|
Official Journal |
EN C series |
|
C/2026/5593 |
6.11.2026 |
COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION
of 29 October 2026
on operational continuity and stress testing guidelines for national contact points within the Union Civil Protection Mechanism
(C/2026/5593)
THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION,
Having regard to Decision No 1313/2013/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 17 December 2013 on a Union Civil Protection Mechanism (1), and in particular Article 7 thereof,
Whereas:
|
(1) |
Under Article 196(1), point (b), of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU), the Union is to promote swift, effective operational cooperation within the Union between national civil protection services. |
|
(2) |
The Union has a supporting competence in the field of civil protection, as stipulated in point (f) of Article 6 of the TFEU. |
|
(3) |
The Union Civil Protection Mechanism (UCPM), established by Decision No 1313/2013/EU, aims to strengthen cooperation between the Union and the Member States and facilitate coordination in the field of civil protection in order to improve the effectiveness of systems for preventing, preparing for and responding to natural and man-made disasters. |
|
(4) |
The Union has witnessed several highly disruptive events in recent years, notably the consequences of the COVID-19 pandemic, Russia’s war of aggression against Ukraine, the major IT disruption in 2024, Storm Éowyn in Ireland in January 2025, and the 2025 blackout in the Iberian Peninsula. Disruptive events may prevent or delay the functioning of civil protection systems, which should remain operational 24 hours a day and 7 days a week (‘24/7’). |
|
(5) |
Article 7 of Decision No 1313/2013/EU stipulates that the Emergency Response Coordination Centre (ERCC) shall ensure a 24/7 operational capacity and serve the Member States and the Commission in pursuit of the objectives of the UCPM. Article 3 of Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2025/704 (2) further specifies that each Member State is to designate a national contact point (NCP) for the ERCC that is available 24/7. |
|
(6) |
The Commission Recommendation of 8 February 2023 on Union disaster resilience goals (3) calls upon the ERCC and civil protection authorities in the Member States and UCPM participating States, within their respective mandates, to reinforce their business continuity planning capabilities. It also specifies that the UCPM ‘should support the conduct of stress tests to test business continuity of emergency operations centres and work with Member States on the follow-up of lessons learned and recommendations’. The stress testing of the emergency operation centres across Europe served as the flagship initiative of Goal number 5, titled ‘Ensuring a robust civil protection system’, as outlined in the Commission Communication on the European Union Disaster Resilience Goals (4). |
|
(7) |
Those efforts align with other frameworks that aim to strengthen resilience, including the European Preparedness Union Strategy (5) and NATO’s baseline requirements for national resilience (6). Specifically, Action 51 of the Strategy calls for the adoption of ‘guidelines for the “stress testing” of emergency response and crisis centres across the EU’. |
|
(8) |
In that context, it is necessary to focus on the operational continuity of the UCPM NCPs and to increase their resilience, so that they can remain operational during disruptive events, by reinforcing their operational continuity plans and practices through systematic evaluation and stress testing. |
|
(9) |
Moreover, response capacities that could be made available for intervention upon request through the UCPM may not belong to the NCP’s authority. Securing communication with the entities managing those capacities during disruptions is essential for the operational continuity of the UCPM. |
|
(10) |
Arrangements for ensuring continuity can easily go unnoticed until a disruption occurs. Such disruptions do not necessarily stem from major crisis or emergencies, but may result from minor incidents or from neglected or suboptimal conditions. To ensure informed decision-making on preventive and mitigation measures, the operational continuity planning for the NCP requires the identification of potential causes of disruptions affecting the NCP’s essential functions (7). Additionally, staff working in 24/7 shifts face unique psychosocial and wellbeing challenges, including health problems resulting from night shifts, work-related stress, and separation from family. If unaddressed, these issues can contribute to burnout, high turnover and potential staff shortages. |
|
(11) |
Operational continuity arrangements should remain effective regardless of the nature or cause of the disruption, whether resulting from natural hazards, accidents, technical failures, human error, infrastructure or utility outages, large-scale staff unavailability, intentional or malicious actions, including cyber incidents and hybrid activities, or any other cause. |
|
(12) |
By preparing for potential disruptions, NCPs increase their ability to respond swiftly and effectively, minimising the duration and impact of disruptive events. That preparation not only ensures that operations can restart within an acceptable timeframe but also limits negative consequences for stakeholders and external actors that depend on the NCP’s activity and safeguards the organisation’s mission and reputation. |
|
(13) |
Disruptions originating from cyber incidents have distinctive characteristics that deserve special attention; unlike other threats to operational continuity, they may be intentional, can propagate across interconnected systems, and may compromise the integrity or confidentiality of data and communications, not just their availability. |
|
(14) |
Regular training, exercises and updates are fundamental to an effective operational continuity programme. The more frequently an operational continuity plan is practiced, the better prepared the organisation becomes, as exercises help identify gaps and familiarise staff with procedures. Well-trained personnel, with a clear understanding of their roles and responsibilities, perform more effectively during disruptions. Similarly, involving stakeholders in exercises ensures that they understand communication protocols and know what to expect during real disruptive events. |
|
(15) |
Exercises, stress tests and real incidents provide valuable lessons. To ensure that the operational continuity plan remains valid, it should be regularly updated to incorporate lessons learned from training, exercises, stress tests, real events, and technological advancements. |
|
(16) |
Where the NCP is part of an entity that falls within the scope of applicable provisions of Directive (EU) 2022/2555 of the European Parliament and of the Council (8), the lessons learned from the stress test should be taken into account when implementing cybersecurity risk-management measures, in particular with regard to business continuity, backup management, disaster recovery, and crisis management. |
|
(17) |
Ensuring the operational continuity of the civil protection national competent authority goes beyond the functioning of its NCP. Therefore, this Recommendation may also serve as a valuable reference for the development of operational continuity within national organisations and civil protection systems, in accordance with recital 7 of Decision No 1313/2013/EU. |
|
(18) |
This Recommendation should be comprehensive, reflecting the diversity of NCP structures and functions across Member States and UCPM participating States. It should be applied flexibly and adapted to each NCP’s mandate, context, circumstances, and operational framework, given that each NCP has distinct characteristics, operates within a different legal framework, and faces different challenges, which may require tailored approaches to ensure operational continuity. |
|
(19) |
This Recommendation is based on the outcome of consultations with the Commission Expert Group on 24/7 Operational Continuity in Disruptive Events, established by the Commission in 2025, and should be complementary to existing well-established standards and guidelines related to business continuity (9), |
HAS ADOPTED THIS RECOMMENDATION:
1. ADDRESSEES
This Recommendation is addressed to national competent authorities of the Member States and UCPM participating States.
