Brussels, 18.10.2018

SWD(2018) 439 final

COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT

Accompanying the document

REPORT FROM THE COMMISSION TO THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND THE COUNCIL

on the 2015-2016 implementation of Regulation (EC) No 561/2006 on the harmonisation of certain social legislation relating to road transport and of Directive 2002/15/EC on the organisation of the working time of persons performing mobile road transport activities

(29th report from the Commission on the implementation of the social legislation relating to road transport)

{COM(2018) 698 final}


1. Social legislation in road transport – objectives and key provisions

The EU social rules in road transport are established by four interrelated acts : Regulation (EC) No 561/2006, which establishes rules on driving times, breaks and rest periods for professional drivers, Regulation (EU) No 165/2014 on recording equipment in road transport, Directive 2002/15/EC, which sets out complementary provisions on the organisation of the working time of persons performing mobile road transport activities and Directive 2006/22/EC, which determines minimum requirements for enforcement of these rules.

Regulation (EC) No 561/2006 applies to employed and self-employed drivers engaged in the carriage by road of goods where the maximum permissible mass of the vehicle exceeds 3.5 tonnes and of passengers by vehicles carrying more than nine persons including the driver. The maximum weekly driving time of a driver should not exceed 56 hours (provided that no more than 90 hours are driven in any two consecutive weeks). The total daily driving time should not exceed 9 hours, although twice a week it can be extended to 10 hours. Breaks should last for at least 45 minutes (which may be separated into a break of 15 minutes followed by 30 minutes) and should be taken not later than 4.5 hours of driving period. The daily rest period is determined at the level of minimum 11 hours, which can be reduced three times a week to 9 hours.

The Commission has undertaken an ex-post evaluation 1 of the social rules which concluded that the legislations remain a relevant tool, but it is only partially effective. The effects in terms of enhancing road safety were positive. However, although road safety levels have improved in the period covered by the evaluation, the impact of the social legislation could not be discerned from the impacts of other road safety measures implemented across Member States. The insufficient effectiveness and efficiency of the social legislation is mainly due to the lack of clarity of certain rules, leading to diverging national interpretations and application of the rules, inconsistent and ineffective enforcement practices and a lack of administrative cooperation.

This is the reason why the Commission has tabled two proposals 2 on 31 May 2017 revising the social rules where discussions are under way since summer 2017 in the European Parliament and the Council.

Regulation (EU) No 165/2014 repealed Council Regulation (EEC) No 3821/85 on recording equipment in road transport. The new Regulation sets out obligations and requirements in relation to the construction, installation, use, testing and control of tachographs used in road transport, in order to verify compliance with the provisions of Regulation (EC) No 561/2006 It also aims at reducing administrative burden and making fraud to the tachograph more difficult. The smart tachograph will be fitted in vehicles registered for the first time as of 15 June 2019. It will feature a new set of advanced communication capabilities with respect to the current digital tachograph, such as satellite geo-localization or short range communication for the transmission of information to enforcement authorities. Those communication capabilities will broaden the areas of enforcement where the tachograph is applied, extending it to, for instance, the control of cabotage operations or the application of the rules on the posting of drivers.

Directive 2002/15/EC, known as the “Road Transport Working Time Directive”, applies to mobile workers such as drivers, crew and other travelling staff, both with the employment or self-employment status. The Directive complements Regulation (EC) No 561/2006 by putting in place limitations on the maximum weekly and maximum average weekly working time of workers in the road transport sector as well as adequate breaks and night work provisions. Working time is defined in the Directive as time devoted to all road transport activities, including driving, loading and unloading, assisting passengers boarding and disembarking from the vehicle, cleaning and technical maintenance and all other work intended to ensure the safety of transport operation. Specific time limits are set out in relation to weekly working time (excluding breaks and periods of availability) which amounts to maximum 48 hours a week, which may be extended to 60 hours, provided that over four months, an average of 48 hours a week is maintained. Moreover, a limitation to 10 hours on daily working time is introduced in case of night work. Each mobile worker is obliged to take a break after working consecutively for 6 hours, which should be at least 30 minutes, if working hours range from six to nine hours and at least 45 minutes, if working time equals to more than nine hours.

