<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<!DOCTYPE O_Doc_Ref SYSTEM "ORD.dtd">
<O_Doc_Ref O_Langue="en" O_Version_doc="4.0" O_Debut_ID="EN62015O0438">
   <Properties>
      <Property name="Juridiction">T</Property>
      <Property name="NumeroOrdre">0438</Property>
      <Property name="Annee">2015</Property>
      <Property name="Formation">9</Property>
      <Property name="Langue">EN</Property>
      <Property name="MessInFileNumber">L_Ord_Mess_Fr.xml</Property>
      <Property name="DtFilename">TRA-DT-FR-ORD_IRR-T-0438-2015-201601940-01_00.xml</Property>
      <Property name="TypeDoc">ORD</Property>
      <Property name="NatureAff">RD</Property>
      <Property name="CreatedFrom">Litige</Property>
      <Property name="EP_Mode">0</Property>
      <Property name="EP_ModeText">DEF</Property>
      <Property name="EP_Titre1"/>
      <Property name="EP_Titre2">ÉDITION PROVISOIRE DU 02/02/2016</Property>
      <Property name="EP_Titre3"/>
      <Property name="EP_Mention">1</Property>
      <Property name="EP_Mention_Texte">Texte pour publication</Property>
      <Property name="EP_IsMention_Texte">0</Property>
      <Property name="Version"/>
      <Property name="EP_Version">0</Property>
      <Property name="NEW">0</Property>
      <Property name="FileDoc">Document2</Property>
      <Property name="TypeOrd"/>
      <Property name="TOC_Position_NotVademecum">0</Property>
      <Property name="NumProc">1</Property>
      <Property name="TypeProc">P</Property>
      <Property name="NumSuite">1</Property>
      <Property name="LitFilePath">C:\Users\set\AppData\Local\Temp\canevas\Litige.xml</Property>
      <Property name="Created">Canevas 3.8.8 J 2/02/2016 10:23:57</Property>
      <Property name="FootNotes">False</Property>
      <Property name="EP_Titre0"/>
      <Property name="EP_DocDeTravail">0</Property>
      <Property name="EP_FormJug_Footer">0</Property>
      <Property name="EP_FormJug_ID">-</Property>
      <Property name="EP_FormJug_Texte"/>
      <Property name="Filename">^CONVERSION^rv@TRA-DOC-EN-ORD_IRR-T-0438-2015-201601940-06_90</Property>
      <Property name="serveur_nom">Doc2XML_2003_TRAD_SUIVI2</Property>
      <Property name="serveur_config_path">C:\Documents and Settings\gti_prod\Application Data\Doc2XML\PR_Doc2XML_2003_TRAD_SUIVI2.xml</Property>
      <Property name="watch">O:\GTiWebTools\Automates\Suivi_II\conversion\doc2xml_trad\In\</Property>
      <Property name="QuotationMark_Open">(</Property>
      <Property name="QuotationMark_Close">)</Property>
      <Property name="serveur_nom">Doc2XML_2003_PC_TRAD SV2_PUB</Property>
      <Property name="serveur_config_path">C:\Documents and Settings\gti_prod\Application Data\Doc2XML\PR_Doc2XML_2003_SV2_PUB.xml</Property>
      <Property name="watch">P:\GTiWebTools\Automates\Suivi_II\conversion\doc2xml_pub\In\</Property>
   </Properties>
   <O_Header_Gauche>
      <blockquote id="A010000000">
         <para style="header" id="A150000000">ORDER OF 9. 3. 2016 — CASE T‑438/15</para>
      </blockquote>
   </O_Header_Gauche>
   <O_Header_Droit>
      <blockquote id="A010000001">
         <para style="header" id="A150000001">PORT AUTONOME DU CENTRE ET DE L’OUEST AND OTHERS v COMMISSION</para>
      </blockquote>
   </O_Header_Droit>
   <O_Footer_Gauche>
      <blockquote id="A010000002">
         <para style="footer" id="A150000002">II - 8<emphasis role="tab" id="A400000000"/>
         </para>
      </blockquote>
   </O_Footer_Gauche>
   <O_Footer_Droit>
      <blockquote id="A010000003">
         <para style="footer" id="A150000003">
            <emphasis role="tab" id="A400000001"/>
            <emphasis role="tab" id="A400000002"/>II - 7</para>
      </blockquote>
   </O_Footer_Droit>
   <Affaire>
      <Introduction>
         <section id="A000000000">
            <para style="19Centre" id="A150000004">ORDER OF THE GENERAL COURT (Ninth Chamber)</para>
            <para style="19Centre" id="A150000005">9 March 2016 <footnote role="fNote" id="A110000000">
                  <number>*</number>
                  <para style="49FootnoteLangue" id="A150000006">
                     <emphasis role="suprscpt" id="A400000003"/>Language of the case: French.</para>
               </footnote>
            </para>
            <para style="71Indicateur" id="A150000007">
               <phrase role="QuotationMark_Open" id="A410000000">(</phrase>
               <phrase role="motcle" id="A410000001">State aid </phrase>
               <phrase role="Separator" id="A410000002">—</phrase>
               <phrase role="motcle" id="A410000003"> Corporation tax </phrase>
               <phrase role="Separator" id="A410000004">—</phrase>
               <phrase role="motcle" id="A410000005"> Aid in favour of Belgian ports granted by Belgium </phrase>
               <phrase role="Separator" id="A410000006">—</phrase>
               <phrase role="motcle" id="A410000007"> Commission letter informing the Member State of its preliminary assessment of that aid as being incompatible with the internal market and of the likely adoption of appropriate measures </phrase>
               <phrase role="Separator" id="A410000008">—</phrase>
               <phrase role="motcle" id="A410000009"> Measure not open to challenge </phrase>
               <phrase role="Separator" id="A410000010">—</phrase>
               <phrase role="motcle" id="A410000011"> Inadmissibility</phrase>
               <phrase role="QuotationMark_Close" id="A410000012">)</phrase>
