<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><JUDGMENT xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:noNamespaceSchemaLocation="http://formex.publications.europa.eu/schema/formex-05.00-20081231.xd"><BIB.JUDGMENT><REF.CASE FILE="ECRCJ2000ENA.0400289101.case.xml"><NO.CASE>C-153/99 P</NO.CASE></REF.CASE><NO.CELEX>61999J0153</NO.CELEX><NO.SEQ>0018.0002</NO.SEQ><PAGE.FIRST.ECR>2905</PAGE.FIRST.ECR><PAGE.SEQ>1</PAGE.SEQ><PAGE.LAST.ECR>2916</PAGE.LAST.ECR><PAGE.TOTAL>12</PAGE.TOTAL><AUTHOR>CJ</AUTHOR></BIB.JUDGMENT><CURR.TITLE><LEFT>JUDGMENT OF <DATE ISO="20000413">13. 4. 2000</DATE> — CASE C-153/99 P</LEFT><RIGHT>COMMISSION V GIANNINI</RIGHT></CURR.TITLE><TITLE><TI><P><HT TYPE="UC">Judgment of the Court</HT> (Sixth Chamber)</P><P><DATE ISO="20000413">13 April 2000</DATE><NOTE NOTE.ID="E0001" NUMBERING="STAR"><P>Language of the case: French.</P></NOTE></P></TI></TITLE><JUDGMENT.INIT><P>In Case C-153/99 P,</P></JUDGMENT.INIT><PARTIES><PLAINTIFS><P><HT TYPE="BOLD">Commission of the European Communities,</HT> represented by G. Valsesia, Principal Legal Adviser, and J. Currall, Legal Adviser, acting as Agents, assisted by D. Waelbroeck, of the Brussels Bar, with an address for service in Luxembourg at the Chambers of C. Gómez de la Cruz, of its Legal Service, Wagner Centre, Kirchberg,</P><PARTY.STATUS>appellant,</PARTY.STATUS></PLAINTIFS><P>APPEAL against the judgment of the Court of First Instance of the European Communities (Fourth Chamber) of <DATE ISO="19990225">25 February 1999</DATE> in Joined Cases <REF.DOC.ECR EDITION="CST" NO.CASE="T-282/97+T-57/98" YEAR="1999" PAGE.ECR="II-151" PAGE.SUM="I-A-33">T-282/97 and T-57/98 <HT TYPE="ITALIC">Giannini</HT> v <HT TYPE="ITALIC">Commission</HT> [1999] ECR-SC I-A-33 and II-151</REF.DOC.ECR>, seeking to have that judgment set aside in so far as it contains an error of law regarding the abuse of power and the infringement of Article 176 of the EC Treaty (now Article 233 EC) which the Commission was alleged to have committed,</P><?PAGE NO="I-2906"?><AGAINST>the other party to the proceedings being:</AGAINST><DEFENDANTS><P><HT TYPE="BOLD">Antonio Giannini,</HT> an official of the Commission of the European Communities, residing in Brussels, represented by M. Dallemagne and C. Locchi, of the Brussels Bar, 85 Rue du Prince Royal, B-1050 Brussels,</P><PARTY.STATUS>applicant at first instance,</PARTY.STATUS></DEFENDANTS></PARTIES><PREAMBLE><PREAMBLE.INIT><P>THE COURT (Sixth Chamber),</P><P>composed of: J.C. Moitinho de Almeida, President of the Chamber, C. Gulmann (Rapporteur), J.-P. Puissochet, G. Hirsch and E Macken, Judges,</P><P>Advocate General: EG. Jacobs,</P><P>Registrar: R. Grass,</P></PREAMBLE.INIT><GR.VISA><VISA>having regard to the report of the Judge-Rapporteur,</VISA><VISA>after hearing the Opinion of the Advocate General at the sitting on <DATE ISO="19991125">25 November 1999</DATE>,</VISA></GR.VISA><?PAGE NO="I-2907"?><PREAMBLE.FINAL><P>gives the following</P></PREAMBLE.FINAL></PREAMBLE><CONTENTS.JUDGMENT><GR.SEQ LEVEL="1"><TITLE><TI><P>Judgment</P></TI></TITLE><NP><NO.P>1</NO.P><TXT>By application lodged at the Court Registry on <DATE ISO="19990423">23 April 1999</DATE> the Commission of the European Communities brought an appeal under Article 49 of the EC Statute and the corresponding provisions of the ECSC and EAEC Statutes of the Court of Justice against the judgment of the Court of First Instance of <DATE ISO="19990225">25 February 1999</DATE> in Joined Cases <REF.DOC.ECR EDITION="CST" NO.CASE="T-282/97+T-57/98" YEAR="1999" PAGE.ECR="II-151" PAGE.SUM="I-A-33">T-282/97 and T-57/98 <HT TYPE="ITALIC">Giannini</HT> v <HT TYPE="ITALIC">Commission</HT> [1999] ECR-SC I-A-33 and II-151</REF.DOC.ECR> (<QUOT.START ID="QS0001" REF.END="QE0001" CODE="2018"/>the contested judgment<QUOT.END ID="QE0001" REF.START="QS0001" CODE="2019"/>), seeking to have that judgment set aside in so far as it contains an error of law regarding the abuse of power and the infringement of Article 176 of the EC Treaty (now Article 233 EC) which the Commission was alleged to have committed.