Directive 2006/22/EC also called the "Enforcement Directive" aims at verifying compliance and ensuring application of the driver's hours rules established by Regulation (EC) No 561/2006 and Regulation (EU) No 165/2014. The Directive promotes harmonised enforcement of the social rules in road transport by means of minimum requirements for the uniform and effective checks to be carried out by Member States. The minimum threshold of checks of the total number of days worked by drivers falling under the scope of Regulation (EC) No 561/2006 and Regulation (EU) No 165/2014 is set at 3% from 2010. In addition, the total number of working days actually checked should be carried out in a proportional manner for checks at the roadside and at premises of transport undertakings, 30 % and 50 % respectively. In order to encourage cooperation between Member States, an obligation of minimum 6 concerted roadside checks per year undertaken by two or more enforcement authorities was introduced.

This Staff working Document is accompanying the Report and provides more national figures and details as well as updates on other relevant aspects in the field.

2. Checks

As mentioned in the report, total working days checked in the EU continued to decrease since 2013-2014. However, looking at the national figures the decrease of around -12.8% of working days checked seemed to mainly result from the lower number of working days checked reported by Germany, Romania and France 3 .

Overall, the majority of Member States performed significantly more working days checked than required. If 100% represents the minimum threshold percentage of 3%, the top five Member States are France (395%), Germany (382%), Bulgaria (375%), Austria (359%) and Latvia (340%), which accounted for more than half of the working days checked in the EU (around 68 out of 131 million). Compared to the last report, Croatia and Lithuania made great improvements and now meet the threshold of 3%.

Only three Member States did not meet the minimum threshold, namely Greece (5% out of 100%), Netherlands (72%) and Malta (94%).

The Netherlands have applied since 2009 a "monitoring based on trust" system where 64 road transport undertakings have concluded an enforcement agreement with the Environment and Transport inspectorate. The agreement covered over 2.8 million days worked by drivers during 2015-2016 which are in addition to the 1.2 million working days checked reported by the Netherlands. Adding these figures together would allow the Netherlands to meet the minimum threshold. The Dutch authorities informed the Commission that the continuous development and expansion of the risk analysis enables the Dutch inspectorates to focus its efforts on those road transport undertakings whose level of compliance is poor. Furthermore, non-compliant undertakings fall under specialised enforcement and are subject to a rigorously applied corrective procedure.

The Directive also requires that at least 50% of the total number of working days checked should be done through checks at the premises of undertakings and at least 30% on the roadside. However, looking at the number of Member States which have met the threshold, only the following six Member State have the required balanced share between working days checked at premises and the roadside: Bulgaria (59% of working days checked at premises), Cyprus (52%), Latvia (57%), Luxembourg (68%), Romania (51%) and Slovakia (58%).

Based on the figures reported the upward trend continues as regards working days checked at the premises with the EU average rising to 26% compared to 23% in 2013-2014 and 18% in 2009-2010. The most significant improvements compared to the last report were reported by Romania (rise from 14% to 51%) and by Luxembourg (from 39% to 68%). Both Member States have now met the threshold.

Ireland continues to be the only Member State which has not met the threshold for the roadside checks because 93% of total working days are checked at the premises. However, the reason seems to be that not many other non-Irish, except British registered vehicles are circulating on Irish roads.

3. Checks compared to the number of enforcement officers and equipment to analyse tachographs

Based on the number of enforcement officers reported from all Member States, the number of control officers involved in checks remained stable with a slight increase from 61,211 in 2013-2014 to 61,503 in 2015-2016. The number of enforcement officers trained to analyse the digital tachograph has continued to decrease by 5.7% as well as the units of equipment provided to control officers to analyse the tachograph by 5.5% compared to the last report.

