CALL FOR EVIDENCE

FOR AN INITIATIVE (without an impact assessment)

·

Title of the initiative

European Capitals of Culture – new legal basis after 2033

Lead DG – responsible unit

Directorate-General for Education, Youth, Sport and Culture – Unit D.2 Creative Europe

Likely Type of initiative

Proposal for decision of the European Parliament and of the Council

Indicative Timing

Q3-2026

Additional Information

https://culture.ec.europa.eu/policies/culture-in-cities-and-regions/about-european-capitals-of-culture 

A. Political context, problem definition and subsidiarity check

Political context

Created in 1985, inspired by an idea of former Greek Minister of Culture Melina Mercouri, the European Capital of Culture (‘ECoC’) is a flagship action of the European Union. The aim of the initiative is to promote and celebrate Europe’s rich cultural diversity and shared aspects of our cultures and heritage, thereby increasing the public’s sense of belonging to a common cultural area. It also aims to strengthen the contribution of culture to the long-term development of cities.

Initially, cities were designated as ‘European Cities of Culture’ by Member States on the basis of a resolution of the ministers responsible for cultural affairs, which recognised the essential role cities play in shaping and spreading culture in Europe. In 1999, the action was changed into a Community action with the adoption of Decision 1419/1999/EC: the ‘European Cities of Culture’ became ‘European Capitals of Culture’.

Another decision was adopted in 2006 (1622/2006/EC), completing the rules for the selection and monitoring of the different European Capitals of Culture. The current legal base (Decision No 445/2014/EU) was adopted in 2014 to cover 2020-2033. It is now necessary to adopt a new legal basis by mid-to-late 2027 to ensure the action’s smooth continuation after 2033.

The EU Agenda for Cities should be adopted towards the end of 2025 with the aim of strengthening the EU’s approach to sustainable urban development, focusing on local implementation of priorities, including in the area of culture, The agenda’s content will therefore be considered where useful in the new legal basis of the European Capitals of Culture.

Problem the initiative aims to tackle

The first interim evaluation of the 2020-2033 ECoC action shows that it is a successful flagship action with substantial cost-effectiveness for the EU due to its very limited impact on the EU budget. Moreover, the initiative can transform the candidate cities and selected cities. This is because cities must engage in long-term planning and incorporate culture into local city policies to be considered for the title. The action is also consistent with other EU initiatives (e.g. the Creative Europe programme), facilitates sharing EU values and supports the movement of European cultural professionals and artists and the circulation of their works across the EU and beyond.

After 40 years, the action is still fully relevant and sought after by cities and territories looking to develop themselves through culture. However, to ensure its continued relevance in the future, it is necessary to update the action, taking into account emerging trends, such as the increasing number of smaller cities competing for the title.

European dimension. It is a key aspect of the ECoC (and one of the criteria for selecting title holders), but it is not often fully understood by many stakeholders. The evaluation recommends the Commission to explore ways to better explain this aspect to stakeholders..

Long-term knowledge. There is a candidate cities network called Culture Next, set up in 2017 that includes current and former cities, regardless of whether they were awarded the title. However, there is no formal ECoC network, so there is risk of knowledge not being shared between newly appointed and previous title holders. The Commission could investigate how to promote knowledge-sharing in the ECoC community to maximise the initiative’s full potential, particularly of its European dimension.

Communication. There are currently no EU-level communication campaigns led by the Commission or other EU institutions to promote the ECoC cities. This hampers the initiative’s visibility, impact and public awareness. The ECoC could benefit from EU communication efforts to support and complement the work of the title-holding cities, with input from Member States. Appointing ECoC ambassadors, such as Commissioners or MEPs could also strengthen the initiative.

An ECoC bureau/secretariat could also be set up to help support communication, network and capacity building and preserve the initiative’s legacy, following the successful model of the European Heritage Label bureau.

Basis for EU action (legal basis and subsidiarity check)

Legal basis

The initiative is based on Article 167 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU), which provides for EU support to encourage cooperation between Member States and to promote the European dimension in cultural heritage.

The proposal follows the ordinary legislative procedure under Article 294 TFEU.

Subsidiarity check

Culture is an area of shared competence between the EU and Member States. While primary responsibility for managing culture lies with national and local governments, EU-level action adds significant value by fostering a shared narrative, encouraging cross-border cooperation and supporting the visibility of cultural cities of European significance.

The ECoC specifically enables the promotion of cultural cities whose symbolic relevance goes beyond national boundaries and contributes to a shared European identity and values. It helps cities access EU funding, build capacity and engage in international networking. The proposed revision respects the principle of subsidiarity by reinforcing the EU’s complementary role and strengthening cooperation without replacing national efforts.

Practical need for EU action

National governments play a central role in protecting and promoting their national cultures and heritage. However, the first interim evaluation of the 2020-2033 ECoC action found that the ECoC adds significant value by offering a European-level framework that highlights the international significance of the selected cities and strengthens their role in promoting the diversity of cultures in Europe and common traits and in promoting shared European values, history and identity.

The evaluation demonstrates that the ECoC facilitates voluntary cooperation, knowledge exchange and visibility among cities across EU countries and non-EU countries as well. The ECoC title has been awarded three times to cities outside the EU and will be given again in 2030 to a city in an EFTA/EEA country, a candidate country or a potential candidate participating in the EU’s Creative Europe programme. The ECoC supports national efforts by integrating them into a coherent and strategic EU context, helping to align cultural initiatives with broader EU priorities, such as youth engagement, sustainability and digital innovation. This initiative also promotes a more balanced geographic representation,. The external aspect of ECoC aligns with broader EU efforts to strengthen enlargement policy, promote cultural diplomacy and foster international cultural relations.