            </para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000008">In Case T‑438/15,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000009">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="A400000004">Port autonome du Centre et de l’Ouest SCRL,</emphasis> established in La Louvière (Belgium), </para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000010">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="A400000005">Port autonome de Namur,</emphasis> established in Namur (Belgium), </para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000011">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="A400000006">Port autonome de Charleroi,</emphasis> established in Charleroi (Belgium), </para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000012">and</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000013">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="A400000007">Région wallonne </emphasis>(Belgium)<emphasis role="bold" id="A400000008">, </emphasis>
            </para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000014">represented by J. Vanden Eynde, lawyer,</para>
            <para style="72Alineadroite" id="A150000015">applicants,</para>
            <para style="19Centre" id="A150000016">v</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000017">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="A400000009">European Commission,</emphasis> represented by S. Noë and B. Stromsky, acting as Agents,</para>
            <para style="72Alineadroite" id="A150000018">defendant,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000019">APPLICATION for annulment of the decision, ostensibly contained in the Commission’s letter of 1 June 2015, finding that the corporation tax exemption for Belgian ports constitutes existing State aid that is incompatible with the internal market (State aid SA.38393 (2014/CP)),</para>
            <para style="19Centre" id="A150000020">THE GENERAL COURT (Ninth Chamber),</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000021">composed of G. Berardis (Rapporteur), President, O. Czúcz and A. Popescu, Judges, </para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000022">Registrar: E. Coulon,</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="A150000023">makes the following</para>
         </section>
      </Introduction>
      <O_Motif>
         <section id="B000000000">
            <para style="75Debutdesmotifs" id="B150000000">
               <emphasis role="bold" id="B400000000">Order</emphasis>
            </para>
            <section id="B000000001">
               <title style="04Titre1" id="B200000000">
                  <titlecontent id="B300000000">
                     <emphasis role="bold" id="B400000001">Background to the dispute</emphasis>
                  </titlecontent>
               </title>
               <blockquote id="B010000000">
                  <title id="B210000000">
                     <number>1</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000001">In 2013, the European Commission’s services sent a questionnaire to all Member States regarding the functioning and tax treatment of their ports in order to obtain a general overview of the situation and to clarify the position of ports with regard to EU State-aid rules. Following this, the Commission’s services exchanged a number of letters relating to that matter with the Belgian authorities.</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000001">
                  <title id="B210000001">
                     <number>2</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000002">By a letter of 9 July 2014, pursuant to Article 17 of Council Regulation (EC) No 659/1999 of 22 March 1999 laying down detailed rules for the application of Article [108 TFEU] (OJ 1999 L 83, p. 1), the Commission informed those authorities of its preliminary assessment of the Belgian rules on the tax treatment of ports, regarding the possible classification of those rules as State aid and their compatibility with the internal market. At the end of that letter, the Commission expressed the preliminary view that the corporation tax exemption for Belgian ports constituted incompatible State aid within the meaning of Article 107(1) TFEU and announced its intention to commence a cooperation procedure with the purpose of re-examining the scheme in question. It also informed the Belgian authorities that that re-examination might result in its proposing appropriate measures, pursuant to Article 18 of that regulation, with a view to abolishing the incompatible aid.</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000002">
                  <title id="B210000002">
                     <number>3</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000003">The Belgian authorities sent their comments to the Commission and, by a letter of 1 June 2015 (‘the contested letter’), the Commission’s services responded to that letter, stating as follows:</para>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="B150000004">‘… We have analysed the points that you raised. Taking these factors into account, I wish to inform you that the Commission’s services continue to take the preliminary view that the fact that the economic activities of the ports are not made subject to corporation tax constitutes State aid that is incompatible with the internal market for the following reasons:</para>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="B150000005">…</para>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="B150000006">Taking account of the legal precedents, the Commission’s services maintain the preliminary view expressed in their letter of 9 July 2014 … Consequently, I wish to inform Belgium that the Commission may be obliged to move to the next stage of the procedure and to submit to it formal proposals concerning appropriate measures to be taken by Belgium …’</para>