Table 1: Overview of national enforcement capacity in 2015-2016 per Member State

Member
States

Control officers involved in checks

Control officers trained to analyse the digital tachograph

Units of equipment provided to control officers to analyse the tachograph

AT

1150

1150

485

BE

3654

3510

123

BG

198

198

220

HR

315

315

150

CY

136

10

8

CZ

693

693

136

DK

68

68

31

EE

206

58

19

FI

455

207

109

FR

6000

6000

3500

DE

16795

4528

2321

EL

1171

437

350

HU

700

600

350

IE 4

11

11

11

IT

11309

1333

304

LV

28

28

12

LT

426

148

55

LU

26

20

15

MT

2

2

1

NL

100

300

85

PL 5

1344

1193

240

PT

14909

1315

343

RO

318

318

318

SK

40

41

40

SL

80

310

36

ES

512

395

445

SE

249

227

205

UK

608

310

310

Total

61,503

23,725

10,222

4. Roadside checks

As mentioned in the report, in general 32% of vehicles checked at the roadside are from another EU country 6 . However, in some Member States the percentage of vehicles from another EU country constitutes more than half: namely in Luxembourg (64%), Belgium (62%), Austria (61%), France (60%), the Netherlands (54%) and the UK (53%). The geographic location and volume of transit operations may in certain Member States play a factor. Member States whose share of checking vehicles registered in non-EU country was the largest are Slovenia (43%), Croatia (23%) and Lithuania (21%). A complete overview per Member State can be found in Table 2 below.

Table 2: Share of checked vehicles on the roadside by country of registration

Member
States

Nationals

Non-nationals

Third
nationals

AT

35%

61%

4%

BE

34%

62%

3%

BG

71%

14%

15%

HR

65%

12%

23%

CY

100%

0%

0%

CZ

55%

41%

4%

DK 7

EE

85%

12%

2%

FI

FR

38%

60%

1%

DE

60%

35%

5%

EL

82%

11%

7%

HU

56%

33%

11%

IE

95%

5%

0%

IT

86%

13%

1%

LV

57%

33%

10%

LT

46%

33%

21%

LU

35%

64%

1%

MT

67%

33%

0%

NL

44%

54%

2%

PL

66%

16%

19%

PT

97%

3%

0%

RO

83%

10%

7%

SK

45%

48%

7%

SL

30%

28%

43%

ES

89%

10%

1%

SE

56%

41%

2%

UK

45%

53%

3%

EU average

63%

32%

5%

5. Roadside checks – type of tachograph

According to Article 2 of Directive 2006/22/EC, the threshold of minimum checks of number of days worked by drivers of vehicles will be raised to 4% once 90% of vehicles checked are equipped with a digital tachograph. Compared to the last report, the share of vehicles checked at the roadside that were equipped with the digital tachograph increased from 64% to 72% 8 . There is therefore no base to raise the threshold of minimum checks to 4% for the time being. The highest share of digital tachograph (above 80%) was found during roadside check in Austria (91%), Luxembourg (86%), France (85%), Slovakia (82%) and Sweden (82%). In contrast, the lowest percentage of digital tachograph was reported in Cyprus (28%) and Greece (27%). Table 3 below provides a full overview.

Table 3: Overview of the number of vehicles stopped for roadside check by type of tachograph