Member States may find it relevant for other national crisis centres and entities managing UCPM capacities.
2. DEFINITIONS
For the purposes of this Recommendation, the following definitions apply:
|
(a) |
‘national competent authority’ means an authority appointed by a Member State or a UCPM participating State (10) within the framework of the UCPM, as referred to in Article 29 of Decision No 1313/2013/EU; |
|
(b) |
‘national contact point’ (NCP) means a contact point for the ERCC in a Member State or in a UCPM participating State that is available 24 hours a day and 7 days a week, designated in accordance with Article 9(7) of Decision No 1313/2013/EU and Article 3(1) of Implementing Decision (EU) 2025/704; |
|
(c) |
‘essential functions’ means the activities, operations or services of the NCP that are fundamental to the fulfilment of its mandate and mission and either cannot be interrupted or must be resumed within a short, predefined timeframe. For the purposes of these guidelines, whether a function is classified as essential shall be determined by the urgency with which it must be restored following disruption, and not solely by its strategic, operational or institutional importance. Accordingly, functions of strategic, operational or institutional importance that can withstand disruption or extended delay without unacceptable impact shall not be regarded as essential functions; |
|
(d) |
‘essential staff’ means personnel working in the NCP who carry out or support essential functions, personnel who are part of the team responsible for managing or responding to a disruptive event, or personnel who fulfil both roles; |
|
(e) |
‘scarce essential staff’ means essential staff whose small number constitutes a vulnerability to operational continuity in the event of their absence or unavailability to work, because they possess the certifications, security clearance, authority, decision-making responsibility, access rights, knowledge, expertise or language skills required to carry out specific activities necessary to ensure the continuity of an essential function; |
|
(f) |
‘staff bottleneck’ means a situation in which the continuity of an essential function depends on the availability of one or more staff members of scarce essential staff; |
|
(g) |
‘operational continuity’ means the capacity of a NCP to maintain its essential functions working – encompassing activities, operations or services – when the resources necessary to those functions, such as essential staff, incoming information, services, products, supplies, budgetary provisions, equipment, information and communications technology (ICT) systems or location requirements, become unavailable, damaged, unusable or interrupted; |
|
(h) |
‘operational continuity plan’ or ‘plan’ means either a single document or a collection of procedures for the operational continuity of the NCP; |
|
(i) |
‘disruptive event’ means an incident or circumstance that prevents or substantially delays the execution of an essential function of the NCP; |
|
(j) |
‘recovery’ refers to the restoration of the NCP's operational capabilities, facilities, systems and resources following a disruption. |
3. RECOMMENDATIONS FOR OPERATIONAL CONTINUITY OF NCPS
3.1. Key recommendations
|
1. |
The NCP should develop a coherent and comprehensive operational continuity plan or a documented set of procedures covering all elements of operational continuity. Section 3.2 contains further recommendations on the operational continuity plan. |
|
2. |
The objective of operational continuity planning is to ensure that the NCP can fulfil its essential functions under degraded conditions when disruptive events occur. As such, operational continuity planning should assume that disruptive events will occur and that normal operating conditions may not be restored immediately or, in some cases, may not be restored at all. The NCP should be capable of maintaining essential functions under degraded conditions by using alternative procedures, alternative facilities, alternative communication channels and reduced resources until full capability is restored. |
|
3. |
During disruptive events, resources should be prioritised towards sustaining the essential functions of the NCP. This may imply that non-essential functions may not be maintained. |
|
4. |
Operational continuity arrangements should ensure the uninterrupted collection, analysis, validation and dissemination of the operational information necessary to maintain the NCP’s situational awareness and support decision-making throughout the disruption. |
|
5. |
Trained personnel are the main resource for ensuring operational continuity. While the operational continuity plan, associated arrangements and backup measures support continuity, it ultimately depends on staff being able to make decisions and apply these measures under pressure. |
|
6. |
Operational continuity planning should be based on a thorough understanding of the administrative and operational arrangements of the organisation to which the NCP belongs. To achieve this, collaboration across departments should be actively promoted and facilitated. |
|
7. |
The NCP should assess potential sources of disruptions to its activities. The focus of the assessment should be on their disruptive potential for the NCP’s activities and on developing a response plan to ensure continuity of essential functions. |
|
8. |
When assessing threats to operational continuity, special attention should be given to time-sensitive processes and bottlenecks, including:
|
|
9. |
Bottlenecks in staff, facilities, communications, ICT systems, logistics and decision-making should be identified and removed. Where unavoidable, appropriate prevention and mitigation measures should be established and tested, including those suggested in Section 3.9. |
|
10. |
Every disruption, exercise and stress test should identify lessons and lead to improvements in operational continuity arrangements, strengthening resilience over time. |
|
11. |
For the purpose of operational continuity and stress testing for NCPs within the UCPM, the following non-exhaustive categories of disruptive events should be considered. Annex I provides a description of each category.