               </blockquote>
            </section>
            <section id="B000000002">
               <title style="04Titre1" id="B200000001">
                  <titlecontent id="B300000001">
                     <emphasis role="bold" id="B400000002">Procedure and forms of order sought</emphasis>
                  </titlecontent>
               </title>
               <blockquote id="B010000003">
                  <title id="B210000003">
                     <number>4</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000007">By an application lodged at the Court Registry on 30 July 2015, the applicants, namely the Port autonome du Centre et de l’Ouest SCRL, the Port autonome de Namur, the Port autonome de Charleroi and the Région wallonne, brought the present action.</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000004">
                  <title id="B210000004">
                     <number>5</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000008">By a document lodged at the Court Registry on 3 November 2015, the Commission raised an objection of inadmissibility under Article 130(1) of the Court’s Rules of Procedure. </para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000005">
                  <title id="B210000005">
                     <number>6</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000009">The applicants have not submitted any observations on that objection. </para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000006">
                  <title id="B210000006">
                     <number>7</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000010">By separate documents lodged at the Court Registry on 24 November 2015, the Port autonome de Liège and the Société régionale du port de Bruxelles applied for leave to intervene in support of the form of order sought by the applicants.</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000007">
                  <title id="B210000007">
                     <number>8</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000011">In the application, the applicants claim that the Court should:</para>
                  <itemizedlist id="B030000000">
                     <listitem id="B060000000">
                        <blockquote id="B010000008">
                           <title id="B210000008">
                              <number>–</number>
                           </title>
                           <para style="03Tiretlong" id="B150000012">declare the action admissible;</para>
                        </blockquote>
                     </listitem>
                     <listitem id="B060000001">
                        <blockquote id="B010000009">
                           <title id="B210000009">
                              <number>–</number>
                           </title>
                           <para style="03Tiretlong" id="B150000013">annul the contested letter;</para>
                        </blockquote>
                     </listitem>
                     <listitem id="B060000002">
                        <blockquote id="B010000010">
                           <title id="B210000010">
                              <number>–</number>
                           </title>
                           <para style="03Tiretlong" id="B150000014">order the Commission to pay the costs.</para>
                        </blockquote>
                     </listitem>
                  </itemizedlist>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000011">
                  <title id="B210000011">
                     <number>9</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000015">The Commission contends that the Court should:</para>
                  <itemizedlist id="B030000001">
                     <listitem id="B060000003">
                        <blockquote id="B010000012">
                           <title id="B210000012">
                              <number>–</number>
                           </title>
                           <para style="03Tiretlong" id="B150000016">dismiss the action as manifestly inadmissible;</para>
                        </blockquote>
                     </listitem>
                     <listitem id="B060000004">
                        <blockquote id="B010000013">
                           <title id="B210000013">
                              <number>–</number>
                           </title>
                           <para style="03Tiretlong" id="B150000017">order the applicants to pay the costs.</para>
                        </blockquote>
                     </listitem>
                  </itemizedlist>
               </blockquote>
            </section>
            <section id="B000000003">
               <title style="04Titre1" id="B200000002">
                  <titlecontent id="B300000002">
                     <emphasis role="bold" id="B400000003">Law</emphasis>
                  </titlecontent>
               </title>
               <blockquote id="B010000014">
                  <title id="B210000014">
                     <number>10</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000018">Under Article 130 of the Rules of Procedure, if a party applies, by a separate document, to the Court for a decision on inadmissibility or lack of competence, without going to the substance of the case, the Court may give a decision, by reasoned order, without taking further steps in the proceedings.</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000015">
