 10 and 32 thereof and in accordance with Article 17(2) of the Charter.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">50.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Nor can it be disputed that the interpretation proposed by Constantin Film Verleih would increase the level of protection of intellectual property in the internal market.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">51.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">However, it must be borne in mind that Directive 2004/48, like all legislation on intellectual property,  (<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="c-13" href="#t-13">13</a>
</span>) strikes a balance between, on the one hand, the interest of holders in protecting their intellectual property right, enshrined in Article 17(2) of the Charter and, on the other, the protection of the interests and fundamental rights of users of protected subject matter, and the public interest.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">52.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">As the Court has held on numerous occasions, there is nothing whatsoever in the wording of Article 17(2) of the Charter or in the Court’s case-law to suggest that the right to intellectual property enshrined in that article is inviolable and must for that reason be absolutely protected.  (<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="c-14" href="#t-14">14</a>
</span>)
      </p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">53.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Therefore, Article 17(2) of the Charter does not require that all available technical means be used to assist the holder in identifying possible infringers, without account being taken of the wording of the provisions of Directive 2004/48.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">54.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">With regard, in particular, to Article 8 of Directive 2004/48, the Court has already had occasion to specify, in the judgment in Coty Germany, that the aim of that provision is to reconcile compliance with various rights, inter alia the right of holders to information and the right of users to protection of personal data.  (<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="c-15" href="#t-15">15</a>
</span>)
      </p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">55.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">In the context of the case in the main proceedings, the data requested by Constantin Film Verleih are, by definition, personal data within the meaning of Article 2(a) of Directive 95/46/EC,  (<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="c-16" href="#t-16">16</a>
</span>) now Article 4(a) of Regulation (EU) 2016/679,  (<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="c-17" href="#t-17">17</a>
</span>) since they must enable Constantin Film Verleih to identify the persons concerned.  (<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="c-18" href="#t-18">18</a>
</span>)
      </p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">56.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Although it is clear from recital 32 of Directive 2004/48 that that directive seeks to ensure full respect for intellectual property, in accordance with Article 17(2) of the Charter, at the same time it is clear from Article 2(3)(a) and recitals 2 and 15 of that directive that the protection of intellectual property is not to hamper, inter alia, the protection of personal data guaranteed in Article 8 of the Charter, so that that directive cannot, in particular, affect Directive 95/46.  (<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="c-19" href="#t-19">19</a>
</span>)
      </p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">57.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">I note, in that regard, the importance of Article 8(3)(b) to (e) of Directive 2004/48, in accordance with which that article is to apply without prejudice to the provisions which set out, or even restrict, the holder’s right to information, and in particular the provisions which govern the processing of personal data.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">58.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">In that context, I take the view that it is not for the Court to alter the scope of the terms used by the EU legislature in Article 8(2) of Directive 2004/48, which would have the effect of upsetting the balance that the legislature had intended to achieve when adopting that directive. The EU legislature alone has the competence to strike that balance.  (<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="c-20" href="#t-20">20</a>
</span>)
