Brussels, 19.11.2024

SWD(2024) 264 final

COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT

Technical information

Accompanying the document

Report from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council

on the functioning of the European carbon market in 2023 

{COM(2024) 538 final}


Contents

I.    State of play on the EU ETS – scope and coverage    

II.    Balancing supply and demand - contributions to the Market Stability Reserve    

III.    Revenue from the EU ETS    

IV.    EU ETS implementation framework    



I.State of play on the EU ETS – scope and coverage

As explained in the main report, this section relies on the data reported by Italy under Article 21 of the ETS Directive for 2022 as a proxy to make year-to-year comparison possible. For all other countries 2023 data is used.

The EU Emissions Trading System (EU ETS) applies in all 27 EU Member States plus Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway, as well as to power plants in Northern Ireland 1 . Countries’ reports under Article 21 of the ETS Directive (Directive 2003/87/EC) 2  provide an annual overview of the EU ETS implementation. In 2024, countries submitted their reports for 2023.

In 2023, the EU ETS covered emissions from 8 554 installations in the electricity and heat generation and industry sectors, as well as from 379 aircraft operators flying between airports in the European Economic Area (EEA) and on routes from the EEA to Switzerland and to the UK.

Most installations in the EU ETS emit less than 50 000 tonnes CO2eq (carbon dioxide equivalent) per year (71.4% of the total) 3 . Of these, 4 823 were classified as installations with low emissions 4 . Most of the remaining installations emit between 50 000 and 500 000 tonnes CO2eq per year 5 (21.4% of the total), and only a fraction emits over 500 000 tonnes CO2eq per year 6 (7.2% of the total). Figure A  shows the breakdown of installations in the EU ETS by the level of emissions in 2023.

Countries reported that 167 installations were excluded from the scope of the EU ETS in 2023. For 111 of these installations, the exclusion resulted from a reduction in their capacity below the 20 MW of thermal input threshold (applicable to combustion installations in Annex I to the ETS Directive). Combustion installations below that threshold are out of the scope of the system.

To reduce the administrative burden, countries can exclude installations with emissions below 25 000 tonnes CO2eq per year from the EU ETS if alternative measures to reduce emissions are implemented 7 . Since 2021, it is also possible to exclude from the EU ETS installations that emit less than 2 500 tonnes CO2eq per year 8  if certain conditions have been met, as well as reserve or back-up units that operate no more than 300 hours per year 9 .

In 2023, 15 countries opted to exclude installations from the system and apply equivalent measures to reduce emissions. These installations accounted for a total of 4 Mt CO2eq and 0.3% of installations’ total emissions under the EU ETS.

In aviation, most of the 379 regulated operators in 2023 were commercial operators (70% of the total) 10 . A total of 169 operators (45%) qualified as small emitters, including almost all of 115 non-commercial aircraft operators (97%).

In addition to CO2 emissions, the EU ETS covers emissions of N2O (nitrous oxide) from nitric, adipic and glyoxylic acids’ and glyoxal production and PFCs (perfluorocarbons) from primary aluminium production. In 2023, 22 countries reported permits for ETS activities releasing emissions other than CO2. Only Norway declared carbon capture and storage activities. Countries reporting emissions other than CO2 from ETS activities are shown in Table A.

Figure A. Categories of installations in the EU ETS 11



Table A. Countries reporting emissions other than CO2 from EU ETS activities (2023) 12

Gas

Activity

Number of countries

Country

PFCs

Primary aluminium

11

DE, EL, ES, FR, IS, NL, NO, RO, SE, SI, SK

N2O

Nitric acid

20

AT, BE, BG, CZ, DE, EL, ES, FI, FR, HR, HU, IT, LT, NL, NO, PL, PT, RO, SE, SK

Adipic acid

3

DE, FR, IT

Glyoxal and glyoxylic acid

2

DE, FR



II.Balancing supply and demand - contributions to the Market Stability Reserve

Table B. Annual contributions per country to the Market Stability Reserve in allowances (2021-2024)