|
|
12. |
The NCP should ensure its ability to continue operating in the event of one or more of the continuity triggers listed in paragraph 11 above. |
3.2. Operational continuity plan of the NCP
|
13. |
Each NCP should develop a coherent, comprehensive and written operational continuity plan, or an equivalent documented set of procedures, covering all elements of operational continuity and integrating and systematising the response to disruptions, including mitigation measures and agreements for immediate intervention. |
|
14. |
The operational continuity plan should provide alternative arrangements for all essential processes, especially time-sensitive ones, ensuring that they can continue if primary resources fail. Backup and alternative arrangements should be fully independent. They should not rely on the same resources, such as the same building, power source, communication route, ICT platform or service provider. They should also not create new dependencies that could introduce further risks of disruption. |
|
15. |
The operational continuity plan should be exercised regularly under realistic conditions. Plans that have not been validated through training, exercises or stress tests should not be considered operational. The operational continuity programme should include regular mandatory training for essential staff; regular testing and exercises involving the activation of the plan, and its systematic review and update, ensuring that all concerned staff and stakeholders are aware of and trained on the updates. |
|
16. |
Depending on the organisation’s structure, the NCP should involve in the development of the operational continuity plan personnel who are not directly involved in essential functions but who have the expertise or knowledge needed to support an overall understanding of the organisation’s functions. |
|
17. |
NCPs should consider designating, within their organisation, a continuity coordination function dedicated to the operational continuity plan. Depending on the size and structure of the NCP, the continuity coordination function should be exercised by a single coordinator, by a dedicated team bringing together representatives of the relevant operational areas, or through other arrangements adapted to the national context. Where a group is constituted, it should include members with expertise in the operational areas relevant to the implementation of the plan, such as ICT systems, alternative premises, human resources or logistics. The role of the continuity coordination function should be to ensure the consistent implementation, periodic review and updating of the operational continuity plan, including the verification of resources and arrangements on which the plan relies. |
3.3. Identification of essential functions
|
18. |
The NCP should identify its essential functions and establish and maintain an inventory of them. In addition to the UCPM-related functions, such as managing requests for assistance and offering and deploying UCPM response capacities, the NCP may also need to ensure continuity of other essential functions for the organisation. Examples include coordinating with national or regional authorities, liaising with other international organisations, issuing public warnings, and supporting higher-level decision-making.
For each essential function, the NCP should establish operational performance objectives defining the maximum acceptable degradation of services during disruptive events. Such objectives should include, where appropriate, the maximum tolerable period of disruption, recovery time objectives, acceptable loss of operational information, minimum staffing levels, communication availability and decision-making capability. These objectives should guide the design of the operational continuity plan and form the basis for evaluating stress tests performance. Annex II contains examples of operational performance objectives. |
|
19. |
It is advisable to rank essential functions according to their priority or the urgency with which they must be resumed. |
3.4. Business Process Analysis and backup resources
|
20. |
Based on the inventory of essential functions, the NCP should conduct a Business Process Analysis (BPA) and develop backup solutions to ensure continuity of its essential functions. The BPA should include a comprehensive understanding of how functions operate, by determining, for each function:
|
|
21. |
When conducting their Business Process Analysis, NCPs are invited to take into account the table in Annex III. |
3.5. Recommended practices for alternative facilities and equipment
|
22. |
The NCP should ensure its capacity to continue operating when its premises become temporarily inaccessible or unusable, including ensuring the availability of key equipment. |
|
23. |
Primary and alternative facilities and temporary solutions should be secure and have an appropriate classification level. This should be proportionate to the nature of the crises addressed and the sensitivity or classification of the information being handled. |
3.6. Recommended practices for electricity supply
|
24. |
The NCP should ensure its capacity to continue operating in the event of local outages or widespread blackouts. |
|
25. |
Primary and alternative facilities, including temporary facilities, should have electricity supply arrangements that are resilient and have backup systems, so that the NCP can continue to operate and provide its essential functions during long power outages. |
|
26. |
The measures set out for NCPs should be implemented, where relevant, in a manner that is consistent with national electricity risk-preparedness plans established under Regulation (EU) 2019/941 of the European Parliament and of the Council (11) and national preventive action plans and emergency plans established under the Security of Gas Supply Regulation (EU) 2017/1938 of the European Parliament and of the Council (12), as well as with existing national crisis-management arrangements. |
3.7. Recommended practices for ICT systems
|
27. |
The NCP should ensure that the ICT systems supporting its essential functions are reliable and resilient. Special attention should be placed on:
|
|
28. |