      </p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">59.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">To supplement what I said in point 43 of this Opinion, to adopt the interpretation suggested by Constantin Film Verleih would be tantamount to the Court not only rewriting Article 8(2) of Directive 2004/48, but also upsetting the balance that was struck by the EU legislature in such a way as to favour the interests of holders of intellectual property rights.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">60.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">I would add that the dynamic interpretation suggested by Constantin Film Verleih also runs counter to the general scheme of Directive 2004/48, which is based on the minimum harmonisation intended by the EU legislature, as the Commission has noted.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">61.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">That institution rightly states that a dynamic interpretation of that kind is not appropriate in the present case since, under Article 8(3)(a) of Directive 2004/48, the EU legislature expressly provided for the possibility for the Member States to address that dynamic concern by granting rightholders ‘rights to receive fuller information’.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">62.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">In other words, a dynamic interpretation of Directive 2004/48 by the EU Courts, in order to bring it into line with new behaviour on the internet, is not necessary since the Member States have the power to adopt additional measures targeting that behaviour.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">63.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">For the sake of completeness, I would point out, lastly, that Article 47 of the TRIPS Agreement,  (<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="c-21" href="#t-21">21</a>
</span>) which establishes a mere ability to provide for a right to information, cannot be relied on in support of the interpretation proposed by Constantin Film Verleih.  (<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="c-22" href="#t-22">22</a>
</span>)
      </p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">64.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">For all of those reasons, I consider that Article 8(2)(a) of Directive 2004/48 must be interpreted as meaning that the concept of ‘names and addresses’ set out in that provision does not cover, in respect of a user who has uploaded files which infringe intellectual property rights, the email address, the telephone number, the IP address used to upload those files or the IP address used when the user’s account was last accessed.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">65.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Accordingly, the Member States are not obliged, under that provision, to provide for the possibility, for the competent judicial authorities, to order that that information be provided in the context of proceedings concerning an infringement of an intellectual property right.</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">V.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">Conclusion</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <table cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" border="0" width="100%">
<col width="5%"/>
<col width="95%"/>
<tr>
<td valign="top">
<p class="count">66.</p>
</td>
<td valign="top">
<p class="normal">In the light of the foregoing, I propose that the Court should answer the questions referred for a preliminary ruling by the Bundesgerichtshof (Federal Court of Justice, Germany) as follows:</p>
</td>
</tr>
</table>
    <p class="C02AlineaAltA" id="para-120" title="page-15">
      Article 8(2)(a) of Directive 2004/48/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 29 April 2004 on the enforcement of intellectual property rights must be interpreted as meaning that the concept of ‘names and addresses’ set out in that provision does not cover, in respect of a user who has uploaded files which infringe intellectual property rights, the email address, the telephone number, the IP address used to upload those files or the IP address used when the user’s account was last accessed.
    </p>
    <p class="C02AlineaAltA" id="para-121" title="page-15">
      Accordingly, the Member States are not obliged, under that provision, to provide for the possibility, for the competent judicial authorities, to order that that information be provided in the context of proceedings concerning an infringement of an intellectual property right
    </p>
    <div/>
  <hr class="note"/>
<p class="note footnote">(<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="t-1" href="#c-1">1</a>
</span>) Original language: French.</p>
<p class="note footnote">(<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="t-2" href="#c-2">2</a>
</span>) Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council of 29 April 2004 on the enforcement of intellectual property rights (OJ 2004 L 157, p. 45, and corrigendum OJ 2004 L 195, p. 16).</p>
<p class="note footnote">(<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="t-3" href="#c-3">3</a>
</span>) ‘The Charter’.</p>
