<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<!DOCTYPE A_Doc_Ref SYSTEM "ARR.dtd">
<A_Doc_Ref A_Langue="en" A_Version_doc="4.0" A_Debut_ID="EN62015-0651">
   <Properties>
      <Property name="Gendoc_User">bartnsa</Property>
      <Property name="Gendoc_GenerationDate">03/07/2017 20:03:24</Property>
      <Property name="Created">GenDoc 03/07/2017 18:03:24</Property>
      <Property name="Gendoc_GendocTemplateType">ARR_C</Property>
      <Property name="TypeDoc">ARR</Property>
      <Property name="Gendoc_Juridiction">C</Property>
      <Property name="Juridiction">C</Property>
      <Property name="Gendoc_CaseNumber">0651</Property>
      <Property name="NumeroOrdre">0651</Property>
      <Property name="Gendoc_CaseYear">2015</Property>
      <Property name="Annee">2015</Property>
      <Property name="Gendoc_CaseNature">PV</Property>
      <Property name="NatureAff">PV</Property>
      <Property name="Gendoc_CaseNumberSuite">0001</Property>
      <Property name="NumSuite">0001</Property>
      <Property name="Gendoc_ProcedureType">P</Property>
      <Property name="TypeProc">P</Property>
      <Property name="Gendoc_ProcedureNumber">1</Property>
      <Property name="NumProc">1</Property>
      <Property name="Gendoc_EditionType">Final</Property>
      <Property name="Gendoc_LastVerificationDate">12/07/2017 11:15:16</Property>
      <Property name="Gendoc_LastVerificationStatus">COMPLETE_document_go_green</Property>
      <Property name="Canevas3_Vademecum">0</Property>
      <Property name="ReadyToPublish">OK</Property>
      <Property name="Generation_In_Progress">false</Property>
      <Property name="EP_Version">0</Property>
      <Property name="EP_Mode">1</Property>
      <Property name="DocumentIdentifier">07e0b2682752478b8e3349aafc8afe0f</Property>
      <Property name="SdlIdentifier">ImportedWithoutSource</Property>
      <Property name="Gendoc_DGTGenerated">True</Property>
      <Property name="Gendoc_DGTGeneratedDate">03/07/2017 22:03:36</Property>
      <Property name="Gendoc_DGTGeneratedUser">bartnsa</Property>
      <Property name="Gendoc_Lang">en-GB</Property>
      <Property name="Gendoc_LangCode">en</Property>
      <Property name="Langue">EN</Property>
      <Property name="Gendoc_Vademecum">2016</Property>
      <Property name="IsFlattened">True</Property>
      <Property name="WithoutAuthorBlock">TRUE</Property>
      <Property name="WithoutAuthorBlockFlatP">TRUE</Property>
      <Property name="CreateCustomParts">False</Property>
      <Property name="GenDocUID">FkkiYLtbinme3/fSrei1EfBNnflHSgeEjQTvqi/4Tp2rz26ggwOeojjn1IrVkVWo0ldHnEKsWZEVXr3O2LLyv3Qe/Isf0bI0/QTIDtxhXG3nkwPuXPBG6hTwZ1lPaZ5tseUyrfodnaiNDGhgWkgBjDgWyWufDu4R6itWChWrFPs=</Property>
      <Property name="Filename">2017-07-0000-00-aut-en-arr-c-0651-2015</Property>
      <Property name="QuotationMark_Open">(</Property>
      <Property name="QuotationMark_Close">)</Property>
      <Property name="serveur_nom">Doc2XML_2003 PUB</Property>
      <Property name="serveur_config_path">C:\Documents and Settings\gti_prod\Application Data\Doc2XML\PR_Doc2XML_2003_PUB.xml</Property>
      <Property name="watch">R:\flux_Publication\conversion\doc2xml_in\</Property>
   </Properties>
   <A_Header_Gauche>
      <blockquote id="A010000000">
         <para style="header" id="A150000000">
            <emphasis role="sm_caps" id="A400000000">JUDGMENT OF 13. 7. 2017 — Case C‑651/15 P</emphasis>
         </para>
      </blockquote>
   </A_Header_Gauche>
   <A_Header_Droit>
      <blockquote id="A010000001">
         <para style="header" id="A150000001">
            <emphasis role="sm_caps" id="A400000001">VECCO AND OTHERS v COMMISSION </emphasis>
         </para>
      </blockquote>
   </A_Header_Droit>
   <A_Footer_Gauche>
      <blockquote id="A010000002">
         <para style="footer" id="A150000002">20<emphasis role="tab" id="A400000002"/>
         </para>
      </blockquote>
   </A_Footer_Gauche>
   <A_Footer_Droit>
      <blockquote id="A010000003">
         <para style="footer" id="A150000003">21</para>
      </blockquote>
   </A_Footer_Droit>
   <Affaire>
      <Introduction>
         <section id="A000000000">
            <para style="19Centre" id="A150000004">JUDGMENT OF THE COURT (Sixth Chamber)</para>
            <para style="19Centre" id="A150000005">13 July 2017 <footnote role="fNote" id="A110000000">
                  <number>*</number>
                  <para style="42FootnoteLangue" id="A150000006">
                     <emphasis role="suprscpt" id="A400000003">* </emphasis>Language of the case: English</para>
               </footnote>
            </para>
            <para style="71Indicateur" id="A150000007">
               <phrase role="QuotationMark_Open" id="A410000000">(</phrase>
               <phrase role="motcle" id="A410000001">Appeal </phrase>
               <phrase role="Separator" id="A410000002">—</phrase>
               <phrase role="motcle" id="A410000003"> Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006 (REACH) </phrase>
               <phrase role="Separator" id="A410000004">—</phrase>
               <phrase role="motcle" id="A410000005"> Article 58(2) </phrase>
               <phrase role="Separator" id="A410000006">—</phrase>
               <phrase role="motcle" id="A410000007"> Authorisation </phrase>
               <phrase role="Separator" id="A410000008">—</phrase>
               <phrase role="motcle" id="A410000009"> Substances of very high concern </phrase>
               <phrase role="Separator" id="A410000010">—</phrase>
               <phrase role="motcle" id="A410000011"> Exemption </phrase>
               <phrase role="Separator" id="A410000012">—</phrase>
               <phrase role="motcle" id="A410000013"> Regulation amending Annex XIV to Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006 </phrase>
               <phrase role="Separator" id="A410000014">—</phrase>
               <phrase role="motcle" id="A410000015"> Inclusion of chromium trioxide in the list of substances subject to authorisation</phrase>
               <phrase role="QuotationMark_Close" id="A410000016">)</phrase>
            </para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000008">In Case C‑651/15 P,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000009">APPEAL under Article 56 of the Statute of the Court of Justice of the European Union, brought on 4 December 2015,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000010">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="A400000004">Verein zur Wahrung von Einsatz und Nutzung von Chromtrioxid und anderen Chrom-VI-Verbindungen in der Oberflächentechnik eV (VECCO) and Others,</emphasis> represented by C. Mereu, avocat, and J. Beck, Solicitor, </para>
            <para style="72Alineadroite" id="A150000011">appellants,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000012">the other parties to the proceedings being:</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000013">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="A400000005">European Commission,</emphasis> represented by K. Mifsud-Bonnici and K. Talabér-Ritz, acting as Agents,</para>
            <para style="72Alineadroite" id="A150000014">defendant at first instance,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000015">supported by</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000016">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="A400000006">French Republic,</emphasis> represented by D. Colas and J. Traband, acting as Agents,</para>
            <para style="72Alineadroite" id="A150000017">intervener in the appeal,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000018">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="A400000007">European Chemicals Agency (ECHA),</emphasis> represented by W. Broere and M. Heikkilä, acting as Agents,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000019">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="A400000008">Assogalvanica and Others,</emphasis> represented by C. Mereu, avocat, and J. Beck, solicitor, </para>
            <para style="72Alineadroite" id="A150000020">interveners at first instance,</para>
            <para style="19Centre" id="A150000021">THE COURT (Sixth Chamber),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000022">composed of E. Regan, President of the Chamber, C.G. Fernlund (Rapporteur) and S. Rodin, Judges,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000023">Advocate General: E. Sharpston,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000024">Registrar: A. Calot Escobar,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000025">having regard to the written procedure,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000026">having decided, after hearing the Advocate General, to proceed to judgment without an Opinion,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000027">gives the following</para>
         </section>
      </Introduction>
      <A_Motif>
         <section id="B000000000">
            <para style="75Debutdesmotifs" id="B150000000">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="B400000000">Judgment</emphasis>
            </para>
            <blockquote id="B010000000">
               <title id="B210000000">
                  <number>1</number>
               </title>
               <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000001">By their appeal, Verein zur Wahrung von Einsatz und Nutzung von Chromtrioxid und anderen Chrom-VI-Verbindungen in der Oberflächentechnik eV (VECCO) and the 185 other appellants whose names are listed in Annex I to the present judgment (collectively, ‘VECCO and Others’) seek to have set aside the judgment of the General Court of the European Union of 25 September 2015, <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000001">VECCO and Others </emphasis>v<emphasis role="italc" id="B400000002"> Commission</emphasis> (T‑360/13, ‘the judgment under appeal’, EU:T:2015:695) by which that court dismissed their action for partial annulment of Commission Regulation (EU) No 348/2013 of 17 April 2013 amending Annex XIV to Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006 of the European Parliament and of the Council on the Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and Restriction of Chemicals (REACH) (OJ 2013 L 108, p. 1).</para>
            </blockquote>
            <section id="B000000001">
               <title style="04Titre1" id="B200000000">
                  <number/>
                  <titlecontent id="B300000000">
                     <emphasis role="bold" id="B400000003">Legal context</emphasis>
                  </titlecontent>
               </title>
               <blockquote id="B010000001">
                  <title id="B210000001">
                     <number>2</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000002">Paragraph 1 of Article 1 of Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 18 December 2006 concerning the Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and Restriction of Chemicals (REACH), establishing a European Chemicals Agency, amending Directive 1999/45/EC and repealing Council Regulation (EEC) No 793/93 and Commission Regulation (EC) No 1488/94 as well as Council Directive 76/769/EEC and Commission Directives 91/155/EEC, 93/67/EEC, 93/105/EC and 2000/21/EC (OJ 2006 L 396, p. 1, and corrigendum OJ 2007 L 136, p. 3), as amended by Regulation (EC) No 1272/2008 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 December 2008 (OJ 2008 L 353, p. 1) (‘the REACH Regulation’), entitled ‘Aim and scope’, provides:</para>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="B150000003">‘The purpose of this Regulation is to ensure a high level of protection of human health and the environment, including the promotion of alternative methods for assessment of hazards of substances, as well as the free circulation of substances on the internal market while enhancing competitiveness and innovation.’ </para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000002">