Country

2021

2022

2023

2024

AT

5 563 187

6 345 090

5 555 134

4 657 247

BE

9 228 856

10 525 966

9 215 496

7 725 979

BG

6 531 499

7 449 497

6 522 044

5 467 874

CY

874 285

997 166

873 019

731 911

CZ

14 108 876

16 091 870

14 088 451

11 811 310

DE

80 029 579

91 277 689

79 913 725

66 997 128

DK

5 005 490

5 709 009

4 998 244

4 190 368

EE

2 225 742

2 538 569

2 222 520

1 863 290

EL

11 888 232

13 559 116

11 871 023

9 952 288

ES

30 610 010

34 912 228

30 565 697

25 625 310

FI

6 682 443

7 621 657

6 672 769

5 594 238

FR

21 881 211

24 956 603

21 849 536

18 317 957

HR

1 513 604

1 726 341

1 511 413

1 267 121

HU

4 381 023

4 996 772

4 374 681

3 667 594

IE

3 740 851

4 266 625

3 735 436

3 131 670

IS

156 001

177 927

155 775

130 598

IT

37 775 362

43 084 666

37 720 676

31 623 817

LI

3 492

3 982

3 486

2 923

LT

1 100 842

1 255 564

1 099 248

921 575

LU

438 053

499 621

437 419

366 718

LV

480 330

547 840

479 635

402 110

MT

332 525

379 262

332 044

278 375

NL

13 394 277

15 276 835

13 374 887

11 213 081

NO

3 106 500

3 543 117

3 102 003

2 600 621

PL

34 583 085

39 443 717

34 533 022

28 951 388

PT

6 072 075

6 925 501

6 063 284

5 083 265

RO

11 604 041

13 234 982

11 587 243

9 714 376

SE

3 246 409

3 702 690

3 241 709

2 717 746

SI

1 478 674

1 686 501

1 476 533

1 237 879

SK

4 206 047

4 797 204

4 199 958

3 521 111

XI
(Northern Ireland)

883 013

1 007 119

881 734

739 218

III.Revenue from the EU ETS

Table C. Revenue from the auctioning of general and aviation allowances in the EU ETS (EU 27, 2023)

EU Member State

Revenue in 2023 (million EUR)

General allowances

Aviation allowances

Austria (AT)

428.4

10.0

Belgium (BE)

739.9

13.6

Bulgaria (BG)

1 167.6

4.5

Cyprus (CY)

110.3

3.3

Czechia (CZ)

771.3

4.8

Germany (DE)

7 582.5

74.1

Denmark (DK)

403.9

12.2

Estonia (EE)

358.8

1.3

Greece (EL)

1 441.8

24.6

Spain (ES)

3 514.0

70.3

Finland (FI)

571.5

10.1

France (FR)

2 060.1

53.2

Croatia (HR)

155.3

3.6

Hungary (HU)

434.9

4.6

Ireland (IE)

149.2

9.1

Italy (IT)

3 547.4

58.0

Lithuania (LT)

111.7

2.1

Luxemburg (LU)

0.0

1.7

Latvia (LV)

88.2

2.6

Malta (MT)

41.8

2.8

Netherlands (NL)

1 261.1

20.2

Poland (PL)

5 406.7

11.8

Portugal (PT)

726.7

18.3

Romania (RO)

571.8

8.8

Sweden (SE)

305.6

17.6

Slovenia (SI)

186.5

0.6

Slovakia (SK)

377.5

0.7

Table D. Revenue from the auctioning of general and aviation allowances (Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway and the UK for Northern Ireland, 2023)

Country

Revenue in 2023 (million EUR)

General allowances

Aviation allowances

Iceland

0.0

4.3

Liechtenstein

0.3

0.0

Norway

244.1

19.9

UK (Northern Ireland)

78.8

0.0

Table E. Revenue from the auctioning of allowances for the ETS Innovation Fund, the ETS Modernisation Fund and the Recovery and Resilience Facility (2023)

Fund supplied from the EU ETS

Revenue in 2023 (million EUR)

Innovation Fund

1 812.0

Modernisation Fund

5 611.4

Recovery and Resilience Facility

2 828.2

IV.EU ETS implementation framework

As explained in the main report, this section relies on the data reported by Italy under Article 21 of the ETS Directive for 2022 as a proxy to make year-to-year comparison possible. For all other countries 2023 data is used.