</TXT></NP><NP><NO.P>2</NO.P><TXT>The legal framework and the facts which gave rise to the appeal are set out in the contested judgment in the following terms:</TXT><P><QUOT.S LEVEL="1"><NP><NO.P><QUOT.START ID="QS0002" REF.END="QE0002" CODE="2018"/>1</NO.P><TXT>On <DATE ISO="19941215">15 December 1994</DATE> the Commission published a vacancy notice (COM/151/94, <QUOT.START ID="QS0003" REF.END="QE0003" CODE="201C"/>the original notice<QUOT.END ID="QE0003" REF.START="QS0003" CODE="201D"/>) for the post of Head of the Unit responsible for negotiating and managing the agreements on textiles, footwear of Directorate D (Sectoral commercial questions) in Directorate General I (External economic relations) (<QUOT.START ID="QS0004" REF.END="QE0004" CODE="201C"/>the post at issue<QUOT.END ID="QE0004" REF.START="QS0004" CODE="201D"/>). The notice was headed:</TXT><P><QUOT.S LEVEL="2"><P><QUOT.START ID="QS0005" REF.END="QE0005" CODE="201C"/>COM/151/94 A3/A4/A5 I/D/I Head of the Unit responsible for negotiating and managing the agreements on textiles, footwear.<QUOT.END ID="QE0005" REF.START="QS0005" CODE="201D"/></P></QUOT.S></P></NP><?PAGE NO="I-2908"?><NP><NO.P>2</NO.P><TXT>The minimum requirements to be met by candidates wishing to transfer or be promoted to the post were as follows:</TXT><P><QUOT.S LEVEL="2"><LIST TYPE="DASH"><ITEM><NP><NO.P><QUOT.START ID="QS0006" REF.END="QE0006" CODE="201C"/>—</NO.P><TXT>being in the same category/service/career bracket as the COM (internal transfer);</TXT></NP></ITEM><ITEM><NP><NO.P>—</NO.P><TXT>being in the career bracket below that of the COM (promotion, in accordance with Article 45 of the Staff Regulations);</TXT></NP></ITEM><ITEM><NP><NO.P>—</NO.P><TXT>knowledge and experience/abilities appropriate to the tasks to be carried out;</TXT></NP></ITEM><ITEM><NP><NO.P>—</NO.P><TXT>for posts requiring particular qualifications: thorough knowledge and experience of/connected with the relevant sector.<QUOT.END ID="QE0006" REF.START="QS0006" CODE="201D"/></TXT></NP></ITEM></LIST></QUOT.S></P></NP><NP><NO.P>3</NO.P><TXT>The applicant, an official in grade A 4, applied with six others for the post. The appointing authority appointed Mr X to the post. The applicant was informed that he had not been successful by a note of <DATE ISO="19950428">28 April 1995</DATE>. After the complaint he lodged on <DATE ISO="19950725">25 July 1995</DATE> had been rejected he brought on <DATE ISO="19960221">21 February 1996</DATE> an action seeking the annulment of the decisions not to consider him for the post and to appoint Mr X to it and for compensation for material and nonmaterial damage caused by the decisions. The Court of First Instance upheld the application for annulment and dismissed that for<?PAGE NO="I-2909"?> compensation by its judgment of <DATE ISO="19970319">19 March 1997</DATE> in Case <REF.DOC.ECR EDITION="CST" NO.CASE="T-21/96" YEAR="1997" PAGE.ECR="II-211" PAGE.SUM="I-A-69">T-21/96 <HT TYPE="ITALIC">Giannini</HT> v <HT TYPE="ITALIC">Commission</HT> [1997] ECR-SC I-A-69 and II-211</REF.DOC.ECR> (hereinafter <QUOT.START ID="QS0007" REF.END="QE0007" CODE="201C"/>the judgment of <DATE ISO="19970319">19 March 1997</DATE><QUOT.END ID="QE0007" REF.START="QS0007" CODE="201D"/>).