                  <title id="B210000002">
                     <number>3</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000004">As set out in Article 55 of the REACH Regulation:</para>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="B150000005">‘The aim of this Title is to ensure the good functioning of the internal market while assuring that the risks from substances of very high concern are properly controlled and that these substances are progressively replaced by suitable alternative substances or technologies where these are economically and technically viable. To this end all manufacturers, importers and downstream users applying for authorisations shall analyse the availability of alternatives and consider their risks, and the technical and economic feasibility of substitution.’ </para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000003">
                  <title id="B210000003">
                     <number>4</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000006">Article 57 of the REACH Regulation sets out the criteria for inclusion of substances in Annex XIV to that regulation. </para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000004">
                  <title id="B210000004">
                     <number>5</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000007">Article 58 of the REACH Regulation provides:</para>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="B150000008">‘1.<emphasis role="tab" id="B400000004"/>Whenever a decision is taken to include in Annex XIV substances referred to in Article 57, such a decision shall be taken in accordance with the procedure referred to in Article 133(4). It shall specify for each substance:</para>
                  <blockquote id="B010000005">
                     <para style="09Marge0avecretrait" id="B150000009">(a)<emphasis role="tab" id="B400000005"/>the identity of the substance as specified in Section 2 of Annex VI;</para>
                  </blockquote>
                  <blockquote id="B010000006">
                     <para style="09Marge0avecretrait" id="B150000010">(b)<emphasis role="tab" id="B400000006"/>the intrinsic property (properties) of the substance referred to in Article 57;</para>
                  </blockquote>
                  <blockquote id="B010000007">
                     <para style="09Marge0avecretrait" id="B150000011">...</para>
                  </blockquote>
                  <blockquote id="B010000008">
                     <para style="09Marge0avecretrait" id="B150000012">(d)<emphasis role="tab" id="B400000007"/>review periods for certain uses, if appropriate;</para>
                  </blockquote>
                  <blockquote id="B010000009">
                     <para style="09Marge0avecretrait" id="B150000013">(e)<emphasis role="tab" id="B400000008"/>uses or categories of uses exempted from the authorisation requirement, if any, and conditions for such exemptions, if any.</para>
                  </blockquote>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="B150000014">2. <emphasis role="tab" id="B400000009"/>Uses or categories of uses may be exempted from the authorisation requirement provided that, on the basis of the existing specific Community legislation imposing minimum requirements relating to the protection of human health or the environment for the use of the substance, the risk is properly controlled. In the establishment of such exemptions, account shall be taken, in particular, of the proportionality of risk to human health and the environment related to the nature of the substance, such as where the risk is modified by the physical form.</para>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="B150000015">…’ </para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000010">
                  <title id="B210000005">
                     <number>6</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000016">Articles 60 to 64 of the REACH Regulation concern the granting of authorisations.</para>
               </blockquote>
            </section>
            <section id="B000000002">
               <title style="04Titre1" id="B200000001">
                  <number/>
                  <titlecontent id="B300000001">
                     <emphasis role="bold" id="B400000010">Background to the dispute</emphasis>
                  </titlecontent>
               </title>
               <blockquote id="B010000011">
                  <title id="B210000006">
                     <number>7</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000017">It is apparent from paragraphs 1 to 9 of the judgment under appeal that, by means of Regulation No 348/2013, chromium trioxide was included in Annex XIV to the REACH Regulation without any exemptions under Article 58(2) of that regulation being granted for certain uses or categories of uses of that substance.</para>
               </blockquote>
            </section>
            <section id="B000000003">
               <title style="04Titre1" id="B200000002">
                  <number/>
                  <titlecontent id="B300000002">
                     <emphasis role="bold" id="B400000011">The procedure before the General Court and the judgment under appeal</emphasis>
                  </titlecontent>
               </title>
               <blockquote id="B010000012">
                  <title id="B210000007">
                     <number>8</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000018">On 8 July 2013, VECCO and Others brought an action for the annulment of Regulation No 348/2013. By the judgment under appeal, the General Court dismissed the action and ordered VECCO and Others to pay the costs.</para>
               </blockquote>
            </section>
            <section id="B000000004">
               <title style="04Titre1" id="B200000003">
                  <number/>
                  <titlecontent id="B300000003">
                     <emphasis role="bold" id="B400000012">Forms of order sought by the parties before the Court of Justice</emphasis>
                  </titlecontent>
               </title>
               <blockquote id="B010000013">
                  <title id="B210000008">
                     <number>9</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000019">VECCO and Others are asking the Court of Justice to set aside the judgment under appeal and rule on the merits of their action or to refer the case back to the General Court for final judgment. </para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000014">
                  <title id="B210000009">
                     <number>10</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000020">The European Commission contends that the Court should dismiss the appeal and order VECCO and Others to pay the costs. </para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000015">
                  <title id="B210000010">
                     <number>11</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000021">The French Republic, which was granted leave to intervene in support of the Commission, and the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA), which intervened at first instance in support of the form of order sought by the Commission, request the Court to dismiss the appeal.</para>
               </blockquote>
            </section>
            <section id="B000000005">
               <title style="04Titre1" id="B200000004">
                  <number/>
                  <titlecontent id="B300000004">
                     <emphasis role="bold" id="B400000013">The appeal</emphasis>
                  </titlecontent>
               </title>
               <blockquote id="B010000016">
                  <title id="B210000011">
                     <number>12</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000022">VECCO and Others rely on three grounds in support of their appeal. The first and second grounds allege infringement of Article 58(2) of the REACH Regulation. The third ground alleges an error of assessment. The second and third grounds of appeal are submitted as subsidiary grounds in the event that the first ground of appeal is upheld.</para>
               </blockquote>
               <section id="B000000006">
                  <title style="05Titre2" id="B200000005">
                     <number/>
                     <titlecontent id="B300000005">
                        <emphasis role="bold" id="B400000014">
                           <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000015">First ground of appeal, alleging infringement of Article 58(2) of the REACH Regulation</emphasis>
                        </emphasis>
                     </titlecontent>
                  </title>
                  <section id="B000000007">
                     <title style="06Titre3" id="B200000006">
                        <number/>
                        <titlecontent id="B300000006">
                           <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000016">Arguments of the parties</emphasis>
                        </titlecontent>
                     </title>
                     <blockquote id="B010000017">
                        <title id="B210000012">
                           <number>13</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000023">The first ground of appeal is directed against paragraphs 28 to 53 of the judgment under appeal, in which the General Court held that neither Council Directive 98/24/EC of 7 April 1998 on the protection of the health and safety of workers from the risks related to chemical agents at work (fourteenth individual Directive within the meaning of Article 16(1) of Directive 89/391/EEC) (OJ 1998 L 131, p. 11) nor Directive 2004/37/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 29 April 2004 on the protection of workers from the risks related to exposure to carcinogens or mutagens at work (sixth individual Directive within the meaning of Article 16(1) of Council Directive 89/391/EEC) (OJ 2004 L 158, p. 50) constitutes ‘specific Community legislation imposing minimum requirements’ within the meaning of Article 58(2) of the REACH Regulation. VECCO and Others claim that the General Court misinterpreted that provision. </para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000018">
                        <title id="B210000013">
                           <number>14</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000024">The appellants claim that, in paragraphs 40 to 44 and 50 to 53 of the judgment under appeal, the General Court erred in law by restricting the scope of the exemption laid down in Article 58(2) of the REACH Regulation solely to secondary legislation which relates to particular substances explicitly named. </para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000019">
                        <title id="B210000014">
                           <number>15</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000025">According to VECCO and Others, the exemption set out in Article 58(2) of the REACH Regulation does not apply to substances per se, but rather to their uses or categories of uses. Accordingly, it is not necessary for the legislation in question to specifically name the relevant substances. In that regard, VECCO and Others note that ECHA has acknowledged, in a document entitled ‘Preparation of draft Annex XIV entries for the third recommendation of substances to be included in Annex XIV — General Approach’ that uses falling within the exemption include, inter alia, the hazard classification category of a substance (as a carcinogen, mutagen or reproductive toxicant). Contrary to what was held by the General Court in paragraph 41 of the judgment under appeal, the appellants claim that that interpretation would not be liable seriously to jeopardise the purpose and functioning of the REACH Regulation. </para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000020">