Table F. Accreditation and verification in the EU ETS (2023) 13

Aspect

Countries

Number

Number per country

Number of verifiers accredited by the national accreditation body – for installations

23

105

AT(2), BE(2), BG(3), CZ(5), DE(18), DK(3), EE(1), EL(6), ES(6), FI(4), FR(6), HR(3), HU(4), IT(10), LV(2), NL(2), NO(3), PL(8), PT(3), RO(5), SE(3), SI(2), SK(4)

Number of verifiers accredited by the national accreditation body - for aviation

9

20

CZ(1), DE(5), EL(3), ES(2), FR(2), IT(2), LV(1), PT(2), RO(2)

Number of active verifiers that were accredited by another country - for installations

24

56

AT(1), BE(3), BG(3), CY(2), CZ(1), EE(3), EL(1), ES(3), FR(1), HR(1), HU(2), IE(5), IS(2), LT(3), LU(4), MT(1), NL(2), NO(2), PL(3), PT(1), RO(2), SE(7), SK(1), XI(2)

Number of active verifiers that were accredited by another country - for aviation

26

45

AT(3), BE(3), BG(1), CY(2), DE(1), DK(1), EE(2), EL(1), ES(1), FI(1), FR(1), HR(1), HU(1), IE(2), IS(1), IT(2), LT(2), LU(2), MT(3), NL(2), NO(1), PL(3), PT(1), RO(3), SE(3), SK(1)

Number of complaints made about verifiers

3

48

DE(13), DK(15), ES(20)

Number of resolved complaints

3

47

DE(12), DK(15), ES(20)

Number of complaints from prior reports, not reported as resolved earlier and meanwhile resolved

0

0

-

Number of non-conformities for verifiers reported in the information exchange

6

56

AT(2), BG(6), DE(1), FI(21), HR(21), NO(5)

Number of non-conformities above resolved

6

51

AT(2), BG(5), DE(1), FI(17), HR(21), NO(5)

Number of non-conformities from prior reports, not reported as resolved earlier and meanwhile resolved

3

17

AT(2), BG(5), FI(10)

Verifiers suspended

0

0

-

Withdrawal of accreditation certificate

0

0

-

Scope of accreditation reduced

2

2

FI(1), PL(1)



Table G. Coordination between competent authorities that implement the EU ETS (2023)  14

Aspect

Number and list of countries

A central competent authority regularly reviews monitoring plans, annual emission reports and improvement reports in addition to local and regional authorities.

12

AT, BG, DE, ES, HR, HU, LT, NL, PL, SE, SI, XI

A central competent authority steers local and/or regional competent authorities by giving binding instructions and guidance.

5

BG, FR, NL, SK, XI

A central competent authority steers local and/or regional competent authorities by giving non- binding instructions and guidance.

5

AT, FI, LT, PL, PT

Regular meetings of competent authorities are organised.

10

BE, BG, DE, EL, ES, FR, NL, PT, SE, XI

Common training is organised for all competent authorities to ensure harmonised implementation of requirements.

8

AT, BG, FR, NL, PT, SE, SK, XI

A structured working or coordination group is established, where competent authority staff discuss implementation issues and develop common approaches.