</TXT></NP><NP><NO.P>4</NO.P><TXT>In that judgment, the Court first reviewed the case-law of the Court of Justice to the effect that the exercise of the discretion which the appointing authority enjoys in the matter of appointments presupposes a meticulous examination of the application files and a careful regard for the requirements set out in the vacancy notice, so that the appointing authority must reject any candidate who does not meet those requirements. In this case, one of those requirements was to have <QUOT.START ID="QS0008" REF.END="QE0008" CODE="201C"/>knowledge and experience/abilities appropriate to the tasks to be carried out<QUOT.END ID="QE0008" REF.START="QS0008" CODE="201D"/> (third indent of the general conditions), a requirement which had to be assessed in conjunction with the description of the post, namely <QUOT.START ID="QS0009" REF.END="QE0009" CODE="201C"/>Head of the Unit responsible for negotiating and managing the agreements on textiles, footwear<QUOT.END ID="QE0009" REF.START="QS0009" CODE="201D"/>.</TXT></NP><NP><NO.P>5</NO.P><TXT>The Court went on to find that Mr X manifestly did not meet that requirement, since he did not possess, at the time when he submitted his application for the post, any experience either in the textiles or in the footwear sector, or in the general field represented by the post at issue, namely that of the common commercial policy. It also noted that the Commission had confirmed that the applicant, who had been responsible for negotiating and managing bilateral and multilateral textiles agreements of the Community for some 10 years and had been a principal negotiator of such agreements for a further five years, had good qualifications for the post.</TXT></NP><NP><NO.P>6</NO.P><TXT>The Court concluded that by appointing Mr X to the post when he did not meet one of the minimum requirements set out in the vacancy notice, while rejecting Mr Giannini's application, the Commission had, having regard to the comparative assessments which might have led to its conclusion, manifestly abused its powers and disregarded the interests of the service<?PAGE NO="I-2910"?> within the meaning of Article 7 of the Staff Regulations. Consequently, it annulled the contested decisions of the appointing authority.</TXT></NP><NP><NO.P>7</NO.P><TXT>On <DATE ISO="19970410">10 April 1997</DATE> the Commission published a new document annulling vacancy notice COM/151/94 and publishing a new vacancy notice for the post at issue (<QUOT.START ID="QS0010" REF.END="QE0010" CODE="201C"/>the new vacancy notice<QUOT.END ID="QE0010" REF.START="QS0010" CODE="201D"/>), worded as follows:</TXT><P><QUOT.S LEVEL="2"><P><QUOT.START ID="QS0011" REF.END="QE0011" CODE="201C"/>COM/062/97 A 3 I/D/I Head of the Unit responsible for negotiating and managing the agreements on textiles; footwear; various. Preference will be given to candidates with proven experience in international negotiation and in the management of a unit.<QUOT.END ID="QE0011" REF.START="QS0011" CODE="201D"/></P></QUOT.S></P></NP><NP><NO.P>8</NO.P><TXT>That notice included the same minimum requirements as those of the original notice (see paragraph 2 above).</TXT></NP><NP><NO.P>9</NO.P><TXT>On <DATE ISO="19970507">7 May 1997</DATE> the applicant lodged a complaint against the new notice and the withdrawal of the original notice, and an application for compensation.</TXT></NP><NP><NO.P>10</NO.P><TXT>By decision of <DATE ISO="19970530">30 May 1997</DATE> the defendant reappointed Mr X to the post at issue.</TXT></NP><NP><NO.P>11</NO.P><TXT>The applicant's complaint of <DATE ISO="19970507">7 May 1997</DATE> was expressly rejected by decision of <DATE ISO="19970724">24 July 1997</DATE>, notified on <DATE ISO="19970730">30 July 1997</DATE>.</TXT></NP><?PAGE NO="I-2911"?