                        <title id="B210000015">
                           <number>16</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000026">VECCO and Others maintain that the purpose of Article 58(2) of the REACH Regulation requires a preliminary consideration as to whether existing EU legislation is sufficient to ensure the risks are properly controlled. The three criteria laid down in that provision, requiring ‘specific Community legislation’ imposing ‘minimum requirements’ to ensure ‘the risk is properly controlled’, should therefore be assessed together, in the light of that objective, rather than being assessed in isolation, as done by the General Court. </para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000021">
                        <title id="B210000016">
                           <number>17</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000027">According to VECCO and Others, on a proper construction of Article 58(2) of the REACH Regulation, the General Court should have, first, examined whether Directives 98/24 and 2004/37 were ‘specific’ to the use of chromium trioxide in the surface treatment and electropolishing industry, secondly, if that had been found to be the case, have determined whether that existing legislation imposed ‘minimum requirements’ and, thirdly, have verified whether those minimum requirements were sufficient to properly control the risks involved.</para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000022">
                        <title id="B210000017">
                           <number>18</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000028">As regards the first criterion under Article 58(2) of the REACH Regulation, relating to the existence of ‘specific’ EU legislation, VECCO and Others consider it satisfied, given that the uses or categories of uses for which an exemption has been requested, namely, surface coating and electropolishing processes using chromium trioxide, fall within the uses contemplated by Directive 98/24 and, on account of that substance being classified as a carcinogen, by Directive 2004/37.</para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000023">
                        <title id="B210000018">
                           <number>19</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000029">As regards the second criterion of Article 58(2) of the REACH Regulation, VECCO and Others consider that the General Court appropriately outlined, in paragraphs 37 and 43 of the judgment under appeal, the ‘minimum requirements’ laid down by Directives 98/24 and 2004/37. However, they maintain that that court failed to assess <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000017">in concreto</emphasis> whether those requirements ensured proper control of the risk to workers in the surface treatment and electropolishing industry.</para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000024">
                        <title id="B210000019">
                           <number>20</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000030">The appellants claim that the General Court was wrong to find, in paragraph 40 of the judgment under appeal, that Directive 98/24 lays down only a general framework of the duties imposed on employers who expose their employees to chemical risks. They assert that the General Court also held, in paragraph 44 of the judgment under appeal, that since Directive 98/24 does not lay down a maximum occupational exposure limit for the substance at issue, that directive cannot be considered to impose ‘minimum requirements’, within the meaning of Article 58(2) of the REACH Regulation.</para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000025">
                        <title id="B210000020">
                           <number>21</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000031">VECCO and Others maintain that the setting of maximum occupational exposure limits is neither the best nor the only method of managing chemical risks. The lack of such maximum limits for chromium trioxide is not sufficient for it to be concluded that those directives do not impose ‘minimum requirements’, within the meaning of Article 58(2) of the REACH Regulation. </para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000026">
                        <title id="B210000021">
                           <number>22</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000032">As regards the criterion concerning the proper control of risks, VECCO and Others take issue with paragraph 64 of the judgment under appeal, by which the General Court held that it was impossible to assess whether that criterion had been satisfied, because of the lack of specific Community legislation imposing minimum requirements. The appellants claim that that ‘superficial’ interpretation misconstrued, in law, the overall objective of Article 58(2) of the REACH Regulation and failed to have regard, in fact, to the evidence adduced as a whole, which sought to demonstrate that the risk to workers in the surface treatment and electropolishing industry stemming from the use of chromium trioxide is properly controlled by existing EU legislation. </para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000027">
                        <title id="B210000022">
                           <number>23</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000033">The Commission disputes the interpretation proposed by VECCO and Others to the effect that Article 58(2) of the REACH Regulation applies to uses and not to substances. It agrees with the reasoning of the General Court in finding that it was not necessary to examine the uses covered by Directives 98/24 and 2004/37, since those directives are not specific to chromium trioxide.</para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000028">
                        <title id="B210000023">
                           <number>24</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000034">ECHA supports the arguments of the Commission. It maintains that the legislature has not provided for an automatic exemption from authorisation for all uses covered by Directives 98/24 and 2004/37.</para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000029">
                        <title id="B210000024">
                           <number>25</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000035">The French Republic takes the same point of view and considers that Directives 98/24 and 2004/37 are not specific Community legislation imposing minimum requirements relating to the protection of human health or the environment for the use of the substance within the meaning of Article 58(2) of the REACH Regulation.</para>
                     </blockquote>
                  </section>
                  <section id="B000000008">
                     <title style="06Titre3" id="B200000007">
                        <number/>
                        <titlecontent id="B300000007">
                           <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000018">Findings of the Court</emphasis>
                        </titlecontent>
                     </title>
                     <blockquote id="B010000030">
                        <title id="B210000025">
                           <number>26</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000036">In order to address the first ground of appeal, it is necessary to bear in mind the context in which the exemption laid down in Article 58(2) of the REACH Regulation applies.</para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000031">
                        <title id="B210000026">
                           <number>27</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000037">In that regard, Article 1(1) of the REACH Regulation states that the purpose of the regulation is to ensure a high level of protection of human health and the environment, including the promotion of alternative methods for assessment of hazards of substances, as well as the free circulation of substances on the internal market while enhancing competitiveness and innovation. To that end, that regulation introduces an integrated system for monitoring chemical substances, including registration, evaluation and authorisation, together with possible restrictions on their use (see, inter alia, judgment of 15 March 2017, <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000019">Polynt </emphasis>v<emphasis role="italc" id="B400000020"> ECHA</emphasis>, C‑323/15 P, EU:C:2017:207, paragraph 20).</para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000032">
                        <title id="B210000027">
                           <number>28</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000038">As made clear, inter alia, in recitals 69 and 70 of the REACH Regulation, that regulation makes substances ‘of very high concern’ subject to careful attention. Those substances are thus subject to the authorisation scheme laid down in Title VII of that regulation. Article 55 of that regulation states that the objective of the authorisation scheme is ‘to ensure the good functioning of the internal market while assuring that the risks from substances of very high concern are properly controlled and that these substances are progressively replaced by suitable alternative substances or technologies where these are economically and technically viable’ (see, inter alia, judgment of 15 March 2017, <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000021">Polynt </emphasis>v<emphasis role="italc" id="B400000022"> ECHA</emphasis>, C‑323/15 P, EU:C:2017:207, paragraph 21).</para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000033">
                        <title id="B210000028">
                           <number>29</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000039">The first stage under that authorisation scheme is the procedure for identifying substances of very high concern on the basis of the criteria set out in Article 57 of the REACH Regulation. The second stage is the inclusion of those substances on the list of substances subject to authorisation set out in Annex XIV to that regulation, and the third and final stage concerns the procedure that leads, if appropriate, to the authorisation of a substance of very high concern (see, inter alia, judgment of 15 March 2017, <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000023">Polynt </emphasis>v<emphasis role="italc" id="B400000024"> ECHA</emphasis>, C‑323/15 P, EU:C:2017:207, paragraph 22).</para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000034">
                        <title id="B210000029">
                           <number>30</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000040">In order to ensure coherence between the authorisation scheme laid down in Title VII of the REACH Regulation and other EU legal provisions aimed at protecting human health and the environment from risks arising from the use of chemical substances, Article 58(2) of that regulation allows for the exemption of certain uses or categories of uses from the authorisation requirement ‘provided that, on the basis of the existing specific Community legislation imposing minimum requirements relating to the protection of human health or the environment for the use of the substance, the risk is properly controlled’. </para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000035">