Particular attention should be given to cyber incidents as a distinct category of ICT disruption. The NCP should consider establishing coordination protocols with the national cybersecurity authority, as part of its broader operational continuity arrangements. Such measures should include early warning channels, joint incident response protocols, and the clarification of roles during a cyber incident affecting the NCP. |
3.8. Recommended practices for human resources
|
29. |
The NCP should ensure that it has sufficient personnel to remain operational in situations of reduced staff availability and that its personnel have the necessary profiles and skills. |
|
30. |
The NCP should consider the following:
|
|
31. |
Essential functions should be supported by appropriate operational continuity arrangements, structured and systematic cross-training, and regular exercises, so that they can be carried out by several trained personnel avoiding staff bottlenecks.. No single essential function should depend exclusively on the availability of one staff member. |
3.9. Prevention and mitigation measures for each category of disruptive event
|
32. |
The following section provides an indicative list of recommended prevention and mitigation measures for each category of disruptive event. While these can be implemented in parallel, each Member State should select the most appropriate and effective options based on its NCP’s mandate, context, circumstances, capacity, the structure of its operational and legal framework, and the potential causes of disruptions that could affect its NCP’s essential functions. The list is not meant to be applied in full simultaneously, as, in some cases, the implementation of one measure could conflict with the application of another measure or require excessive investment. |
|
33. |
Recommended prevention and mitigation measures to address unavailability of premises:
|
|
34. |
Recommended prevention and mitigation measures to address disruption of electricity supply:
|
|
35. |
Recommended prevention and mitigation measures to address disruption or failure of ICT systems:
|
|
36. |
Recommended prevention and mitigation measures to address large-scale staff absence and absence of scarce essential staff:
|
|
37. |
Annex IV provides technical guidance for the implementation of each of the measures listed. |
3.10. Continuity of operations in the case of UCPM activations
|
38. |
To enhance UCPM operations and ensure continuity, the following actions are recommended:
|
|
39. |
The operational continuity plan should be aligned with the Commission Recommendation of 29 November 2024 on EU Host Nation Support Guidelines (13), specifically regarding UCPM activations by the NCP and its role in host nation support (14). |
3.11. Activation of the operational continuity plan
|
40. |
Depending on the nature and scale of the disruption, the NCP operational continuity plan should define different activation levels, including a partial activation, where the NCP continues operating from its main premises under adapted procedures, and a full activation, which requires relocation to alternative premises or other alternative arrangements. |
|
41. |
The criteria, activation levels and triggers, as well as the authority empowered to authorise activation, should be defined at national level, in line with each NCP’s structure and operational framework. An illustrative example of an activation flow is provided in Annex V. |
|
42. |
Activation procedures should enable the timely activation of continuity arrangements in response to both actual and anticipated disruptions, including events occurring outside normal working hours and events for which advance warning is available. |
|
43. |
In the event that an incident disrupts the operational continuity of the NCP, triggering the activation of its operational continuity plan, the NCP should consider notifying the ERCC. |
3.12. Training, exercises and regular testing
|
44. |
Operational continuity plans should be regularly trained, exercised and tested. It is recommended to schedule regular awareness and information sessions as well as training sessions and exercises related to continuity plans. Other regular training, such as onboarding training for new personnel, should also incorporate the necessary elements of the operational continuity plan. The participation of external stakeholders who could be affected by a disruption in the NCP’s activities should also be considered in regular targeted awareness and information sessions, as well as in exercises. |
|
45. |
At a minimum, the operational continuity plan should be tested annually. More frequent testing should be considered where justified by the NCP's structure, operational context or risk profile. |
3.13. Recovery
|
46. |
Once the negative effects of the disruptive event have been mitigated, the NCP should treat the gradual return to normal operations as a distinct phase of operational continuity: recovery is the phase in which the NCP transitions from the operational continuity arrangements back to normal operations, including the resumption of important (but non-essential) functions that may have been temporarily suspended. |
|
47. |
The operational continuity plan should define the conditions for initiating recovery, identify the authority empowered to authorise the transition, and specify the steps required to return safely to normal operations. |
|
48. |
The following points should be considered in the recovery phase:
|
|
49. |
NCPs should also carry out the following activities:
|
3.14. Communication strategy
|
50. |
Efficient management of disruptive events involves communication, and each NCP should develop a solid communication strategy that acknowledges the NCP’s responsibilities for general communication and for crisis communication. This strategy should guide the NCP’s decisions and actions on information sharing during disruptions, ensuring that all involved or affected parties receive the necessary information and, where applicable, are able to act accordingly, thereby helping to protect the organisation’s reputation and maintain trust. Annex VI contains suggested points to be considered by the NCP when developing a solid communication strategy. |