11

BG, EL, ES, FR, HR, HU, NL, PL, PT, SE, XI



Table H. Administrative charges in the EU ETS (2023)  15

Aspect

Number and list of relevant countries
(charges expressed in EUR)

Installations

Fees charged to operators

15

AT, BG, CZ, DK, ES, FI, HU, IS, IT, NO, PL, PT, RO, SI, XI

Fees charged for permit issuance/monitoring plan approval

14

AT(100), BG(250), CZ(400), ES(983.35), FI(500), HU(246), IS(4 730), IT(750), NO(1 013), PL(19.23), PT(235.03), RO(360), SI(22.60), XI(8 442)

Fees charged for permit update

13

AT(100), BG(100), ES(393.33), FI(400), HU(130), IS(830), IT(700), NO(680), PL(2.35), PT(117.52), RO(360), SI(22.60), XI(597)

Fees charged for permit transfer

8

AT(100), FI(500), HU(130), IS(830), IT(400), PL(2.35), SI(22.60), XI(597)

Fees charged for permit surrender

3

AT(100), PL(2.35), XI(950)

Fees charged for an application to the New entrants reserve

8

AT(100), BG(500), HU(705), IS(3 480), PL(2.35), PT(1 645.42), SI(22.60), XI(1 581)

Annual subsistence charge

3

DK(4 854), IT(300), XI(5 762)

Aircraft operators

Fees charged to aircraft operators

14

AT, BG, DK, FI, HU, IE, IS, IT, LV, NO, PL, PT, RO, SI

Fees charged for approval of an emissions monitoring plan

13

AT(100), BG(500), FI(770), HU(570), IE(500), IS(4 100), IT(650), LV(374), NO(1 013), PL(2.35), PT(304.37), RO(2 000), SI(22.60)

Fees charged for approval of a change to an emissions monitoring plan

12

AT(100), BG(50), FI(280), HU(570), IS(1 280), IT(350), LV(200), NO(680), PL(2.35), PT(152.77), RO(500), SI(22.60)

Fees charged for approval of a monitoring plan for tonne-kilometre data

10

AT(100), BG(500), HU(570), IS(4 100), IT(700), LV(200), PL(2.35), PT(304.37), RO(2 500), SI(22.60)

Fees charged for approval of a change to a monitoring plan for tonne-kilometre data

9

AT(100), BG(50), HU(570), IS(1 280), LV(200), PL(2.35), PT(152.77), RO(500), SI(22.60)

Transfer of monitoring plan

4

AT(100), HU(570), IS(1 280), SI(22.60)

Surrender of monitoring plan

1

AT(100)



Table I. Compliance checks in the EU ETS (2023)  16

Type of check

Number and list of countries
(% or number per country)

Installations

Share of emissions reports checked for completeness and internal consistency (%)

30

AT(100%), BE(100%), BG(100%), CY(100%), CZ(100%), DE(100%), DK(100%), EE(100%), EL(100%), ES(100%), FI(100%), FR(100%), HR(100%), HU(100%), IE(80%), IS(100%), IT(100%), LT(100%), LU(100%), LV(100%), MT(100%), NL(100%), NO(100%), PL(100%), PT(100%), RO(100%), SE(100%), SI(100%), SK(100%), XI(100%)

Share of emissions reports checked for consistency with the monitoring plan (%)

30

AT(25%), BE(7%), BG(100%), CY(100%), CZ(45%), DE(100%), DK(100%), EE(100%), EL(100%), ES(90%), FI(100%), FR(100%), HR(100%), HU(100%), IE(80%), IS(100%), IT(30%), LT(80%), LU(100%), LV(100%), MT(100%), NL(20%), NO(100%), PL(100%), PT(100%), RO(100%), SE(5%), SI(100%), SK(100%), XI(100%)

Share of emissions reports cross-checked with allocation data (%)

25

AT(25%), BE(100%), BG(100%), CY(100%), CZ(30%), DK(100%), EE(100%), EL(100%), ES(46%), FI(100%), FR(100%), HU(100%), IE(100%), IS(100%), IT(30%), LT(80%), LU(100%), LV(100%), NL(20%), PL(100%), PT(100%), RO(100%), SI(100%), SK(100%), XI(100%)

Share of emissions reports cross-checked with other data (%).