                        <title id="B210000030">
                           <number>31</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000041">It is clear from that provision that certain uses or categories of uses of a substance of very high concern may be exempted from the authorisation requirement if two conditions are satisfied. Those conditions require, first, that there be ‘existing specific Community legislation imposing minimum requirements relating to the protection of human health or the environment for the use of the substance’ and, secondly, that, on the basis of that legislation, ‘the risk [be] properly controlled’. It is also apparent from the clear wording of that provision that those conditions are cumulative, which means that, as the General Court essentially held in paragraphs 32 and 64 of the judgment under appeal, it is sufficient that only one of those conditions is not satisfied for the exemption to have to be refused.</para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000036">
                        <title id="B210000031">
                           <number>32</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000042">Moreover, a restrictive interpretation of that provision is necessary precisely because it constitutes an exception.</para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000037">
                        <title id="B210000032">
                           <number>33</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000043">As regards the question whether Directives 98/24 and 2004/37 satisfy the first of those conditions, it is necessary to determine whether those directives can be regarded as specific legislation imposing minimum requirements relating to the protection of human health or the environment for the use of the substance. </para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000038">
                        <title id="B210000033">
                           <number>34</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000044">In accordance with settled case-law, the meaning and scope of the term ‘specific legislation’, for which the REACH Regulation provides no definition, must be determined by considering its usual meaning in everyday language, while also taking into account the context in which it occurs and the purposes of the rules of which it is part (see, by analogy, judgment of 24 June 2015,<emphasis role="italc" id="B400000025"> Hotel Sava Rogaška</emphasis>, C‑207/14, EU:C:2015:414, paragraph 25 and the case-law cited).</para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000039">
                        <title id="B210000034">
                           <number>35</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000045">In everyday language, the usual meaning of the adjective ‘specific’ denotes that which is distinctive of a particular subset and distinguishes it from other subsets, thus it can be regarded as the opposite of ‘general’. In accordance with its usual meaning, the term ‘specific legislation’ used in Article 58(2) of the REACH Regulation must be interpreted as referring, at the very least, to any directive or regulation laying down rules particular to the substance concerned. That term is to be understood as contrasting with legislation governing either a group of substances or categories of uses, which are defined generally and abstractly.</para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000040">
                        <title id="B210000035">
                           <number>36</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000046">VECCO and Others nonetheless maintain that the exemption laid down in Article 58(2) of the REACH Regulation applies to uses or categories of uses and not to substances. Consequently, they claim that in order to determine whether that exemption is applicable, rather than assessing whether the substance in question is expressly mentioned in the legislation at issue, it is necessary to assess whether that legislation makes it possible, in practice, properly to control the risks associated with the uses or categories of uses considered for that substance. Thus the appellants submit that the General Court erred in law by holding that Directives 98/24 and 2004/37 do not constitute specific legislation imposing minimum requirements on the ground that those directives do not expressly mention chromium trioxide.</para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000041">
                        <title id="B210000036">
                           <number>37</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000047">In that regard, although the first sentence of Article 58(2) of the REACH Regulation refers not to the notion of ‘substance’ but only to the notion of ‘uses or categories of uses’, the fact remains that the exemption mechanism implies an inextricable link between a substance and its uses or categories of uses.</para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000042">
                        <title id="B210000037">
                           <number>38</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000048">The objective of the REACH Regulation is to regulate substances, as is apparent from its title and its general scheme. The authorisation scheme referred to in Title VII more specifically covers substances which, on account of their intrinsic properties, are considered to be of very high concern and, accordingly, must ultimately be replaced.</para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000043">
                        <title id="B210000038">
                           <number>39</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000049">As is apparent from Article 55 of that regulation, those substances may be placed on the market only on the basis of an authorisation which ensures that the risks posed by their use are properly controlled. It is for that reason that the grant of an authorisation under Article 60 of the REACH Regulation is preceded by a risk assessment carried out under the conditions laid down in Article 64 of that regulation. </para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000044">
                        <title id="B210000039">
                           <number>40</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000050">Furthermore, the decision to include a substance in Annex XIV of the REACH Regulation must, in accordance with Article 58(1)(e) of that regulation, state in particular the uses or categories of uses exempted from the authorisation requirement, if any, and the conditions for such exemptions, if any.</para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000045">
                        <title id="B210000040">
                           <number>41</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000051">Moreover, as the General Court correctly stated, in essence, in paragraphs 41 and 44 of the judgment under appeal, the interpretation of Article 58(2) of the REACH Regulation put forward by VECCO and Others would mean, in particular, that any substance in carcinogenicity category 1 or 2 would be exempted from the obligation to obtain authorisation for occupational uses, on the ground that Directive 2004/37 governs such use for all carcinogenic substances. Such an interpretation is incompatible with both the wording and purpose of the authorisation scheme under Title VII of the REACH Regulation with regard to substances of very high concern, such as substances in carcinogenicity category 1 or 2.</para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000046">
                        <title id="B210000041">
                           <number>42</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000052">Therefore, in the present case, having correctly held that Directives 98/24 and 2004/37 contain no provisions specific to chromium trioxide imposing minimum requirements relating to the protection of human health or the environment for the use of the substance, the General Court did not err in law in finding, on the grounds set out in paragraphs 37 to 45 of the judgment under appeal, that those directives do not constitute ‘specific legislation’ within the meaning of Article 58(2) of the REACH Regulation. Consequently, the General Court was fully entitled to conclude, at paragraph 63 of the judgment under appeal, that the first of the two conditions laid down by that provision was not satisfied and, accordingly, that Court was justified in rejecting, in paragraph 66 of the judgment under appeal, the plea alleging infringement of Article 58(2) of the REACH Regulation.</para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000047">
                        <title id="B210000042">
                           <number>43</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000053">It follows that the first ground of appeal must, for that reason alone, be rejected as unfounded.</para>
                     </blockquote>
                     <blockquote id="B010000048">
                        <title id="B210000043">
                           <number>44</number>
                        </title>
                        <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000054">The second and third grounds of appeal were submitted as subsidiary grounds in the event that the first ground of appeal was upheld. Since the first ground has been rejected, the second and third grounds of appeal must be dismissed as ineffective.</para>
                     </blockquote>
                  </section>
               </section>
            </section>
            <section id="B000000009">
               <title style="04Titre1" id="B200000008">
                  <number/>
                  <titlecontent id="B300000008">
                     <emphasis role="bold" id="B400000026">Costs</emphasis>
                  </titlecontent>
               </title>
               <blockquote id="B010000049">
                  <title id="B210000044">
                     <number>45</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000055">Under Article 184(2) of the Rules of Procedure of the Court of Justice, where the appeal is unfounded the Court is to make a decision as to costs. Under Article 138(1) of those Rules of Procedure, applicable to appeal proceedings by virtue of Article 184(1) thereof, the unsuccessful party is to be ordered to pay the costs if they have been applied for in the successful party’s pleadings.</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000050">
                  <title id="B210000045">
                     <number>46</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000056">Article 140(1) of the Rules of Procedure, which applies to the procedure on appeal by virtue of Article 184(1) thereof, provides that the Member States and institutions which have intervened in the proceedings are to bear their own costs.</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000051">
                  <title id="B210000046">
                     <number>47</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000057">Under Article 184(4) of those Rules of Procedure, the Court of Justice may decide that an intervener at first instance who has taken part in the written or oral part of the proceedings before the Court is to bear his own costs.</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000052">
                  <title id="B210000047">
                     <number>48</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000058">Since the Commission has applied for costs to be awarded against VECCO and Others and the latter have been unsuccessful, VECCO and Others must be ordered to bear their own costs and to pay those incurred by the Commission.</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000053">