4. RECOMMENDATIONS FOR ORGANISING AND CONDUCTING A STRESS TEST
|
51. |
The Commission recommends stress testing of NCPs in the UCPM. This section provides guidance on how to design and evaluate a stress test. |
4.1. Purpose and objectives
|
52. |
The purpose of the stress test should be to assess the capacity of the NCP to continue performing its essential functions under disruptive conditions. To that end, the stress test should take the form of a limited-scale exercise designed to evaluate existing arrangements for operational continuity and the performance of targeted essential functions of the NCP under disruptive conditions, including by testing both primary and alternative resources. |
|
53. |
The stress test should pursue the following general objectives:
|
|
54. |
When planning the stress test, it is recommended to formulate specific objectives for the stress test that are measurable and aligned with the essential functions to be tested. |
|
55. |
The stress test should not aim to identify threats that could trigger incidents capable of disrupting the normal functioning of the NCP. |
4.2. Scope
|
56. |
The scope of the stress test should identify the following:
|
4.3. Scenario
|
57. |
A scenario-based approach should cover the consequences of incidents (triggers) that may cause disruption of operations and therefore activate the operational continuity plan of the NCP. It is recommended to exercise different scenarios and vary their complexity, thereby preparing the organisation for a range of possible outcomes. It should be ensured that the scenarios are challenging but realistic, so as to provide meaningful insights into the effectiveness of the operational continuity plan. Annex VII provides two examples of scenarios. |
|
58. |
NCPs are recommended to use the following non-exhaustive list of triggers for the activation of the NCP operational continuity plan: unavailability of premises (1), disruption of electricity supply (2), disruption or failure of ICT systems (3) and large-scale staff absence and absence of scarce essential staff (4).
|
|
59. |
Stress tests should progressively combine several disruptive events to assess the NCP’s ability to maintain essential functions during cascading or compound disruptions that affect multiple resources at the same time. |
4.4. Participants
|
60. |
It is recommended to identify participants in accordance with the defined objectives, essential functions and scenario of the stress test. |
4.5. Evaluation, lessons identification and implementing improvements
|
61. |
When planning the stress test, it is advisable to establish an evaluation system. This helps identify gaps and areas for improvement in the operational continuity plan while assessing the overall success of the exercise. It also provides a basis for future planning and training on operational continuity of the NCP. |
|
62. |
It is recommended to systematise the evaluation format, after both real events and exercises or training activities, including stress tests. For the purpose of the stress test, NCPs are recommended to use the evaluation grid provided in Annex VIII. This evaluation grid suggests evaluating operational continuity from two complementary angles:
|
|
63. |
In addition, the table contained in Annex IX is intended to support NCPs in compiling the evaluation, identifying lessons and proposed improvements. Annex X contains a questionnaire template designed to gather feedback from participants. |
|
64. |
Member States and UCPM participating States are invited to share non-sensitive lessons learned and proposed improvements with the ERCC after conducting a stress test of their NCP. |
Done at Brussels, 29 October 2026.
For the Commission
Hadja LAHBIB
Member of the Commission
(1) OJ L 347, 20.12.2013, p. 924, ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/dec/2013/1313/oj.
(2) Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2025/704 of 10 April 2025 laying down rules for the implementation of Decision No 1313/2013/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council on a Union Civil Protection Mechanism and repealing Commission Implementing Decisions 2014/762/EU and (EU) 2019/1310 (OJ L, 2025/704, 15.4.2025, ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/dec_impl/2025/704/oj).
(4) Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions ‘European Union Disaster Resilience Goals: Acting together to deal with future emergencies’, 8.2.2023, COM(2023) 61 final.
(5) Joint Communication to the European Parliament, the European Council, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions on the European Preparedness Union Strategy, 26.3.2025, JOIN(2025) 130 final.
(6) Commitment to enhance resilience, issued by the Heads of State and Government participating in the meeting of the North Atlantic Council in Warsaw, 8-9 July 2016.
(7) Examples include software updates, uncommunicated changes to the corporate email domain, uncommunicated updates of contact details, persistent staff shortages, or the simultaneous retirement of a large portion of essential staff, whose replacement cannot begin until the retirement date.
(8) Directive (EU) 2022/2555 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 14 December 2022 on measures for a high common level of cybersecurity across the Union, amending Regulation (EU) No 910/2014 and Directive (EU) 2018/1972, and repealing Directive (EU) 2016/1148 (NIS 2 Directive) (OJ L 333, 27.12.2022, p. 80, ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/dir/2022/2555/oj).
(9) International standards: ISO 22301:2019 (Business Continuity Management Systems); FEMA’s Federal Continuity Directive 1 (2017), Federal Continuity Directive 2 (2017), Continuity Guidance Circular (2018, 2024 update), Business Process Analysis and Business Impact Analysis User Guide (2019); and the Good Practice Guidelines (2018) from the Business Continuity Institute.
(10) On participating States, see Article 28 of Decision No 1313/2013/EU.
(11) Regulation (EU) 2019/941 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 5 June 2019 on risk-preparedness in the electricity sector and repealing Directive 2005/89/EC (OJ L 158, 14.6.2019, p. 1, ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/reg/2019/941/oj).