22

AT(100%), BE(100%), BG(100%), CY(100%), CZ(25%), DK(78%), EE(100%), EL(100%), ES(49%), FR(100%), HR(100%), LT(80%), LU(100%), NL(10%), NO(100%), PL(20%), PT(100%), RO(100%), SE(100%), SI(100%), SK(100%), XI(100%)

Share of emissions reports analysed in detail (%).

25

AT(25%), BE(10%), BG(10%), CY(100%), CZ(45%), DK(72%), EE(100%), EL(50%), ES(18%), FI(100%), FR(30%), HR(100%), IE(80%), IS(100%), LT(100%), LU(100%), MT(100%), NL(25%), NO(100%), PL(100%), PT(100%), RO(100%), SE(5%), SK(100%), XI(100%)

Number of verified emissions reports rejected due to non-compliance

2

FR(1), RO(1)

Number of verified emissions reports rejected for other reasons

4

FR(13), LT(6), NO(14), PT(7)

Aircraft operators

Share of emissions reports checked for completeness and internal consistency (%)

25

AT(100%), BE(56%), BG(100%), CY(100%), CZ(100%), DE(100%), DK(100%), EE(100%), ES(100%), FI(100%), FR(100%), HR(100%), IE(100%), IS(100%), IT(100%), LU(100%), MT(100%), NL(100%), NO(100%), PL(100%), PT(100%), RO(100%), SE(100%), SI(100%), SK(100%)

Share of emissions reports checked for consistency with the monitoring plan (%)

24

AT(100%), BE(56%), BG(100%), CY(100%), CZ(50%), DE(100%), DK(100%), EE(100%), ES(100%), FI(100%), FR(100%), HR(100%), IE(100%), IS(100%), IT(80%), LU(100%), MT(100%), NL(100%), NO(100%), PL(100%), PT(100%), RO(100%), SI(100%), SK(100%)

Share of emissions reports cross-checked with other data (%)

25

AT(100%), BE(100%), BG(100%), CY(100%), CZ(100%), DE(100%), DK(100%), EE(100%), ES(100%), FI(100%), FR(100%), HR(100%), IE(33%), IS(100%), IT(100%), LT(100%), LU(100%), MT(100%), NL(100%), NO(100%), PT(100%), RO(100%), SE(100%), SI(100%), SK(100%)

Share of emissions reports analysed in detail (%)

23

AT(100%), BE(11%), BG(100%), CY(100%), CZ(16%), DE(100%), DK(50%), EE(100%), ES(100%), FI(100%), HR(100%), IE(33%), IS(100%), IT(50%), LU(100%), MT(100%), NL(41%), NO(100%), PL(100%), PT(100%), RO(100%), SE(94%), SK(100%)

Number of verified emissions reports rejected due to non-compliance

2

FR(2), PT(1)

Number of verified emissions reports rejected for other reasons.

2

FR(2), LT(1)


Table J. Measures to ensure compliance with the EU ETS (2023)

Compliance measures

Countries

Installations

Onsite inspections

18

AT, BG, CY, CZ, DE, EL, ES, FR, HR, HU, IE, LT, NL, NO, PL, RO, SE, SI

Preventive measures taken to ensure operator’s compliance

17

AT, BG, CZ, DE, DK, EE, ES, FI, FR, HR, HU, LU, NL, NO, PL, SE, SI

Ensuring that selling of emission allowances is prohibited in case of irregularities

7

AT, BG, CZ, DE, FR, SI, SK

Imprisonment possible

8

BE, CY, DK, EE, IE, LU, NO, SE

Aircraft operators

Onsite inspections

3

DE, NL, SE

Preventive measures taken to ensure aircraft operator’s compliance

2

AT, DE

Ensuring that selling of emission allowances is prohibited in
case of irregularities