                  <title id="B210000015">
                     <number>11</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000019">The Court considers in the present case that it has sufficient information from an examination of the documents before it and consequently finds that it is appropriate to rule without taking further steps in the proceedings.</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000016">
                  <title id="B210000016">
                     <number>12</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000020">First, it should be recalled that, unlike new aid, which is regulated by Article 108(2) and (3) TFEU, Article 108(1) TFEU provides that, in the case of existing aid, the Commission must, in cooperation with Member States, keep under constant review all existing systems of aid in those States and that it must propose to the latter any appropriate measures required by the progressive development of the functioning of the internal market.</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000017">
                  <title id="B210000017">
                     <number>13</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000021">Regulation No 659/1999 specifies, in its Articles 17 to 19, the procedure applicable to existing aid schemes in the following terms:</para>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="B150000022">‘Article 17</para>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="B150000023">Cooperation pursuant to Article [108](1) [TFEU]</para>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="B150000024">1.<emphasis role="tab" id="B400000004"/>The Commission shall obtain from the Member State concerned all necessary information for the review, in cooperation with the Member State, of existing aid schemes pursuant to Article [108](1) [TFEU]. </para>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="B150000025">2.<emphasis role="tab" id="B400000005"/>Where the Commission considers that an existing aid scheme is not, or is no longer, compatible with the [internal] market, it shall inform the Member State concerned of its preliminary view and give the Member State concerned the opportunity to submit its comments within a period of one month. In duly justified cases, the Commission may extend the prescribed period. </para>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="B150000026">Article 18</para>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="B150000027">Proposal for appropriate measures </para>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="B150000028">Where the Commission, in the light of the information submitted by the Member State pursuant to Article 17, concludes that the existing aid scheme is not, or is no longer, compatible with the [internal] market, it shall issue a recommendation proposing appropriate measures to the Member State concerned. The recommendation may propose, in particular: </para>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="B150000029">(a)<emphasis role="tab" id="B400000006"/>substantive amendment of the aid scheme, or</para>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="B150000030">(b)<emphasis role="tab" id="B400000007"/>introduction of procedural requirements, or </para>
                  <blockquote id="B010000018">
                     <para style="09Marge0avecretrait" id="B150000031">(c)<emphasis role="tab" id="B400000008"/>abolition of the aid scheme. </para>
                  </blockquote>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="B150000032">Article 19</para>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="B150000033">Legal consequences of a proposal for appropriate measures </para>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="B150000034">1.<emphasis role="tab" id="B400000009"/>Where the Member State concerned accepts the proposed measures and informs the Commission thereof, the Commission shall record that finding and inform the Member State thereof. The Member State shall be bound by its acceptance to implement the appropriate measures. </para>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="B150000035">2.<emphasis role="tab" id="B400000010"/>Where the Member State concerned does not accept the proposed measures and the Commission, having taken into account the arguments of the Member State concerned, still considers that those measures are necessary, it shall initiate proceedings pursuant to Article 4(4). Articles 6, 7 and 9 shall apply <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000011">mutatis mutandis</emphasis>.’</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000019">
                  <title id="B210000018">
                     <number>14</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000036">Article 4(4) and Articles 6 and 7 of Regulation No 659/1999 concern the formal investigation procedure provided for in Article 108(2) TFEU, while Article 9 governs the revocation of a decision adopted under that procedure.</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000020">
                  <title id="B210000019">