Renewing the legal basis will strengthen the initiative’s capacity to support cities more effectively, increase flexibility in its design and improve its long-term coherence and impact. This will ensure that the EU continues to play a constructive and complementary role in the cultural and heritage landscape.

B. What does the initiative aim to achieve and how

The revision of the ECoC legal basis aims to improve the scheme’s selection process, make it simpler and more transparent for applicants and national authorities, and increase its strategic relevance to other EU policies. The changes are designed to build on existing strengths while tackling key issues identified in the summer 2024 public consultation and the interim evaluation.

In practical terms, the initiative will be revised to:

·mainstream the European dimension in all selection criteria;

·better embed key EU priorities into the selection and monitoring phases, such as the green and digital transitions, inclusion, youth engagement, and accessibility;

·reinforce the ‘contribution to the long-term strategy’ criterion and improve evaluation criteria and indicators to bring about longer-term impacts and legacy in the candidate cities;

·simplify the competition’s rules and make them more transparent (selection and monitoring);

·ensure that the expert panel (which carries out the selection and monitoring procedures for applicant and title-holding cities) has the skills and resources to carry out its tasks effectively;

·improve the set of indicators the Commission provides to the organisations responsible for organising the different ECoC competitions;

·build on the knowledge of the 40 years of ECoC: develop capacity building and exchange best practices between past and upcoming title holders;

·consider changes to the rotation of countries holding the title and the size of applicant cities;

·consider a regional approach and the possibility for connections with other parts of the world.

The overall design of the ECoC will not be changed. This will ensure continuity for stakeholders and make the initiative more effective, increase its scalability outside the EU and boost its visibility, in line with the current and future goals of EU cultural policy.

Likely impacts

The proposed revision of the ECoC legal basis is expected to have a positive social, economic, environmental and international impact.

·Social impact. The revised ECoC is expected to strengthen the sense of European identity and belonging, broadening access to and participation in culture. In particular, it will benefit people in rural and less-visible regions and encourage more young people to get involved. It will support social cohesion, intercultural and intergenerational dialogue and democratic engagement in the EU and beyond.

·Economic impact. By improving the visibility and network of ECoC, the initiative is likely to boost local cultural tourism, stimulate innovation and regional development, and create jobs, especially in small and medium-sized cultural businesses.

·Environmental impact. The revised framework will integrate sustainability more explicitly into the selection and monitoring processes, encouraging cities to adopt green practices in management, visitor engagement and operations. This will contribute to raising awareness of climate issues through cultural narratives and boosting the role of culture in advancing the green transition.

·International impact. The revised framework will primarily focus on Member States, as is currently the case, in line with the instrument providing direct financial support to the ECoC at EU level (the Creative Europe programme until 2027 and then its successor). However, EU external action priorities will also be taken into account to ensure that the revised framework play a role in EU enlargement policy, cultural diplomacy and international cultural relations.

UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). The initiative will contribute positively to several SDGs, in particular:

oSDG 4 – Quality education

oSDG 5 – Gender equality

oSDG 8 – Decent work and economic growth

oSDG 10 – Reduced inequalities

oSDG 11 – Sustainable cities and communities

oSDG 13 – Climate action

oSDG 16 – Peace, justice and strong institutions

oSDG 17 – Partnerships for the goals

Future monitoring

The revised ECoC will be supported by a proportionate and structured long-term monitoring framework to maintain quality and track its legacy.

Key aspects of this approach include:

·strengthened post-ECoC year reporting by cities, focusing on implementation of the European dimension, engagement activities and impact on visitors;

·thematic or regional peer-learning sessions, which will serve as both capacity-building and informal monitoring tools by enabling cities to share experiences and highlight good practices;

·possible regular evaluation of the initiative’s legacy supported by independent external assessments.

C. Better regulation

Impact assessment

An impact assessment is not being conducted for this initiative as the revision of the ECoC legal basis is an administrative and operational measure.

Given its narrow scope, low impact on the EU budget and primarily administrative purpose, the revision does not meet the criteria requiring an impact assessment under the EU’s Better Regulation guidelines.

However, a call for evidence is being carried out.

No public consultation is planned since a public consultation was carried out last summer (from 18 June to 24 September 2024) as part of the first interim evaluation of the 2020-2033 ECoC action. The public consultation included some questions on the new legal basis after 2033.

Why we are consulting?

The aim of the call for evidence is to collect input from a wide range of stakeholders on the revision of the ECoC legal basis. This includes views on the main issues identified in the interim evaluation, the relevance of proposed adjustments, and ideas for further improving the initiative’s clarity, effectiveness and alignment with EU priorities. The feedback will inform the final legislative proposal and ensure it reflects the needs and expectations of those directly involved in or impacted by the ECoC action.

Target audience

·ECoC managers (former, present and future ones) who can share operational insights from the field;

·ECoC managing authorities in Member States (the respective ministry of culture), responsible for implementation and governance;

·academic experts in the cultural development of cities and the ECoC Expert Panel;

·the general public, including people who have visited or engaged with ECoC and wish to share their views;

·cultural networks, NGOs and civil society organisations involved in culture and cities.

Consultation activities already carried out

·Stakeholder engagement:

othe White Paper ‘40 recommendations from 40 years of ECOC’ was presented and debated in Chemnitz during the 40th ECoC anniversary conference in early April 2025;

oa workshop was organised to discuss the results of the first interim evaluation of the 2020-2033 ECoC action by Ecorys (end of March 2025)

·Consultation with Member States. the White Paper was presented to the European Parliament in May 2025 and the Council’s Culture Affairs Committee in July 2025.

·Document review. Past reports from the ECoC Expert Panel, EU-funded studies and existing monitoring or evaluation data will be incorporated into the evidence base.