(12) Regulation (EU) 2017/1938 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 25 October 2017 concerning measures to safeguard the security of gas supply and repealing Regulation (EU) No 994/2010 (OJ L 280, 28.10.2017, p. 1, ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/reg/2017/1938/oj).
(13) C(2024) 8339.
(14) Host nation support is defined in Article 4, point (9), of Decision No 1313/2013/EU as any action undertaken in the preparedness and response phases by the country receiving or sending assistance, or by the Commission, to remove foreseeable obstacles to international assistance offered through the Union Mechanism. It includes support from Member States to facilitate the transit of this assistance through their territory.
ANNEX I
Categories of disruptive events
Four different categories of disruptive events can be identified for the purpose of operational continuity and stress testing for NCPs within the UCPM:
|
— |
Unavailability of premises: The premises of the NCP can no longer be used due to a physical or operational incident that prevents or severely limits access to the building or its use, either temporarily or permanently. Examples also include blocked key access routes, physical damage to nearby buildings, and failures or problems affecting utilities and installations, such as water, heating, ventilation or security systems (1). Such incidents may also disrupt the normal activity of the NCP by forcing evacuation of the premises, preventing access to them, or rendering them unusable. |
|
— |
Disruption of electricity supply: A power failure that affects the NCP’s premises. A long-lasting failure of power supply may lead to a fuel-supply incident for backup generators. It may also have an impact on electricity-dependent systems, including ICT systems. |
|
— |
Disruption or failure of ICT systems: the software or applications of the NCP are unable to operate effectively. Such a failure may take various forms, such as loss of access due to authentication issues, severe performance degradation, data corruption or unavailability, failure of interfaces with external systems, or disruption following updates or a cybersecurity incident, including cases such as illegitimate personification of a NCP main system, leading to the dissemination of manipulated information by the NCP. |
|
— |
Large scale staff absence or absence of scarce essential staff: a significant number of essential staff are unable to reach the premises or are otherwise unable to work. The situation is aggravated when essential functions depend on a single individual or a small group of scarce essential staff, whose unplanned absence or unavailability causes disruption. |
These four categories provide a framework for understanding the measures required to mitigate disruptions. However, disruptive events can also be triggered by other incidents, such as a sudden influx of information that exceeds the NCP's capacity to manage it, or the spread of false information that requires NCP resources for verification and dissemination of accurate information.
Furthermore, disruptive incidents can be interconnected, and a single event may affect several areas at the same time. For example, a fire may render the premises inaccessible while also causing a power outage and damaging ICT systems and data. They may also result from intentional or malicious actions, including cyber incidents and hybrid activities, and from several concurrent incidents, intensifying their overall impact. As a result, NCPs need to develop a comprehensive response plan that addresses each category individually, considers their combined effects, and prepares for the possibility of simultaneous disruptions to ensure the continuity of their operations.
(1) Disruption of electricity supply and disruption or failure of ICT systems are considered different categories.
ANNEX II
Examples of operational performance objectives
|
Capability |
Indicative operational objective (to be assessed and adapted to national requirements) |
|
Initial situational awareness |
within 15 minutes |
|
Activation of continuity arrangements |
within 30 minutes |
|
Alternative communications established |
within 30 minutes |
|
Alternative command location operational |
within 2 hours |
|
Decision support capability |
uninterrupted whenever possible |
|
Fuel autonomy |
minimum 72 hours |
|
Food and water autonomy |
minimum 72 hours |
|
CECIS operational |
within 60 minutes |
|
First operational situation report to the ERCC |
within the first operational reporting cycle |
ANNEX III
Table to support the Business Process Analysis
|
Essential function 1 |
Name of this function. |
|
Description |
Include a description of this function, including the tasks it comprises. |
|
Inputs |
List the inputs (information, datasets, services, products, supplies, budgetary provisions, equipment, ICT systems and location requirements) necessary to complete this function and the external entities providing them, when applicable. |
|
Output |
List the information, product(s), service(s), or action(s) that result from this function and identify the (external) organisation(s), entity(ies) or concerned group(s) that receive them. |
|
Leadership (validation or authorisation) |
List the positions with a validation or authorisation role necessary to complete this function, if applicable. |
|
Essential staff |
List the positions of essential staff, and their profile, expertise and training, if applicable, such as security clearance. |
|
Facility |
List the physical location(s) or premises from which the essential function is performed. |
|
Equipment and systems |
List the equipment, systems and provisions necessary to complete this function. These could include secure premises, computers for encrypted communications, videowalls, high-level meeting rooms, equipment for videoconferencing, and computers with access to the Trans European Services for Telematics between Administrations (TESTA), etc. |
|
Essential records |
List the data and information needed to accomplish the function. |
|
Dependencies and interdependencies |
List the relationships or arrangements among the items identified above and specify, where relevant, the nature of the relationship or arrangement, the essential services needed (e.g. power supply, ICT, etc.), the impact in case of service or supply disruption, and the agreements with the entities that provide these services or supplies. The assessment should also describe interdependencies, including cascading effects where disruption of one service (for example electricity or ICT) affects other services and thereby amplifies the operational impact. |
|
Backups |
List the alternative resources or arrangements that would be activated to continue operating if the main resources or arrangements were affected by the disruptive event. |
ANNEX IV
Guidance for the application of mitigation and prevention measures
This section provides guidance for the application of mitigation and prevention measures, arranged by category of disruptive event. To avoid repetition, measures that are applicable to several different disruptive event categories are detailed only once in the first applicable category.
|
— |
Unavailability of premises:
|
|
— |
Disruption of electricity supply:
|
|
— |
Disruption or failure of ICT systems:
|
|
— |
Large-scale staff absence and absence of scarce essential staff:
|
ANNEX V
Operational reference tools
This Annex provides an operational reference tool that NCPs should consider using when developing or reviewing their operational continuity plan.