Member
States

Analogue
tachograph

% analogue

Digital
tachograph

% digital

AT

23,568

9%

240,479

91%

BE

14,449

27%

38,871

73%

BG

70,375

24%

225,521

76%

HR

18,864

61%

12,020

39%

CY

4,759

72%

1,841

28%

CZ

37,287

29%

89,479

71%

DK 9

EE

3,934

49%

4,094

51%

FI 10

FR

115,617

15%

659,731

85%

DE

523,487

18%

2,368,617

82%

EL

29,783

73%

11,025

27%

HU

23,203

16%

120,007

84%

IE

2,293

24%

7,068

76%

IT

308,395

46%

361,310

54%

LV

10,258

39%

15,794

61%

LT

31,188

51%

29,710

49%

LU

415

14%

2,598

86%

MT

15

38%

24

62%

NL

7,248

22%

25,723

78%

PL

319,046

63%

190,055

37%

PT

34,600

56%

27,066

44%

RO

172,162

53%

154,926

47%

SK

2,468

18%

11,443

82%

SL

7,207

37%

12,127

63%

ES

133,457

29%

325,030

71%

SE

8,143

18%

36,561

82%

UK

72,269

39%

112,861

61%

Total

1,977,872

28%

5,084,766

72%

6. Checks at premises

As indicated in the report, the total share of working days checked at premises has slightly risen by 1%. In total, Member States checked around 663,000 drivers during 2015-2016 which constitutes 12% of drivers compared to 2013-2014. However, there are Member States who significantly increased the numbers of drivers checked at the premises (Hungary by 196 %, Finland by 133% and Luxembourg by 70%). Other Member States covered significantly less drivers during their checks, namely Ireland (-90%), Greece (-70%), Romania (-67%) and Portugal (-55%).

At the same time, the share of drivers checked at the premises compared to all drivers controlled at premises and roadside, continued to increase throughout the years with 10% in 2015-2016 (9% share in 2013-2014 and 7% in 2011-2013 and 5% in 2009-2010). Table 4 below provides an overview of this share across Member States.

The offence rate per undertaking was extremely high in Latvia (553 offences per undertaking checked), Poland (81 offences), Sweden (76 offences), Germany (65 offences) and Ireland (30 offences).

Figure 4: Share of working days checked at premises checks from 2011-2016 by Member States

7. Offences – detection rate

Like in the last reporting period, it is almost the same small group of Member States who detected over two thirds (73%) of all offences detected. These countries are Germany (32% of total offences), Poland (16%), Austria (11%), Latvia (8%) and Italy (7%). The average share of offences detected on the roadside is around 58% and 42% at the premises of undertakings. Significant disparities continue to exist between Member States as well illustrated in Figure 5 with offence rates. Almost the same Member States are marking the lowest offence rate in the EU: 0.04 in Bulgaria, 0.38 in Hungary, 0.53 in France, 0.99 in Romania, even though they are among the top seven Member Stats with the highest working days checked in the EU. At the same time, the following Member States have very high offence rates: 16.89 in Latvia, 8.34 in Greece, 7.59 in Austria, 6.01 in Poland and 6.29 in Cyprus. An important increase in the offence rate can be observed in Greece 11 (from 3.10 to 8.34) Luxembourg (from 1.33 to 5.01) and Poland (2.69 to 6.01), whereas a drop was reported by Lithuania (4.07 to 1.9) and Malta (3.03 to 1.61) compared to the last report. The table in Figure 5 provides an overview of the offence rate development since 2011. Given these discrepancies, the enforcement practices across the EU should be aligned, leading to harmonised checks that have similar outcomes. The Commission is currently in the process of establishing a common training curriculum for EU enforcers to ensure that the initial and continuing training enforcers in the EU adhere to a minimum standard and to ensure that enforcement practices are harmonised.

8. Offences detected at roadside

In total, 58% of the total offences were detected on the roadside in the EU, which represents a decrease compared to 63% in the last report. The offence rates found on the roadside were very diverse 12 across the EU. Compared to the EU average of 2.07 offence rates are in particular high in Greece 13 (11.17), Austria (8.69) and significantly more than the EU average in Slovakia (3.51) Ireland (3.38), Sweden (3.29) and Poland (3.21). Very low offence rates at the roadside were reported in Bulgaria (0.08), Hungary (0.32), Latvia (0.49), Finland (0.5) and France (0.55). A considerable increase in detection rate could be seen in Greece (4.64 to 11.17) Romania (from 0.42 to 1.74), Poland (1.22 to 3.21) and in the Czech Republic (1.11 to 2.59). An important decrease in the offence rate could be observed in Estonia (4.33 to 2.39), in Lithuania (5.77 to 2.33) and Latvia (1.68 to 0.49).