                  <title id="B210000048">
                     <number>49</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000059">The French Republic, as intervener in the appeal, shall bear its own costs.</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000054">
                  <title id="B210000049">
                     <number>50</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000060">ECHA, as an intervener at first instance, shall bear its own costs.</para>
               </blockquote>
            </section>
         </section>
      </A_Motif>
      <Dispositif>
         <section id="D000000000">
            <para style="41DispositifIntroduction" id="D150000000">On those grounds, the Court (Sixth Chamber) hereby:</para>
            <orderedlist id="D020000000">
               <listitem id="D060000000">
                  <blockquote id="D010000000">
                     <title id="D210000000">
                        <number>1.</number>
                     </title>
                     <para style="08Dispositif" id="D150000001">
                        <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000000">Dismisses the appeal;</emphasis>
                     </para>
                  </blockquote>
               </listitem>
               <listitem id="D060000001">
                  <blockquote id="D010000001">
                     <title id="D210000001">
                        <number>2.</number>
                     </title>
                     <para style="08Dispositif" id="D150000002">
                        <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000001">Orders Verein zur Wahrung von Einsatz und Nutzung von Chromtrioxid und anderen Chrom-VI-Verbindungen in der Oberflächentechnik eV (VECCO) and the other applicants whose names are listed in Annex I to the present judgment to bear their own costs and to pay those incurred by the European Commission;</emphasis>
                     </para>
                  </blockquote>
               </listitem>
               <listitem id="D060000002">
                  <blockquote id="D010000002">
                     <title id="D210000002">
                        <number>3.</number>
                     </title>
                     <para style="08Dispositif" id="D150000003">
                        <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000002">Orders the French Republic and the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) to bear their own costs.</emphasis>
                     </para>
                  </blockquote>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000004"/>
                  <para style="77SignaturesComposition" id="D150000005">Regan<emphasis role="tab" id="D400000003"/>Fernlund<emphasis role="tab" id="D400000004"/>Rodin</para>
                  <para style="77SignaturesAlinea" id="D150000006">     </para>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000007">Delivered in open court in Luxembourg on 13 July 2017.</para>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000008"/>
               </listitem>
            </orderedlist>
         </section>
      </Dispositif>
      <A_Signatures>
         <section id="D000000001">
<para style="77Signatures" id="D150000009">A. Calot Escobar <emphasis role="tab" id="D400000005"/>
               <emphasis role="tab" id="D400000006"/>E. Regan</para>
<para style="77Signatures" id="D150000010">Registrar <emphasis role="tab" id="D400000007"/>
               <emphasis role="tab" id="D400000008"/>President of the Sixth Chamber</para>

<para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000011">
               <emphasis role="pagebreak" id="D400000009"/>
            </para>
            <para style="73Alineacentregras" id="D150000012">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000010">ANNEX I</emphasis>
            </para>
            <para style="73Alineacentregras" id="D150000013">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000011">List of appellants</emphasis>
            </para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000014">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000012">Verein zur Wahrung von Einsatz und Nutzung von Chromtrioxid und anderen Chrom-VI-Verbindungen in der Oberflächentechnik eV (VECCO), </emphasis>established in Memmingen (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000015">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000013">Adolf Krämer GmbH &amp; Co. KG, </emphasis>established in Ulm (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000016">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000014">AgO Argentum GmbH Oberflächenveredelung,</emphasis> established in Nuremberg (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000017">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000015">Alfred Kruse GmbH Metallveredelungen,</emphasis> established in Langenfeld (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000018">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000016">AL-Oberflächenveredelungsgesellschaft mbH, </emphasis>established in Wuppertal (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000019">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000017">Anke GmbH &amp; Co. KG Oberflächentechnik,</emphasis> established in Essen (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000020">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000018">ATC Armoloy Technology Coatings GmbH &amp; Co. KG,</emphasis> established in Mosbach (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000021">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000019">August Schröder GmbH &amp; Co. KG Oberflächenveredelung, </emphasis>established in Hemer (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000022">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000020">August Sure KG, </emphasis>established in Lüdenscheid (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000023">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000021">Baaske Oberflächenveredelung GmbH, </emphasis>established in Wuppertal,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000024">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000022">Hartchrom Beck GmbH, </emphasis>established in Güglingen (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000025">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000023">Bredt GmbH, </emphasis>established in Meschede (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000026">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000024">Breidert Galvanic GmbH,</emphasis> established in Darmstadt (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000027">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000025">Chrom-Müller Metallveredelung GmbH,</emphasis> established in Oberndorf am Neckar (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000028">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000026">Chrom-Schmitt GmbH &amp; Co. KG,</emphasis> established in Baden-Baden (Germany), </para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000029">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000027">C. Hübner GmbH, </emphasis>established in Marktoberdorf (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000030">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000028"> C.W. Albert GmbH &amp; Co. KG, </emphasis>established in Hemer-Bredenbruch (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000031">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000029">Detlef Bingen GmbH,</emphasis> established in Langenfeld,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000032">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000030">Dittes Oberflächentechnik GmbH,</emphasis> established in Keltern (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000033">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000031">Duralloy Süd GmbH,</emphasis> established in Villingen-Schwenningen (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000034">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000032">Durochrom-Bogatzki, </emphasis>established in Oberndorf am Neckar,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000035">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000033">Metallveredelung Emil Weiß GmbH &amp; Co. KG, </emphasis>established in Mitwitz (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000036">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000034">Ewald Siodla Metallveredelungsgesellschaft mbH,</emphasis> established in Witten (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000037">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000035">Flügel CSS GmbH &amp; Co. KG, </emphasis>established in Solingen (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000038">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000036">Fritz Zehnle Galvanische Anstalt, Inh. Gerd Joos eK</emphasis>, established in Triberg (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000039">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000037">Galvanoform Gesellschaft für Galvanoplastik mbH, </emphasis>established in Lahr (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000040">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000038">Galvano Herbert Geske eK, </emphasis>established in Solingen,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000041">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000039">Galvanotechnik Friedrich Holst GmbH,</emphasis> established in Hamburg (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000042">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000040">Galvano Weis, Weis GmbH &amp; Co., Galvanische Werkstätte KG, </emphasis>established in Emmering (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000043">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000041">gebr. böge Metallveredelungs GmbH,</emphasis> established in Hamburg,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000044">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000042">Hans Giesbert GmbH &amp; Co. KG,</emphasis> established in Mömbris (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000045">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000043">Groz-Beckert KG,</emphasis> established in Albstadt (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000046">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000044">GTW GmbH,</emphasis> established in Werl (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000047">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000045">GWC Coating GmbH, </emphasis>established in Villingen-Schwenningen,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000048">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000046">Hartchrom Beuthel GmbH,</emphasis> established in Schwelm (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000049">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000047">Hartchrom Erb GmbH,</emphasis> established in Weiterstadt (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000050">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000048">Hartchrom GmbH,</emphasis> established in Karlsruhe (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000051">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000049">Hartchrom GmbH Werner Kreuz, </emphasis>established in Blumberg (Germany), </para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000052">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000050">Hartchrom Schoch GmbH, </emphasis>established in Sternenfels (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000053">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000051">Hartchrom Teikuro Automotive GmbH,</emphasis> established in Sternenfels,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000054">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000052">Heine Optotechnik GmbH &amp; Co. KG,</emphasis> established in Herrsching (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000055">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000053">Heinrich Schnarr GmbH Metallveredlungswerk,</emphasis> established in Mainaschaff (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000056">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000054">Heinrich Schulte Söhne GmbH &amp; Co. KG, </emphasis>established in Arnsberg (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000057">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000055">Heinz Daurer und Söhne GmbH &amp; Co. KG Metall-Veredelung-Lampertheim, </emphasis>established in Lampertheim (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000058">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000056">Helmut Gossmann Metallveredelungs-GmbH, </emphasis>established in Goldbach (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000059">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000057">Henry Gevekoth GmbH, </emphasis>established in Hamburg,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000060">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000058">Heyer GmbH Oberflächentechnik, </emphasis>established in Lübeck (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000061">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000059">HFJ Galvano Kiel GmbH,</emphasis> established in Kiel (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000062">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000060">Hueck Engraving GmbH &amp; Co. KG,</emphasis> established in Viersen (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000063">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000061">Imhof Hartchrom GmbH, </emphasis>established in Karlstadt (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000064">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000062">Johannes Jander GmbH &amp; Co. KG Metalloberflächenveredelung, </emphasis>established in Iserlohn (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000065">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000063">Johann Maffei GmbH &amp; Co. KG,</emphasis> established in Iserlohn-Simmern (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000066">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000064">Kesseböhmer Beschlagsysteme GmbH &amp; Co. KG, </emphasis>established in Bad Essen (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000067">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000065">Knipex-Werk C. Gustav Putsch KG,</emphasis> established in Wuppertal,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000068">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000066">Kreft &amp; Röhrig GmbH, </emphasis>established in Troisdorf-Friedrich-Wilhelms Hütte (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000069">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000067">Kriebel Metallveredelung GmbH, </emphasis>established in Kirschfurt (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000070">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000068">LKS Kronenberger GmbH Metallveredlungswerk,</emphasis> established in Seligenstadt (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000071">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000069">Kunststofftechnik Bernt GmbH,</emphasis> established in Kaufbeuren (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000072">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000070">L B — Oberflächentechnik GmbH, </emphasis>established in Wuppertal,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000073">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000071">Linder Metallveredelungsgesellschaft mbH,</emphasis> established in Albstadt (Germany), </para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000074">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000072">Metallisierwerk Peter Schreiber GmbH, </emphasis>established in Düsseldorf (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000075">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000073">Montanhydraulik GmbH, </emphasis>established in Holzwickede (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000076">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000074">Morex SpA, </emphasis>established in Crespano del Grappa (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000077">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000075">Motoren-Sauer Instandsetzungs-GmbH,</emphasis> established in Hösbach (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000078">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000076">MSC/Copperflow Ltd,</emphasis> established in Bolton, Greater Manchester (United Kingdom),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000079">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000077">Neumeister Hydraulik GmbH,</emphasis> established in Neuenstadt am Kocher (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000080">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000078">Nießer Metallveredelung GmbH,</emphasis> established in Röthenbach an der Pegnitz (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000081">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000079">Norddeutsche Hartchrom GmbH &amp; Co. KG,</emphasis> established in Ganderkesee (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000082">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000080">Oberflächenzentrum Elz GmbH, </emphasis>established in Limburg (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000083">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000081">OK Oberflächenveredelung GmbH &amp; Co. KG, </emphasis>established in Sundern (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000084">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000082">OTH Oberflächentechnik Hagen GmbH &amp; Co. KG, </emphasis>established in Hagen (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000085">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000083">OT Oberflächentechnik GmbH &amp; Co. KG,</emphasis> established in Schwerin (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000086">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000084">Präzisionsgalvanik GmbH Wolfen, </emphasis>established in Bitterfeld-Wolfen (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000087">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000085">Rahrbach GmbH, </emphasis>established in Heiligenhaus (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000088">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000086">Rudolf Clauss GmbH &amp; Co. KG Metallveredlung, </emphasis>established in Mülheim an der Ruhr (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000089">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000087">Rudolf Jatzke Galvanik-Hartchrom Günter Holthöfer GmbH &amp; Co. KG, </emphasis>established in Bielefeld (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000090">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000088">Schaeffler Technologies AG &amp; Co. KG, </emphasis>established in Herzogenaurach (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000091">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000089">Scherer GmbH,</emphasis> established in Haslach im Kinzigtal (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000092">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000090">Schmitz Hydraulikzylinder GmbH, </emphasis>established in Büttelborn (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000093">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000091">Schnarr Metallveredlung GmbH,</emphasis> established in Waiblingen (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000094">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000092">Schornberg Galvanik GmbH,</emphasis> established in Lippstadt (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000095">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000093">Robert Schrubstock GmbH &amp; Co. KG,</emphasis> established in Velbert (Germany), </para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000096">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000094">Schulte Hartchrom GmbH, </emphasis>established in Arnsberg,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000097">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000095">Schwing GmbH, </emphasis>established in Sankt Stefan im Lavanttal (Austria),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000098">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000096">Silit-Werke GmbH &amp; Co. KG,</emphasis> established in Riedlingen (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000099">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000097">Steinbach &amp; Vollmann GmbH &amp; Co. KG, </emphasis>established in Heiligenhaus,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000100">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000098">Strötzel Oberflächentechnik GmbH &amp; Co. KG,</emphasis> established in Hildesheim (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000101">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000099">Süss Oberflächentechnik GmbH, </emphasis>established in Wetzlar (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000102">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000100">Thoma Metallveredelung GmbH,</emphasis> established in Heimertingen (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000103">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000101">Viemetall Viersener Metallveredlung Pottel GmbH &amp; Co. KG, </emphasis>established in Viersen (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000104">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000102">Walzen-Service-Center GmbH, </emphasis>established in Oberhausen (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000105">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000103">Wavec GmbH, </emphasis>established in Eisenhüttenstadt (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000106">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000104">Wilhelm Bauer GmbH &amp; Co. KG,</emphasis> established in Hanovre (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000107">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000105">Willy Remscheid Galvanische Anstalt GmbH,</emphasis> established in Solingen,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000108">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000106">Willy Remscheid Kunststofftechnik GmbH,</emphasis> established in Velbert,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000109">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000107">Wiotec, Inhaber Udo Wilmes eK, </emphasis>established in Ense (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000110">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000108">Wissing Hartchrom GmbH, </emphasis>established in Lohmar (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000111">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000109">alfi GmbH Isoliergefäße, Metall- und Haushaltswaren, </emphasis>established in Wertheim (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000112">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000110">BIA Kunststoff- und Galvanotechnik GmbH &amp; Co. KG,</emphasis> established in