><NP><NO.P>12</NO.P><TXT>On <DATE ISO="19970821">21 August 1997</DATE> the applicant lodged a complaint against the defendant's decision of <DATE ISO="19970530">30 May 1997</DATE> appointing Mr X to the post. That complaint, too, was expressly rejected by a decision adopted by the defendant on <DATE ISO="19971218">18 December 1997</DATE> and notified to the applicant on <DATE ISO="19980106">6 January 1998</DATE>.<QUOT.END ID="QE0002" REF.START="QS0002" CODE="2019"/></TXT></NP></QUOT.S></P></NP><NP><NO.P>3</NO.P><TXT>In those circumstances Mr Giannini brought two actions before the Court of First-Instance seeking the annulment of the measures taken by the Commission to comply with the judgment of <DATE ISO="19970319">19 March 1997</DATE>, replacing the original notice with the new one and reappointing Mr X to the post at issue (hereinafter <QUOT.START ID="QS0012" REF.END="QE0012" CODE="2018"/>the contested measures<QUOT.END ID="QE0012" REF.START="QS0012" CODE="2019"/>). He relied on two pleas: infringement of Article 176 of the Treaty and abuse of powers on the one hand, and breach of the principles of the protection of legitimate expectations and officials' entitlement to a career and failure to have regard for the interests of the service on the other.</TXT></NP><GR.SEQ LEVEL="2"><TITLE><TI><P>The contested judgment</P></TI></TITLE><NP><NO.P>4</NO.P><TXT>In paragraph 29 of the contested judgment the Court observed that it was necessary to determine whether the measures adopted by the Commission replacing the original notice with the new one and appointing, on the basis of the latter, the same official as had been appointed under the first, supposedly adopted in order to comply with the judgment of <DATE ISO="19970319">19 March 1997</DATE>, showed a deliberate intention on the part of the defendant to favour one of the applicants for the postto the detriment of the others, in disregard of the interests of the service.</TXT></NP><?PAGE NO="I-2912"?><NP><NO.P>5</NO.P><TXT>In paragraphs 30 to 33 of the contested judgment, the Court identified three factors which in its view showed that the Commission had failed to have regard for Article 176 of the Treaty and had committed an abuse of power. They were:</TXT><P><LIST TYPE="DASH"><ITEM><P>the Commission's annulment of the original notice and thus the elimination of the original applicants for the post despite the fact that, far from criticising that notice, in the judgment of <DATE ISO="19970319">19 March 1997</DATE> the Court had found that Mr X did not meet one of the minimum requirements laid down in that notice for appointment to the post at issue;</P></ITEM><ITEM><P>the fact that the only essential difference between the new notice and the original one lay in the addition of two conditions regarding the <QUOT.START ID="QS0013" REF.END="QE0013" CODE="2018"/>preference<QUOT.END ID="QE0013" REF.START="QS0013" CODE="2019"/> to be given when selecting a candidate, which corresponded precisely to the qualifications the Court found that Mr X possessed;</P></ITEM><ITEM><P>the reappointment of Mr X, when seven other officials had applied for the post at issue.</P></ITEM></LIST></P></NP><NP><NO.P>6</NO.P><TXT>In paragraph 30 of the contested judgment the Court also observed that when the Commission was questioned at the hearing as to the reasons for replacing the original vacancy notice, it relied primarily on its wide power of discretion in such matters.</TXT></NP><NP><NO.P>7</NO.P><TXT>In the light of those considerations the Court concluded that there was objective, relevant and consistent evidence that the contested measures had been adopted with a view to achieving a purpose other than that of complying in good faith with the judgment of <DATE ISO="19970319">19 March 1997</DATE> and that, in any event, far from serving the aims of Article 176 of the Treaty, they had prejudiced implementation of a judgment of the Court of First Instance. Consequently, it held that by deciding to<?PAGE NO="I-2913"?