However, in some of the Member States, the numbers of detected offences related to non-national vehicles prevail, namely Luxembourg (84%), Slovenia (79%) Hungary (68%), Belgium (65%), Austria, Bulgaria and France (64%), Sweden (63%) and Lithuania (61%). This may be explained by the fact that many Member States mentioned above performed more controls on non-national vehicles. However, as for Bulgaria, Hungary, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Poland, Romania, Slovenia and Sweden, the offences detected on foreign registered vehicles appear more disproportionate.

9. Offences detected at the premises

Offence rates at the premises of undertakings in the EU are also very diverging. Indeed, several Member States are well above the EU average of 4.19 with the highest detection rate in Latvia (29.27), Poland (12.04), Germany (11.27), Cyprus (10.61) and the Netherlands (9.87). This stands in contrast with countries with a very low detection rate such as Bulgaria (0.02), Croatia (0.02), Portugal (0.06), Romania (0.27), Greece (0.31), France (0.42), UK (0.48), Spain (0.63), Malta (0.65) and Hungary (0.79). The majority of these countries, except for Croatia and Malta had also reported very low detection rate in the last report.

Compared to the 2013-2014 reporting period, there is a significant rise in detection rates noted in Poland (from 5.42 to 12.04), Finland (from 3.2 to 6.13), and Luxembourg (from 1.1 to 6.69). In contrast, the detection rate at premises has decreased significantly in Germany (14.01 to 11.27), Malta (4.25 to 0.65) and Sweden (5.41 to 3.89).

Table 5: Breakdown of offences found on the roadside and premises checks in 2015-2016

Checks at

Breaks

Rest periods

Driving time

Driving time records

Recording equipment

Lack/availability of records for other work

Roadside

16%

26%

16%

15%

18%

9%

Premises

26%

21%

10%

33%

5%

5%

Total

21%

24%

13%

24%

11%

7%

Figure 5 14 : Total offence rate at the roadside and premises checks by Member States between 2011-2016

10. Categories of infringements detected at roadside

The main types of infringements detected at the roadside checked by Member States 15 remained on average relatively similar to the last report in terms of share to the total offences detected at the roadside: breaks (decreased from 17% to 16%), rest periods (increased from 25% to 26%), driving time (decreased from 18% to 16%), driving time record for the preceding 28 days (decreased from 17% to 15%) as well as lack and availability of record for other work remained at 9%. In contrast, the offences detected regarding recording equipment increased from 13% to around 18% of the total offences at the roadside. Offences on the recording equipment comprise offences on the incorrect functioning of the tachograph as well as their misuse and manipulation. On average manipulation and misuse of the tachograph constituted 16% of the overall offences (11% in 2013-2014) at the roadside, so around 317,600 offences between 2015-2016. In Germany (30%), Poland (33%) and the UK (33%) manipulation and misuse of the tachograph made up even around a third of their offences found. However, national authorities, among them the Dutch, informed the Commission, that tachograph fraud and manipulation techniques became increasingly sophisticated and makes monitoring and enforcement more difficult and take up a large amount of available inspection capacity, so the real number of offences is likely to be much higher.

Looking at national figures, the detected infringements on driving time were in particular high in Luxembourg (35%), while offences on breaks were high in Cyprus (31%), Ireland (30%), Slovakia (35%) and Sweden (38%). Offences in rest periods were in particular significant in Belgium (36%), Luxembourg (37%), Romania (40%), Slovakia (38%), Spain (40%) and the UK (42%). In contrast to the low EU average regarding the infringement of providing the driving records, it constitutes a significant share in individual Member States, such as in Bulgaria (33%), the Czech Republic (33%), Italy (41%), Latvia (47%) and Lithuania (33%).