                     <number>15</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000037">According to the case-law predating the adoption of Regulation No 659/1999, a significant portion of which was codified in that regulation, whether the Commission does or does not propose appropriate measures is a matter which does not produce any definitive legal effect since, in the absence of acceptance by the Member State of the appropriate measures proposed, that Member State is not obliged to adopt them (judgment of 22 October 1996 in <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000012">Salt Union</emphasis> v <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000013">Commission</emphasis>, T‑330/94, ECR, EU:T:1996:154, paragraph 35).</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000021">
                  <title id="B210000020">
                     <number>16</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000038">It follows from Article 19(1) of Regulation No 659/1999 that, in a situation where the Member State accepts the appropriate measures proposed by the Commission, the Commission must record that finding and inform the Member State that it is bound by its acceptance to implement the appropriate measures. According to the case-law, the Commission’s decision recording the proposals of the Member State and rendering those proposals binding, according to that article, constitutes a challengeable act (judgments of 27 February 2014 in <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000014">Stichting Woonpunt and Others</emphasis> v <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000015">Commission</emphasis>, C‑132/12 P, ECR, EU:C:2014:100, paragraph 72, and of 11 March 2009 in <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000016">TF1</emphasis> v <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000017">Commission</emphasis>, T‑354/05, ECR, EU:T:2009:66, paragraphs 67 to 70).</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000022">
                  <title id="B210000021">
                     <number>17</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000039">In a situation where the Member State rejects the appropriate measures proposed by the Commission, the Commission is required, if it considers that such measures are still necessary for the proper functioning of the internal market, to initiate the procedure provided for in Article 108(2) TFEU. Once that procedure has been concluded, the Commission is required to adopt one of the decisions provided for under Article 7 of Regulation No 659/1999. The decision adopted as a result of that procedure produces binding legal effects which are capable of affecting the interests of the parties concerned and is therefore a challengeable act, since it concludes the procedure in question and decides definitively whether the measure under review is compatible with the rules applicable to State aid (judgments of 27 November 2003 in <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000018">Regione Siciliana</emphasis> v <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000019">Commission</emphasis>, T‑190/00, ECR, EU:T:2003:316, paragraph 45, and of 20 September 2011 in<emphasis role="italc" id="B400000020"> Regione autonoma della Sardegna and Others</emphasis> v <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000021">Commission</emphasis>, T‑394/08, T‑408/08, T‑453/08 and T‑454/08, ECR, EU:T:2011:493, paragraph 77).</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000023">
                  <title id="B210000022">
                     <number>18</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000040">In the present case, unlike the two situations described above, the contested letter was adopted in the context of the stage of cooperation between the Member State concerned and the Commission, referred to in Article 17(1) of Regulation No 659/1999, which may give rise to a proposal for appropriate measures adopted pursuant to Article 18 of that regulation.</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000024">
                  <title id="B210000023">
                     <number>19</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000041">As the Commission correctly submits, given that the proposal for appropriate measures is not a challengeable act (paragraph 15 above), preparatory acts occurring prior to that proposal for appropriate measures, such as the contested letter, do not, <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000022">a fortiori</emphasis>, constitute measures producing binding legal effects (see, to that effect, order of 14 May 2009 in <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000023">US Steel Košice</emphasis> v <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000024">Commission</emphasis>, T‑22/07, EU:T:2009:158, paragraph 55).</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000025">
                  <title id="B210000024">
                     <number>20</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000042">It should be recalled in this regard that, according to settled case-law, in the case of acts or decisions adopted by a procedure involving several stages, in particular where they are the culmination of an internal procedure, a measure will be open to review only if it is a measure definitively laying down the position of the institution upon conclusion of that procedure, and not a provisional measure intended to pave the way for that final decision (see order of 3 March 2015 in <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000025">Gemeente Nijmegen</emphasis> v <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000026">Commission</emphasis>, T‑251/13, ECR, EU:T:2015:142, paragraph 28 and the case-law cited).</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000026">