Illustrative activation flow
The flow below is an example of how the activation of an operational continuity plan can be organised, from the moment a potential disruption is detected until the NCP enters a stable continuity phase. It is structured around decision points, not prescribed timeframes.
ANNEX VI
Key points to address when drafting a communication strategy (1)
|
— |
Identify the different audience groups, under the organisation’s communication responsibility, that could potentially be impacted by the disruption of the NCP’s operations or would need to be informed in case the organisation suffers a disruptive event, including:
|
|
— |
For each audience group, define the purpose of the communication in the event of a disruptive event. Each group could require a different type, format, and content of information. The communication channel(s) used could also differ. |
|
— |
Draft pre-established messages that are clear, concise and consistent across recipients, channels and over time. Ensure that they are tailored to the audience group they target, addressing their specific information needs. |
|
— |
Identify alternative communication channels for each audience group to ensure effective communication if the disruption impacts standard channels. |
|
— |
Consider proactive information as a better approach to reactive information. |
|
— |
Where the communication strategy includes the possibility of disseminating messages through public TV and radio, coordinate the timing of these messages with news broadcasts to ensure effective integration and wide distribution among the population. |
|
— |
Within the communication strategy, consider pre-assigning the role of information manager to a certain position, specifying its tasks before, during and after a disruptive event. |
(1) These suggested items for the drafting of a communication strategy do not take into account the management of mis- or disinformation.
ANNEX VII
Examples of scenarios
|
Example of scenario 1 What: power failure followed by data loss. Where: the power failure affects the area where the NCP’s main premises are located. Duration: 24 hours. Description: repair works in the vicinity of the premises of the NCP have caused damage to the electricity distribution system. The sudden loss of power has caused damage to the NCP’s computer systems, resulting in data loss. Power restoration works are expected to last 24 hours. The ICT failure lasts for 24 hours. |
|
Example of scenario 2 What: inaccessibility of premises due to long-lasting snow. Where: the whole area where the premises are located is affected. Duration: over a week. Description: A major snowstorm has hit the area where the NCP premises are located, leaving them inaccessible by road and public transport. The snowfall is so extensive that snowploughs are not sufficient to clear all main roads during the first 24 hours, with priority given to hospital access. The population has been requested to stay off the streets. For at least 48 hours, access by public transport or private vehicle to the NCP facilities is not possible. The cold wave continues in the area for over a week and snow on smaller roads persists for one week. As a result, one third of the staff scheduled to work in the following days cannot make it into work for one week because their place of residence is remote and smaller roads are the last to be cleared. Additionally, essential staff on duty on the day of the snowfall are stranded in the premises for the first 48 hours. Around one third have already reached the maximum number of hours they are permitted to work that week, and a further third will reach that limit within 24 hours. Consequently, they are legally entitled to adequate rest. They also require support for basic needs (food, personal hygiene), and, in some cases, measures to support their families, and/or evacuation. |
ANNEX VIII
Stress test proposed evaluation framework
The outcome of the stress test should be assessed against two separate but complementary dimensions:
|
— |
Compliance with the operational continuity plan. This dimension should assess the extent to which the NCP implemented the applicable operational continuity arrangements during the stress test, including decision-making structures for activation, escalation, and recovery, internal and external coordination and communication, relocation arrangements and use of backup resources. |
|
— |
Maintenance of essential functions and fulfilment of predefined measurable operational performance objectives. This dimension should assess whether the NCP essential functions were maintained or restarted within acceptable predefined limits, whether there were negative effects on other non-essential functions of the NCP, and whether the stress test achieved the predefined measurable performance objectives. Examples of operational performance objectives are provided in Annex II. |
The two dimensions should be assessed separately in order to identify more precisely which improvements are needed. This distinction helps to ensure that compliance with the operational continuity plan is assessed separately from the effectiveness of the operational outcome. The evaluation report should present the result as two complementary scores: one reflecting compliance with the operational continuity plan, and the other reflecting the maintenance of essential functions and the fulfilment of predefined measurable operational performance objectives.