13

AT, CY, DE, DK, EE, FI, FR, HR, IS, LU, NL, NO, SE

Imprisonment possible

6

CY, DK, IE, LU, NO, SE



Table K. Excess emissions penalties in the EU ETS (2023) 17

Penalty

Countries

Number of operators and country

Imposition of excess emission penalties on installations

10

38

CZ(1), DE(1), ES(3), FI(1), HU(9), IT(2), NO(1), PL(4), RO(13), SK(3)

Imposition of excess emission penalties on aircraft operators

4

9

DE(3), ES(4), IT(1), RO(1)



V.Link between the EU ETS and the Swiss ETS

Table L. Comparison of the EU ETS and the Swiss ETS - installations (2023)

System

EU ETS

Swiss ETS

General allowances auctioned

517 587 000

259 450

Free allocation of general allowances

537 443 682

3 917 667

Verified emissions from stationary installations

1 096 788 327

3 912 485

Table M. Comparison of the EU ETS and the Swiss ETS - aircraft operators (2023)

System

EU ETS

Swiss ETS

Aviation allowances auctioned

5 720 500

183 550

Free allocation of aviation allowances

EU aviation allowances
for EU ETS

Swiss aviation allowances
for Swiss ETS

Swiss aviation allowances
for Swiss ETS

EU aviation allowances
for EU ETS

22 078 845

461 708

533 033

379 412

Verified emissions from aircraft operators

EU ETS

Swiss ETS

Swiss ETS

EU ETS

53 416 176

712 360

770 726

861 289

(1)

Under the Protocol on Ireland/Northern Ireland of the EU-UK Withdrawal Agreement.

(2)

Directive 2003/87/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 13 October 2003 establishing a system for greenhouse gas emission allowance trading within the Union and amending Council Directive 96/61/EC ( OJ L 275 , 25.10.2003)

(3)

Category A installations

(4)

A subset of category A installations, with emissions below 25 000 tonnes CO2eq per year

(5)

Category B installations

(6)

Category C installations

(7)

Under Article 27 of the ETS Directive. Exclusions are notified every 5 years. An installation that exceeds the threshold in any calendar year is required to be re-entered into the scope of the EU ETS.

(8)

Under Article 27a (1) of the ETS Directive. An installation that exceeds the threshold in any calendar year is required to be re-entered into the scope of the EU ETS.

(9)

Under Article 27a (3) of the ETS Directive. An installation that exceeds the threshold in any calendar year is required to be re-entered into the scope of the EU ETS.

(10)

An example of a commercial aircraft operator is a passenger airline providing services to the public. An example of a non-commercial aircraft operator is a privately owned aircraft.

(11)

The figure relies on the data reported by Italy for 2022 as a proxy to make year-to-year comparison possible. For all other countries 2023 data is used.

(12)

The maximum number of countries is 30 because Liechtenstein did not have any active operators in 2023. XI is the country code for Northern Ireland. The table uses the data reported by Italy for 2022 as a proxy to make year-to-year comparison possible. For all other countries 2023 data is used.

 

(13)

The maximum number of countries is 30 because Liechtenstein did not have any active operators in 2023. XI is the country code for Northern Ireland. The table uses the data reported by Italy for 2022 as a proxy to make year-to-year comparison possible. For all other countries 2023 data is used.

(14)

The maximum number of countries is 30 because Liechtenstein did not have any active operators in 2023. XI is the country code for Northern Ireland.

(15)

The maximum number of countries is 30 because Liechtenstein did not have any active operators in 2023. XI is the country code for Northern Ireland. The table uses the data reported by Italy for 2022 as a proxy to make year-to-year comparison possible. For all other countries 2023 data is used.

(16)

The maximum number of countries is 30 because Liechtenstein did not have any active operators in 2023. XI is the country code for Northern Ireland. The table uses the data reported by Italy for 2022 as a proxy to make year-to-year comparison possible. For all other countries 2023 data is used.

(17)

The maximum number of countries is 30 because Liechtenstein did not have any active operators in 2023. XI is the country code for Northern Ireland.