<p class="note footnote">(<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="t-4" href="#c-4">4</a>
</span>) See, in respect of the concept of ‘appropriate compensation’, used in Article 9(7) of Directive 2004/48, judgment of 12 September 2019, Bayer Pharma (C‑688/17, EU:C:2019:722, paragraph 40). See also, again with regard to intellectual property, judgments of 22 June 2016, Nikolajeva (C‑280/15, EU:C:2016:467, paragraph 45), and of 27 September 2017, Nintendo (C‑24/16 and C‑25/16, EU:C:2017:724, paragraphs 70 and 94).</p>
<p class="note footnote">(<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="t-5" href="#c-5">5</a>
</span>) See, inter alia, judgments of 31 January 2013, McDonagh (C‑12/11, EU:C:2013:43, paragraph 28); of 6 September 2018, Kreyenhop &amp; Kluge (C‑471/17, EU:C:2018:681, paragraph 39); and of 12 September 2019, Bayer Pharma (C‑688/17, EU:C:2019:722, paragraph 41).</p>
<p class="note footnote">(<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="t-6" href="#c-6">6</a>
</span>) I have not noticed any inconsistency in the different language versions of that provision, which all refer to the concept of an ‘address’: see, by way of illustration, ‘direcciones’ in the Spanish version, ‘adresse’ in the Danish version, ‘Adressen’ in the German version, ‘addresses’ in the English version, ‘indirizzo’ in the Italian version, ‘adres’ in the Dutch version, ‘endereços’ in the Portuguese version, ‘adresele’ in the Romanian version, and ‘adress’ in the Swedish version.</p>
<p class="note footnote">(<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="t-7" href="#c-7">7</a>
</span>) My italics.</p>
<p class="note footnote">(<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="t-8" href="#c-8">8</a>
</span>) The fact, on which Constantin Film Verleih relies, that the telephone number may have a ‘routing address’ function for the transmission of data, in particular in connection with telephone calls or applications that use a telephone number, such as WhatsApp, cannot change my view in that regard. The concept of persons’ ‘names and addresses’, as envisaged in Article 8 of Directive 2004/48, clearly has no connection with the functional intended purpose of the data flow, notwithstanding the fact that the latter may have been described as a ‘routing address’.</p>
<p class="note footnote">(<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="t-9" href="#c-9">9</a>
</span>) With regard to the email or ‘electronic’ address, see inter alia Article 88(2) of Regulation (EC) No 987/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 September 2009 laying down the procedure for implementing Regulation (EC) No 883/2004 on the coordination of social security systems (OJ 2009 L 284, p. 1); Article 14(1) of Regulation (EU) No 524/2013 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 21 May 2013 on online dispute resolution for consumer disputes and amending Regulation (EC) No 2006/2004 and Directive 2009/22/EC (Regulation on consumer ODR) (OJ 2013 L 165, p. 1); Article 54(2) of Directive 2014/24/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 26 February 2014 on public procurement and repealing Directive 2004/18/EC (OJ 2014 L 94, p. 65), and Article 45(2)(a) of Directive (EU) 2015/2366 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 25 November 2015 on payment services in the internal market, amending Directives 2002/65/EC, 2009/110/EC and 2013/36/EU and Regulation (EU) No 1093/2010, and repealing Directive 2007/64/EC (OJ 2015 L 337, p. 35).</p>
<p class="note footnote">(<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="t-10" href="#c-10">10</a>
</span>) With regard to the IP address, see inter alia Article 10(1)(e) of Directive 2014/41/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 3 April 2014 regarding the European Investigation Order in criminal matters (OJ 2014 L 130, p. 1); Article 5(1)(k) of Regulation (EU) 2017/1128 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 14 June 2017 on cross-border portability of online content services in the internal market (OJ 2017 L 168, p. 1); Article 17(8), Article 34(4)(j) and Article 52(2)(g) of Regulation (EU) 2018/1240 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 12 September 2018 establishing a European Travel Information and Authorisation System (ETIAS) and amending Regulations (EU) No 1077/2011, (EU) No 515/2014, (EU) 2016/399, (EU) 2016/1624 and (EU) 2017/2226 (OJ 2018 L 236, p. 1).</p>
<p class="note footnote">(<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="t-11" href="#c-11">11</a>
</span>) See, in particular, Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on measures and procedures to ensure the enforcement of intellectual property rights of 30 January 2003 (COM(2003) 46 final) and the Opinion of the European Economic and Social Committee of 29 October 2003 (OJ 2004 C 32, p. 15) and the Report of 5 December 2003 by the European Parliament (A5-0468/2003) on that proposal. The proposal for a directive contains no explanation as to the meaning to be given to the terms ‘names and addresses’. Moreover, the Parliament did not propose any amendment in respect of the wording of the future Article 8(2)(a) of Directive 2004/48.</p>