> replace the original notice with the new one, stating preferences to be given which were favourable to Mr X's application, and reappointing him to the post at issue, the Commission had infringed Article 176 of the Treaty and committed an abuse of power.</TXT></NP></GR.SEQ><GR.SEQ LEVEL="2"><TITLE><TI><P>The appeal</P></TI></TITLE><NP><NO.P>8</NO.P><TXT>The Commission asks the Court to declare the appeal admissible and well founded, to set aside the contested judgment and to order Mr Giannini to pay the costs.</TXT></NP><NP><NO.P>9</NO.P><TXT>It relies on a single ground of appeal, that the Court of First Instance erred in law in holding that its withdrawal of the original vacancy notice and the initiation of a new recruitment procedure following the judgment of <DATE ISO="19970319">19 March 1997</DATE> were incompatible with its obligations under Article 176 of the Treaty, and therefore that the Court could not have found that there had been an abuse of power.</TXT></NP><NP><NO.P>10</NO.P><TXT>The Commission considers that it had power to adopt such measures following the partial annulment of the original recruitment procedure, the decision to take that approach being a proper exercise of its power of assessment as confirmed by the decisions of the Court of First Instance, in particular that in Case <REF.DOC.ECR EDITION="CST" NO.CASE="T-56/94" YEAR="1996" PAGE.ECR="II-1325" PAGE.SUM="I-A-473">T-56/94 <HT TYPE="ITALIC">De Santis</HT> v <HT TYPE="ITALIC">Commission</HT> [1996] ECR-SC I-A-473 and II-1325</REF.DOC.ECR>. It is for the appointing authority to state in the vacancy notice for the post to be filled the requirements it deems necessary for appointment to a post bearing in mind the needs of the service. In view of the essential role of vacancy notices, it is also for the appointing authority alone, if it discovers at a late stage that those requirements should be adjusted in the interests of the service, to decide to recommence the procedure for appointment by withdrawing the original notice and replacing it with an amended one.</TXT></NP><?PAGE NO="I-2914"?><NP><NO.P>11</NO.P><TXT>The fact that the preference requirements included in the new vacancy notice corresponded to qualities Mr X had been found to have in the judgment of <DATE ISO="19970319">19 March 1997</DATE> is not, the Commission maintains, conclusive evidence of an abuse of powers aimed at circumventing the effects of that judgment. For that to be so, it would have been necessary to show that those conditions were irrelevant to the post to be filled. In addition, the Commission considers that the judgment cannot have comprised any instruction to the Commission as to the conduct which it was to adopt following the annulment of the decisions then challenged before the Court. Any such instruction would have been contrary to the allocation of powers under Article 176 of the Treaty and would have prevented the Commission from acting in the interests of the service.</TXT></NP><NP><NO.P>12</NO.P><TXT>Accordingly, the Commission claims that the contested judgment is defective primarily because the Court appears to have relied on the premiss that in order to properly implement the judgment of <DATE ISO="19970319">19 March 1997</DATE> it had, in reality, no choice but to resume the original procedure for appointment at the stage at which the decisions annulled by the judgment occurred, with the result that the procedure would continue on the basis of the original vacancy and the Commission could not initiate a new procedure for recruitment based on a new notice.</TXT></NP><NP><NO.P>13</NO.P><TXT>That allegation of error in law however is founded on a wrong analysis of the contested judgment.