11. Categories of infringements detected at premises

Compared to the last report, offences detected at the premises 16 of undertakings are decreasing, namely on driving time (14% to 10%), breaks (33% to 26%), rest period (24% to 21%) and on lack and availability of records for other work (6% to 5%). Offences on recording equipment rose from 4% to 5% and there is a sharp increase of offences detected on driving time records from 19% to 33%, which have to be kept at least for one year by the transport undertakings. The latter offence is significant in the Czech Republic (54% of national offences detected at premises), Italy (69%) and Poland (80%). A possible explanation was given by the Italian authorities which explained that the low fines for missing driving records would encourage drivers and operators to claim that they are not in possession of driving time records rather than risking to be fined for other offences that are subject to significantly higher fines. Driving time offences were also very high in Greece (44%) 17 , Lithuania (36%), Malta (57%) 18 , Portugal (32%) and Slovenia (35%). Offences on breaks were frequently detected in Austria (56%), Belgium (41%), Finland (46%), Germany (45%), Ireland (55%) and Luxembourg (41%). Infringements on rest periods constituted an important share in Estonia (53%), Greece (52%), Hungary (56%) and Romania (54%). Offences on recording equipment constitute 4% and amount to around 48,800 in total during 2015-2016. Their national share was in particular high in Croatia (22%) and the Netherlands (28%). Infringements on the lack and availability of records of other work were in particular high in Sweden where they constituted 46% of the national offences detected at the premises.

12. Cooperation between Member States

According to Directive 2006/22/EC, Member States are obliged to undertake not less than six concerted roadside checks per year with at least one other Member State. Four Member States 19 did not provide information on the number of concerted checks. Out of the Member States that did provide information on checks, 15 Member States 20 met the required number of concerted checks per year.

Table 6 below presents the number concerted checks and exchange of experience carried-out by Member States in 2015-2016. It also provides an overview of the focus of these concerted checks and exchange of experience and which Member States cooperated.

Table 6: Overview of concerted checks per Member States

Austria

Concerted checks:

·6 a year, ECR/TIPSOL Member States

Exchange of experience, data, staff:

·6 bilateral (32 staff), 4 multilateral (10 staff)

Subject for exchange: driving time checks, manipulation of recording equipment, technical checks, securing of loads. ECR/TIPSOL Member States

Belgium

No data provided

Bulgaria

Concerted checks:

·1 joint check with Romanian control bodies (ARR) in Romania and Bulgaria

Exchange of information on detected infringements committed by Bulgarian drivers in Germany, Hungary, Austria, Spain, the UK, Italy, Latvia, Romania and Slovenia.

Croatia

No information provided

Cyprus

·29 road transport inspectors at the Department of Road Transport and 80 members of the Cypriot traffic and transport police received theoretical and practical training on roadside checks.

·In December 2016, two inspectors from the Labour Inspection Department took part in a week-long training programme on tachographs and driving hours organised by the Austrian Ministry of Transport, in cooperation with the corresponding Austrian government department.

Czech Republic

2015:
Concerted checks:

·3 joint inspections in Czech Republic

·5 joint inspections with Germany, 1 with Poland, 1 with Slovakia and 1 with Hungary.

·Inspections carried out in mutual cooperation with Germany’s BAG, Poland’s ITD, Slovakia’s NIP and Hungary’s NHK.

Exchange of experience:

·Multilateral exchange scheme conducted in Poland, France and the Netherlands; workshop focusing on ADR – Germany (always with one representative from the Czech Republic)

·Intensive cooperation within the ECR group, focused exchange of experienced related to checks on social legislation, detection of manipulation and fraud involving tachographs, ADR inspections, checks on the technical state of vehicles and performance of low-speed weighing.