<p class="note footnote">(<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="t-12" href="#c-12">12</a>
</span>) C‑220/15, EU:C:2016:534, point 34.</p>
<p class="note footnote">(<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="t-13" href="#c-13">13</a>
</span>) See, inter alia, judgments of 16 February 2012, SABAM (C‑360/10, EU:C:2012:85, paragraphs 42 to 44); of 29 July 2019, Funke Medien NRW (C‑469/17, EU:C:2019:623, paragraph 57); of 29 July 2019, Pelham and Others (C‑476/17, EU:C:2019:624, paragraph 32); and of 29 July 2019, Spiegel Online (C‑516/17, EU:C:2019:625, paragraph 42).</p>
<p class="note footnote">(<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="t-14" href="#c-14">14</a>
</span>) See, inter alia, judgments of 29 January 2008, Promusicae (C‑275/06, EU:C:2008:54, paragraphs 62 to 70); of 16 February 2012, SABAM (C‑360/10, EU:C:2012:85, paragraph 41); of 19 April 2012, Bonnier Audio and Others (C‑461/10, EU:C:2012:219, paragraph 56); of 3 September 2014, Deckmyn and Vrijheidsfonds (C‑201/13, EU:C:2014:2132, paragraph 26); and of 29 July 2019, Funke Medien NRW (C‑469/17, EU:C:2019:623, paragraph 72).</p>
<p class="note footnote">(<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="t-15" href="#c-15">15</a>
</span>) Judgment of 16 July 2015 (C‑580/13, EU:C:2015:485, paragraph 28).</p>
<p class="note footnote">(<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="t-16" href="#c-16">16</a>
</span>) Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council of 24 October 1995 on the protection of individuals with regard to the processing of personal data and on the free movement of such data (OJ 1995 L 281, p. 31). In accordance with Article 2(a) of that directive, ‘personal data’ is to mean any information relating to an identified or identifiable natural person.</p>
<p class="note footnote">(<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="t-17" href="#c-17">17</a>
</span>) Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council of 27 April 2016 on the protection of natural persons with regard to the processing of personal data and on the free movement of such data, and repealing Directive 95/46 (General Data Protection Regulation) (OJ 2016 L 119, p. 1).</p>
<p class="note footnote">(<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="t-18" href="#c-18">18</a>
</span>) The Court has already had occasion to hold that the IP address, even taken in isolation, may constitute personal data. See judgments of 24 November 2011, Scarlet Extended (C‑70/10, EU:C:2011:771, paragraph 51), and of 19 October 2016, Breyer (C‑582/14, EU:C:2016:779, paragraph 49).</p>
<p class="note footnote">(<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="t-19" href="#c-19">19</a>
</span>) Judgment of 16 July 2015, Coty Germany (C‑580/13, EU:C:2015:485, paragraphs 31 to 33).</p>
<p class="note footnote">(<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="t-20" href="#c-20">20</a>
</span>) See, by analogy, judgment of 15 September 2016, Mc Fadden (C‑484/14, EU:C:2016:689, paragraphs 69 to 71).</p>
<p class="note footnote">(<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="t-21" href="#c-21">21</a>
</span>) Agreement on trade-related aspects of intellectual property, which is contained in Annex 1C to the Agreement establishing the World Trade Organisation (WTO), signed in Marrakesh on 15 April 1994 and approved by Council Decision 94/800/EC of 22 December 1994 concerning the conclusion on behalf of the European Community, as regards matters within its competence, of the agreements reached in the Uruguay Round multilateral negotiations (1986-1994) (OJ 1994 L 336, p. 1, ‘the TRIPS Agreement’). In accordance with Article 47 of that agreement, entitled ‘Right of information’, ‘Members may provide that the judicial authorities shall have the authority, unless this would be out of proportion to the seriousness of the infringement, to order the infringer to inform the right holder of the identity of third persons involved in the production and distribution of the infringing goods or services and of their channels of distribution’.</p>
<p class="note footnote">(<span class="note footnote notemarker">
<a id="t-22" href="#c-22">22</a>
</span>) See, to the same effect, judgment of 29 January 2008, Promusicae (C‑275/06, EU:C:2008:54, paragraph 60). In any event, although it is true that EU legislation must, so far as possible, be interpreted in a manner that is consistent with international law, in particular where its provisions are intended specifically to give effect to an international agreement concluded by the European Union (see, inter alia, judgment of 7 December 2006, SGAE, C‑306/05, EU:C:2006:764, paragraph 35 and the case-law cited), Article 47 of the TRIPS Agreement cannot authorise the Court to disregard the clear wording of Article 8(2)(a) of Directive 2004/48.</p>
</body>
</html>