                  <title id="B210000025">
                     <number>21</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000043">That is manifestly not the position in the present case with regard to the contested letter, given that it is clear from the content of that letter that it concerns a ‘preliminary view’ of the Commission and that the latter may be obliged, as a result of that view, to move to the next stage of the procedure, which involves the submission of formal proposals concerning appropriate measures to be taken by the Kingdom of Belgium.</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000027">
                  <title id="B210000026">
                     <number>22</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000044">The applicants nevertheless rely on a line of case-law according to which a decision to initiate the formal investigation procedure can constitute a measure open to review under Article 263 TFEU (judgment of 23 October 2002 in <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000027">Diputación Foral de Guipúzcoa and Others</emphasis> v <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000028">Commission</emphasis>, T‑269/99, T‑271/99 and T‑272/99, ECR, EU:T:2002:258, paragraphs 38 to 40). They also submit that, according to the case-law, when the Commission adopts a decision confirming its preliminary assessment, that decision, if it is not contested within the period for bringing an action, becomes final (judgment of 10 May 2005 in <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000029">Italy</emphasis> v <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000030">Commission</emphasis>, C‑400/99, ECR, EU:C:2005:275, paragraph 17).</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000028">
                  <title id="B210000027">
                     <number>23</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000045">However, the fact remains that, unlike the decisions at issue in the cases relied on by the applicants, in the present case the contested letter constitutes neither a decision to initiate the formal investigation procedure, within the meaning of Article 108(2) TFEU and Article 4(4) of Regulation No 659/1999, nor a decision closing that procedure within the meaning of Article 7 of that regulation.</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000029">
                  <title id="B210000028">
                     <number>24</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000046">It is true that the case-law has established that, in certain cases, a decision to initiate the formal investigation procedure was liable to entail independent legal effects, in particular where it concerns new aid measures which have not been notified and which are still in the course of implementation (see order in <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000031">Gemeente Nijmegen</emphasis> v <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000032">Commission</emphasis>, paragraph 20 above, EU:T:2015:142, paragraph 30 and the case-law cited) or where, by that decision, the Commission classifies measures as being new aid but which, according to the Member State concerned, do not constitute aid or constitute existing aid (judgments of 9 October 2001 in <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000033">Italy</emphasis> v <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000034">Commission</emphasis>, C‑400/99, ECR, EU:C:2001:528, paragraphs 62 and 69, and of 23 October 2002 in <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000035">Diputación Foral de Álava and Others</emphasis> v <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000036">Commission</emphasis>, T‑346/99 to T‑348/99, ECR, EU:T:2002:259, paragraph 33) based on the standstill clause applicable to new aid under Article 108(3) TFEU.</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000030">
                  <title id="B210000029">
                     <number>25</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000047">However, in the present case, it is sufficient to note that the contested letter does not, even implicitly, constitute such a decision but is rather a letter adopted prior to a potential proposal of appropriate measures by the Commission in the context of the procedure for cooperation between the Member State and the Commission, as provided for by Article 17 of Regulation No 659/1999 in regard to an existing aid scheme.</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000031">
                  <title id="B210000030">
                     <number>26</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000048">It must be borne in mind that, in the context of such a procedure, the Member State remains free to apply the aid scheme concerned and to grant individual aid under that scheme so long as it does not decide to terminate or modify that scheme following the acceptance of appropriate measures proposed by the Commission (see, to that effect, judgment in <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000037">Stichting Woonpunt and Others</emphasis> v <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000038">Commission</emphasis>, paragraph 16 above, EU:C:2014:100, paragraphs 71 to 74), or so long as the Commission does not adopt a final negative decision under Article 7(5) of Regulation No 659/1999 declaring that aid scheme to be incompatible with the internal market (see judgment in <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000039">Italy</emphasis> v <emphasis role="italc" id="B400000040">Commission</emphasis>, paragraph 24 above, EU:C:2001:528, paragraph 48 and the case-law cited).</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000032">