Solingen,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000113">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000111">Siegfried Boner eK,</emphasis> established in Villingen-Schwenningen,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000114">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000112">Bruchmühlbacher Galvanotechnik (BG) GmbH,</emphasis> established in Bruchmühlbach-Miesau (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000115">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000113">C + C Krug GmbH, </emphasis>established in Velbert,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000116">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000114">Collini GmbH, </emphasis>established in Aperg (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000117">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000115">Collini Gesellschaft mbH, </emphasis>established in Hohenems (Austria),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000118">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000116">Collini GmbH, </emphasis>established in Marchtrenk (Austria), </para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000119">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000117">ColliniWien GmbH, </emphasis>established in Vienna (Austria),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000120">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000118">Federal-Mogul TP Europe GmbH &amp; Co KG,</emphasis> established in Burscheid (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000121">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000119">Fischer GmbH &amp; Co. surface technologies KG, </emphasis>established in Katzenelnbogen (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000122">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000120">Friederici Oberflächenveredlung GmbH,</emphasis> established in Iserlohn,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000123">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000121">Galvano Wittenstein GmbH, </emphasis>established in Solingen,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000124">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000122">Gedore-Werkzeugfabrik GmbH &amp; Co. KG, </emphasis>established in Remscheid (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000125">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000123">Gerhardi Kunststofftechnik GmbH,</emphasis> established in Lüdenscheid,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000126">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000124">Gosma — Werkzeugfabrik und Metallveredelung Weber GmbH, </emphasis>established in Gosheim (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000127">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000125">Hartchrom-Meuter Ernst Meuter GmbH &amp; Co. KG, </emphasis>established in Solingen,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000128">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000126">Hartchrom Spezialbeschichtung Winter GmbH, </emphasis>established in Treuen (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000129">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000127">Hasler AG, Aluminiumveredlung, </emphasis>established in Turgi (Switzerland),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000130">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000128">Hartchrom Haslinger Oberflächentechnik GmbH, </emphasis>established in Linz (Austria),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000131">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000129">Hentschel Harteloxal GmbH &amp; Co. KG,</emphasis> established in Schorndorf (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000132">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000130">Kammin Metallveredelung KG, </emphasis>established in Friesenheim (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000133">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000131">Karl-Heinz Bauer GmbH Galvanische Anstalt,</emphasis> established in Ispringen (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000134">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000132">Maschinenfabrik KBA-Mödling AG, </emphasis>established in Maria Enzersdorf (Austria),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000135">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000133">Albert Kißling Galvanische Werke GmbH, </emphasis>established in Neusäß (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000136">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000134">KME Germany GmbH &amp; Co. KG,</emphasis> established in Osnabrück (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000137">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000135">Lahner KG, </emphasis>established in Brunn am Gebirge (Austria),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000138">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000136">Liebherr-Aerospace Lindenberg GmbH,</emphasis> established in Lindenberg (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000139">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000137">MTU Aero Engines AG,</emphasis> established in Munich (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000140">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000138">MTU Maintenance Hannover GmbH, </emphasis>established in Langenhagen (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000141">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000139">Münze Österreich AG,</emphasis> established in Vienna, </para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000142">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000140">Nehlsen-BWB Flugzeug-Galvanik Dresden GmbH &amp; Co. KG, </emphasis>established in Dresden (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000143">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000141">Orbis Will GmbH + Co. KG, </emphasis>established in Ahaus (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000144">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000142">Riag Oberflächentechnik AG,</emphasis> established in Wängi (Switzerland),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000145">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000143">Franz Rieger Metallveredlung, </emphasis>established in Steinheim am Albuch (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000146">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000144">Saxonia Galvanik GmbH, </emphasis>established in Halsbrücke (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000147">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000145">Schweizer Galvanotechnic GmbH &amp; Co. KG, </emphasis>established in Heilbronn (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000148">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000146">G. Schwepper Beschlag GmbH &amp; Co,</emphasis> established in Heiligenhaus,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000149">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000147">R. Spitzke Oberflächen- und Galvanotechnik GmbH &amp; Co. KG,</emphasis> established in Barsbüttel (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000150">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000148">Stahl Judenburg GmbH,</emphasis> established in Judenburg (Austria),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000151">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000149">VTK Veredelungstechnik Krieglach GmbH, </emphasis>established in Krieglach (Austria),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000152">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000150">STI Surface Technologies International Holding AG, </emphasis>established in Steinach (Switzerland),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000153">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000151">Witech GmbH, </emphasis>established in Remscheid,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000154">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000152">Kurt Zecher GmbH, </emphasis>established in Paderborn (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000155">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000153">De Martin AG, Metallveredelung,</emphasis> established in Wängi,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000156">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000154">Hattler &amp; Sohn GmbH, </emphasis>established in Villingen-Schwenningen,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000157">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000155">Alfacrom 2000 Srl,</emphasis> established in Fiume Veneto (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000158">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000156">F.LLI Angelini Sud Srl, </emphasis>established in Arzano (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000159">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000157">Bertola Srl, </emphasis>established in Marene (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000160">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000158">Bugli Srl, </emphasis>established in Scandicci (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000161">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000159">Burello Srl, </emphasis>established in Pavia di Udine (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000162">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000160">Galvanica CMB Di Bittante Franco EC Snc,</emphasis> established in Scorzé (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000163">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000161">Casprini Gruppo Industriale SpA,</emphasis> established in Cavrilia (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000164">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000162">CFG Rettifiche Srl, </emphasis>established in Argenta (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000165">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000163">CIL — Cromatura e Rettifica Srl, </emphasis>established in Esine (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000166">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000164">Cromatura Dura Srl, </emphasis>established in Lozza (Italy), </para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000167">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000165">Cromital Srl, </emphasis>established in Parme (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000168">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000166">Cromoflesch Di Bolletta Giuseppe &amp; C. Snc, </emphasis>established in Salzano (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000169">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000167">Cromogalante Srl, </emphasis>established in Padua (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000170">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000168">Cromotrevigiana Srl,</emphasis> established in Ponzano Veneto (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000171">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000169">Elezinco Srl, </emphasis>established in Castelfidardo (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000172">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000170">Galvanica Nobili Srl, </emphasis>established in Marano sul Panaro (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000173">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000171">Galvanotecnica Vignati Srl,</emphasis> established in Canegrate (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000174">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000172">Galvitek Srl, </emphasis>established in Verona (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000175">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000173">Gilardoni Vittorio Srl, </emphasis>established in Mandello del Lario (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000176">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000174">Industria Galvanica Dalla Torre Ermanno e Figli Srl, </emphasis>established in Villorba (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000177">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000175">La Galvanica Trentina Srl, </emphasis>established in Rovereto (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000178">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000176">Nicros Srl, </emphasis>established in Conegliano (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000179">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000177">OCM Di Liboà Mauro &amp; C. Snc, </emphasis>established in Mondovì (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000180">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000178">Rubinetterie Zazzeri SpA,</emphasis> established in Incisa Valdarno (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000181">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000179">Silga SpA, </emphasis>established in Castelfidarno (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000182">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000180">Surcromo Di Suttora Marco,</emphasis> established in Pieve Emanuele (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000183">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000181">Tobaldini SpA,</emphasis> established in Altavilla Vicentina (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000184">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000182">Tre Albi SNC Di Trentin Silvano Bittante Mario &amp; Albanese Giancarlo, </emphasis>established in Vedelago (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000185">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000183">Adolf Boos GmbH &amp; Co. KG, </emphasis>established in Iserlohn,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000186">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000184">Henkel Beiz- und Elektropoliertechnik GmbH &amp; Co. KG, </emphasis>established in Waidhofen an der Thaya (Austria),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000187">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000185">Saueressig GmbH &amp; Co. KG, </emphasis>established in Vreden (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000188">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000186">Saueressig Polska sp. z o.o.,</emphasis> established in Tarnowo Podgórne (Poland),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000189">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000187">Wetzel GmbH,</emphasis> established in Grenzach-Wyhlen (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000190">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000188">Wetzel sp. z o.o.,</emphasis> established in Duchnów (Poland),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000191">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000189">Apex Cylinders Ltd,</emphasis> established in Bristol (United Kingdom), </para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000192">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000190">Federal-Mogul Burscheid GmbH, </emphasis>established in Burscheid,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000193">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000191">Federal-Mogul Friedberg GmbH, </emphasis>established in Friedberg (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000194">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000192">Federal-Mogul Vermögensverwaltungs-GmbH,</emphasis> established in Burscheid,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000195">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000193">Federal-Mogul Operations France SAS,</emphasis> established in Saint-Jean-de-la-Ruelle (France),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000196">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000194">Dietmar Schrick GmbH, </emphasis>established in Solingen,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000197">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000195">Cromatura Dalla Torre Sergio Snc Di Dalla Torre Sergio EC,</emphasis> established in Breda di Tiave (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000198">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000196">Hartchromwerk Brunner AG,</emphasis> established in Sankt Gallen (Switzerland),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000199">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000197">Schulz Hartchrom GmbH,</emphasis> established in Hamburg, </para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000200">
               <emphasis role="pagebreak" id="D400000198"/>
            </para>
            <para style="73Alineacentregras" id="D150000201">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000199">ANNEX II</emphasis>
            </para>
            <para style="73Alineacentregras" id="D150000202">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000200">List of interveners at first instance</emphasis>
            </para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000203">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000201">European Chemicals Agency (ECHA),</emphasis>
            </para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000204">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000202">Assogalvanica, </emphasis>established in Padua,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000205">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000203">Ecometal, </emphasis>established in Trévise (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000206">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000204">Comité européen pour le traitement de surface (CETS), </emphasis>established in Louvain (Belgium),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000207">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000205">Österreichische Gesellschaft für Oberflächentechnik (AOT), </emphasis>established in Vienna,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000208">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000206">Surface Engineering Association (SEA),</emphasis> established in Birmingham (United Kingdom),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000209">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000207">Zentralverband Oberflächentechnik eV (ZVO), </emphasis>established in Hilden (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000210">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000208">Eco-Chim Galvanotecnica di Antoniazzi G. &amp; C. Snc,</emphasis> established in Codognè (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000211">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000209">Heiche Oberflächentechnik GmbH,</emphasis> established in Schwaigern (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000212">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000210">Schwäbische Härtetechnik Ulm GmbH &amp; Co. KG,</emphasis> established in Ulm,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000213">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000211">Trattamento superfici metalliche Srl (TSM),</emphasis> established in Schio (Italy),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000214">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000212">Aros Hydraulik GmbH, </emphasis>established in Memmingen,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000215">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000213">Berndorf Band GmbH,</emphasis> established in Berndorf (Austria),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000216">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000214">Eberhard Derichs Maschinen- und Apparatebau GmbH, </emphasis>established in Krefeld (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000217">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000215">Friedrich Fausel Metalldrückerei,</emphasis> established in Herrlingen (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000218">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000216">Goldhofer AG, </emphasis>established in Memmingen,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000219">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000217">Heidelberger Druckmaschinen AG,</emphasis> established in Heidelberg (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000220">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000218">Huhtamaki Flexible Packaging Germany GmbH &amp; Co. KG, </emphasis>established in Ronsberg (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000221">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000219">ITW Automotive Products GmbH,</emphasis> established in Hodenhagen (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000222">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000220">Josef Van Baal GmbH,</emphasis> established in Krefeld,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000223">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000221">Kleinvoigtsberger Elektrobauelemente GmbH,</emphasis> established in Großschirma (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000224">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000222">Kniggendorf &amp; Kögler GmbH, </emphasis>established in Laatzen (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000225">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000223">Liebherr-Components Kirchdorf GmbH, </emphasis>established in Kirchdorf (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000226">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000224">Max Hilscher GmbH, </emphasis>established in Dornstadt (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000227">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000225">Mora Metrology GmbH,</emphasis> established in Aschaffenburg (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000228">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000226">Norsystec — Nohra-System-Technik GmbH, </emphasis>established in Nohra (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000229">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000227">Otto Littmann Maschinenfabrik — Präzisionsmechanik GmbH, </emphasis>established in Hamburg,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000230">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000228">Provertha Connectors Cables &amp; Solutions GmbH,</emphasis> established in Pforzheim (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000231">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000229">Roland Merz, </emphasis>residing in Ober-Ramstadt (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000232">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000230">Schwing-Stetter Baumaschinen GmbH,</emphasis> established in Vienna,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000233">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000231">SML Maschinengesellschaft mbH,</emphasis> established in Lenzing (Austria),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000234">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000232">ThyssenKrupp Steel Europe AG,</emphasis> established in Duisbourg (Germany),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000235">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000233">Windmöller &amp; Hölscher KG,</emphasis> established in Lengerich (Germany).</para>
         </section>
      </A_Signatures>
   </Affaire>
</A_Doc_Ref>