</TXT></NP><NP><NO.P>14</NO.P><TXT>Whilst it is true that when exercising judicial review of legality under Article 173 of the EC Treaty (now, after amendment, Article 230 EC) the Community judicature has no power to issue directions to the institutions, even where they concern the manner in which its judgments are to be complied with (see, <HT TYPE="ITALIC">inter alia,</HT> the order of <DATE ISO="19951026">26 October 1995</DATE> in Joined Cases <REF.DOC.ECR EDITION="GEN" NO.CASE="C-199/94 P+C-200/94 P" YEAR="1995" PAGE.ECR="I-3709">C-199/94 P and C-200/94 P <HT TYPE="ITALIC">Pevasa and Inpesca</HT> v <HT TYPE="ITALIC">Commission</HT> [1995] ECR I-3709, paragraph 24</REF.DOC.ECR>), and, in a case such as this, it is for the Commission, after considering the interests of the service with regard to each post to be filled, to adopt the appropriate measures, which may include initiating a fresh recruitment procedure based on a vacancy<?PAGE NO="I-2915"?> notice which has, if necessary, been amended (see paragraphs 30 to 45 of the Opinion of the Advocate General), it is clear that the Court of First Instance has not disregarded those principles.</TXT></NP><NP><NO.P>15</NO.P><TXT>Its decision that the contested measures should be annulled for infringement of Article 176 of the Treaty and abuse of powers was based on the evidence of a number of facts, referred to in paragraph 5 of this judgment, which it considered to be objective, relevant and consistent in showing that the measures had been adopted in order to achieve a purpose other than that of complying in good faith with the judgment of <DATE ISO="19970319">19 March 1997</DATE>.</TXT></NP><NP><NO.P>16</NO.P><TXT>In so far as the arguments of the Commission in support of its sole plea amount to challenging the Court's assessment of the facts, it is sufficient to recall that the Court has consistently held that under Article 168a of the EC Treaty (now Article 225 EC) and the first paragraph of Article 51 of the EC Statute of the Court of Justice an appeal may be based only on grounds relating to the infringement of rules of law, to the exclusion of any appraisal of the facts (see, <HT TYPE="ITALIC">inter alia,</HT> Case <REF.DOC.ECR EDITION="GEN" NO.CASE="C-8/95 P" YEAR="1998" PAGE.ECR="I-3175">C-8/95 P <HT TYPE="ITALIC">New Holland Ford</HT> v <HT TYPE="ITALIC">Commission</HT> [1998] ECR I-3175, paragraph 25</REF.DOC.ECR>).</TXT></NP><NP><NO.P>17</NO.P><TXT>In the light of all those considerations the appeal must be dismissed.</TXT></NP></GR.SEQ><GR.SEQ LEVEL="2"><TITLE><TI><P>Costs</P></TI></TITLE><NP><NO.P>18</NO.P><TXT>Under Article 69(2) of the Rules of Procedure, applicable in appeals in accordance with Article 118 thereof, the unsuccessful party is to be ordered to pay the costs if they have been applied for. Since Mr Giannini has applied for the Commission to pay the costs and the sole plea of the latter has been unsuccessful, it must be ordered to pay the costs.</TXT></NP></GR.SEQ></GR.SEQ><?PAGE NO="I-2916"?><JURISDICTION><INTRO><P>On those grounds,</P><P>THE COURT (Sixth Chamber)</P><P>hereby:</P></INTRO><LIST TYPE="ARAB"><ITEM><NP><NO.P>1.</NO.P><TXT>Dismisses the appeal;</TXT></NP></ITEM><ITEM><NP><NO.P>2.</NO.P><TXT>Orders the Commission of the European Communities to pay the costs.</TXT></NP></ITEM></LIST></JURISDICTION></CONTENTS.JUDGMENT><SIGNATURE.CASE><P>Moitinho de Almeida</P><P>Gulmann</P><P>Puissochet</P><P>Hirsch</P><P>Macken</P><P>Delivered in open court in Luxembourg on <DATE ISO="20000413">13 April 2000</DATE>.</P><SIGNATORY><P>R. Grass</P><P>Registrar</P></SIGNATORY><SIGNATORY><P>J.C. Moitinho de Almeida</P><P>President of the Sixth Chamber</P></SIGNATORY></SIGNATURE.CASE></JUDGMENT>