                  <title id="B210000031">
                     <number>27</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000049">In the light of all those considerations, it must be concluded that the contested letter does not constitute an act producing binding legal effects and capable of being the subject of an action for annulment on the basis of Article 263 TFEU.</para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000033">
                  <title id="B210000032">
                     <number>28</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000050">Consequently, it is necessary to uphold the objection of inadmissibility raised by the Commission and to dismiss the action as inadmissible.</para>
               </blockquote>
            </section>
            <section id="B000000004">
               <title style="04Titre1" id="B200000003">
                  <titlecontent id="B300000003">
                     <emphasis role="bold" id="B400000041">Costs</emphasis>
                  </titlecontent>
               </title>
               <blockquote id="B010000034">
                  <title id="B210000033">
                     <number>29</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000051">Under Article 134(1) of the Rules of Procedure, the unsuccessful party is to be ordered to pay the costs if they have been applied for in the successful party’s pleadings. As the applicants have been unsuccessful, they must be ordered to pay the costs, in accordance with the form of order sought by the Commission. </para>
               </blockquote>
               <blockquote id="B010000035">
                  <title id="B210000034">
                     <number>30</number>
                  </title>
                  <para style="01PointnumeroteAltN" id="B150000052">Under Article 144(10) of the Rules of Procedure, if the proceedings in the main case are concluded before the application for leave to intervene has been decided upon, the applicant for leave to intervene and the main parties must each bear their own costs relating to the application to intervene. In the present case, the Court had not yet given a ruling on the applications for leave to intervene submitted by the Port autonome de Liège and the Société régionale du port de Bruxelles at the at the time of ruling on the admissibility of the main action by way of the present order. The Port autonome de Liège and the Société régionale du port de Bruxelles must for that reason bear their own costs, in accordance with that provision.</para>
               </blockquote>
            </section>
         </section>
      </O_Motif>
      <Dispositif>
         <section id="D000000000">
            <para style="48DispositifIntroduction" id="D150000000">On those grounds,</para>
            <para style="19Centre" id="D150000001">THE GENERAL COURT (Ninth Chamber)</para>
            <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000002">hereby orders:</para>
            <orderedlist id="D020000000">
               <listitem id="D060000000">
                  <blockquote id="D010000000">
                     <title id="D210000000">
                        <number>1.</number>
                     </title>
                     <para style="08Dispositif" id="D150000003">
                        <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000000">The action is dismissed as inadmissible.</emphasis>
                     </para>
                  </blockquote>
               </listitem>
               <listitem id="D060000001">
                  <blockquote id="D010000001">
                     <title id="D210000001">
                        <number>2.</number>
                     </title>
                     <para style="08Dispositif" id="D150000004">
                        <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000001">The Port autonome du Centre et de l’Ouest SCRL, the Port autonome de Namur, the Port autonome de Charleroi and the Région wallonne shall bear their own respective costs and pay those incurred by the European Commission.</emphasis>
                     </para>
                  </blockquote>
               </listitem>
               <listitem id="D060000002">
                  <blockquote id="D010000002">
                     <title id="D210000002">
                        <number>3.</number>
                     </title>
                     <para style="08Dispositif" id="D150000005">
                        <emphasis role="bold" id="D400000002">The Port autonome de Liège and the Société régionale du port de Bruxelles shall bear their own costs.</emphasis>
                     </para>
                  </blockquote>
                  <para style="02AlineaAltA" id="D150000006">Luxembourg, 9 March 2016.</para>
               </listitem>
            </orderedlist>
         </section>
      </Dispositif>
      <O_Signatures>
         <section id="E000000000">
<para style="77Signatures" id="E150000000">E. Coulon<emphasis role="tab" id="E400000000"/>
               <emphasis role="tab" id="E400000001"/>G. Berardis</para>
<para style="77Signatures" id="E150000001">Registrar<emphasis role="tab" id="E400000002"/>
               <emphasis role="tab" id="E400000003"/>President</para>

</section>
      </O_Signatures>
   </Affaire>
</O_Doc_Ref>