Evaluation grid for assessing compliance with the operational continuity plan.
|
Rating (0-3) |
Description |
||
|
The exercise showed little or no alignment with the operational continuity arrangements. Core procedures were absent, incorrectly executed, or ignored. |
||
|
Some points of the continuity arrangements were applied, but other important points were not followed correctly, were applied too late, or proved inadequate in practice. The test revealed substantial weaknesses and important opportunities for improvement in the plan. |
||
|
The stress test was implemented broadly in accordance with the operational continuity plan. Deviations from the plan were limited. The test revealed some weaknesses and opportunities for improvement in the plan. |
||
|
The operational continuity plan was followed in full during the stress test. |
Evaluation grid for assessing maintenance of essential functions and fulfilment of predefined measurable operational performance objectives.
|
Rating (0-3) |
Description |
||
|
The NCP essential functions were suspended or delayed beyond acceptable predefined limits. Other non-essential functions of the NCP were significantly and negatively affected. The predefined measurable performance objectives were not achieved. |
||
|
One or more essential functions were restored only after a substantial delay exceeding acceptable limits. The stress test may also have caused relevant disruption or negatively affected other functions of the NCP. The predefined measurable performance objectives were achieved only partially or with major challenges. |
||
|
Essential functions were maintained or restored within acceptable tolerance margins (with predefined acceptable limits exceeded by a limited time) without significant impact on other NCP functions. The predefined measurable performance objectives were largely achieved, and only minor deviations from the established limits were observed. |
||
|
The essential functions covered by the stress test were maintained or restored without delays exceeding the predefined acceptable limits and without negative impact on other NCP functions. The predefined measurable performance objectives were fully achieved. |
ANNEX IX
Stress Test’s evaluation, lesson identification and proposed improvements (1)
In the evaluation process, it is advisable to identify strategies for improving the areas that were inadequately addressed during the stress test exercise. Additionally, NCPs should consider incorporating successful items that emerged during the exercise but are not included in the current operational continuity plan.
The following table is meant to facilitate the compilation and alignment of the evaluation, the identification of lessons and proposed improvements after conducting a stress test.
|
Compliance with the operational continuity plan. |
Rating (0-3): … Description... |
|
Maintenance of essential functions and fulfilment of predefined measurable operational performance objectives. |
Rating (0-3): … Description... |
|
Findings and comments |
… |
|
Gaps and lessons identified |
… |
|
Proposed improvements |
… |
|
Actions needed for implementation |
… |
(1) This evaluation table is based on the Continuity Resource Toolkit developed by US Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) to support communities and local authorities/organisations in developing operational continuity programmes and has been adapted to the stress test exercise.
ANNEX X
Participant’s feedback form
The following questionnaire is recommended as a template for gathering feedback from stress test participants. The questions should be tailored to the specific scope and focus of the stress test. Collecting responses to these or similar questions from stress test participants, observers or personnel involved in real disruptive events can help identify lessons and gaps, which can then be used to update the NCP's operational continuity plan.
Activation of the operational continuity plan:
|
— |
Were established protocols followed? |
|
— |
If not, what were the reasons for the deviation, and was it due to an error/problem or a positive/optimising adjustment? |
|
— |
How efficiently were the protocols executed? |
|
— |
What challenges were encountered? |
|
— |
Was communication clear and effective during the activation? |
|
— |
Were all essential personnel notified and mobilised in a timely manner? |
Operational resumption, continuity and essential function performance:
|
— |
What was the time taken to resume the essential functions you are responsible for? |
|
— |
Were all essential functions delivered efficiently and within expected timeframes? Assess the quality of outputs delivered under test conditions. |
|
— |
Were there any noted delays or inefficiencies in performing these functions? |
|
— |
Was prioritisation of any essential functions necessary during the exercise? |
|
— |
How was prioritisation decided and communicated? |
|
— |
Was the prioritisation effective in ensuring continuity and effectiveness? |
Equipment and ICT Systems:
|
— |
Was all necessary backup equipment available and fully operational? |
|
— |
Were electricity supply backup systems tested and fully functional? |
|
— |
Were backup communication tools and channels tested and fully functional? |
|
— |
Were other essential services and supplies available, tested and fully operational? |
|
— |
Were any delays or inefficiencies caused by ICT systems identified? |
|
— |
How effectively were issues solved? |
Alternative facilities:
|
— |
Is the alternative location adequate in size, layout and equipment to allow you to work for a long time (several days)? If not, why and what could be done to improve it? |
Communication and coordination:
|
— |
Were all participants, including the hierarchy and relevant teams or colleagues, adequately informed? |
|
— |
Were internal communication and coordination effectively maintained throughout the exercise, including with hierarchy? |
|
— |
Were communication and coordination with the ERCC effectively maintained throughout the exercise? |
|
— |
If applicable, how effective was communication with the ERCC from the backup location? |
|
— |
How was information exchanged and documented during the relocation or disruption? |
Staff training and well-being:
|
— |
Do you think that you were well-prepared for the exercise based on pre-exercise operational continuity training? |
|
— |
Were you well informed about the exercise once it began? |
|
— |
Was there clarity in roles during the exercise? |
|
— |
Was the exercise useful for staff training purposes? |
|
— |
Were your personal and family needs considered, for example your need for transportation, rest, water or food? |
Other general observations:
|
— |
What aspects of the exercise were most successful? |
|
— |
What were the main challenges encountered? |
|
— |
Did the exercise meet its objectives? |
|
— |
Based on the experience during the exercise, how do you assess the capacity of the NCP to continue operating under the conditions of this exercise for 1 week? |
|
— |
Identify possible additional resources or support needed for a similar disruptive event lasting longer than the exercise. |
|
— |
Identify improvements for future training and exercises. |
ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/C/2026/5593/oj
ISSN 1977-091X (electronic edition)