2016:
Concerted checks:

·5 joint inspections in Czech Republic

·5 joint inspections with Germany, 2 with Poland, 1 with Slovakia and 1 with Hungary.

·The inspections were carried out in mutual cooperation with Germany’s BAG, Poland's ITD, Slovakia's NIP, Hungary's NHK and inspectors from the UK.

Exchange of experience:

·Multilateral exchange scheme conducted in Belgium, France, Poland and Hungary; workshop focusing on manipulation and fraud involving tachographs: Poland (always with one participant from the Czech Republic)

·Intensive cooperation within the ECR group, focusing on the exchange of experiences relating to ADR inspections, checks on social legislation and the detection of manipulation and fraud involving tachographs. Deployment of experts on the above topics. Attendance at discussions on those topics by WP.15 representatives responsible for legislation on the carriage of dangerous goods (ADR).

Denmark

·The National Police participated in (concerted) checks arranged by TISPOL. No other concerted checks were recorded.

Exchange of experience:

·The National Police exchanges information concerning inspection procedures, data, etc., with other Member States upon request. It also asks other Member States about their inspection procedures, etc., as required.

Estonia

2015:

·Estonian Police authorities carried out common road side checks 1 time with the Latvian and Lithuanian enforcement authorities and 1 time with the Finnish Police.

2016:

·Estonian Police authorities initiated common road side checks 1 time with the Latvian and Lithuanian enforcement authorities and 1 time with the Finnish Police.

Finland

No information provided

France

In both 2015 and 2016, France participated in 7 concerted checks each year, as an active member of ECR. The focus of these controls was cabotage, roadworthiness tests, transportation of dangerous goods, passenger transport, tachograph fraud and European social regulations.

Exchange of experiences:

·France organised in both 2015 and 2016 a bilateral cooperation session with Germany.

·France participated in multilateral cooperation exchanges in 2015 and 2016 organised by ECR members in the Netherlands, Poland, Hungary, and the UK

Germany

·Experience of ‘manipulation of digital recording equipment’ exchanged at national level between the police, the federal-state inspection authorities and the Federal Goods Transport Office

Concerted checks:

·Total of 14 joint checks with other ECR countries, 12 of which involved TISPOL

Exchange of experience:

·The Federal Goods Transport Office was notified of three exchanges in total. Only Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania provided data relating to joint initiatives.

Greece

No information provided

Hungary

2015:

Concerted checks:

·3 Hungary-Slovenia checks

·3 Hungary-Croatia checks

·1 Hungary-Romania checks

·Annual regional multilateral roadside checks – 3 days in Zala, Hungary with the participation of CZ, DE, SI, AT, SK, PL, RO, FI, BG, Ukraine, RS experts.

2016:

Concerted checks:

·3 Hungary-Slovenia checks

·4 Hungary-Croatia checks

·2 (x 2 days) Hungary-Romania

·Annual regional multilateral roadside checks – 3 days in Zala, Hungary with the participation of Ukraine, SI, CZ, SK, PL, DE, BG, SE, HR, RO.

Exchange of experience:

·In 2016 participation at ECR exchanges in Brussels, Biarritz and organisation, hosting of one exchange in Budapest with 20 experts from 9 countries (BE, NL, LU, FR, DE, PL, RO, IE, CZ).

Ireland

2015:

Concerted checks:

·23 checks with Northern Ireland and the United Kingdom

2016:

Concerted checks:

·18 checks with Northern Ireland and the United Kingdom

Exchange of experience:

Attendance at exchange programmes organised through Euro Controle Route Working Groups.

Apart from enforcement exchanges there were also numerous meetings between senior management personnel from DVSA; DVANI and RSA as part of a Tripartite Working Group.

Ireland is a member of ECR and Corte and participates at working group meetings in relation to training, enforcement practice and interpretation of the regulations.

Italy

2015:

Traffic Police, as part of the activities organised by TISPOL actively participated in the joint European checking and safety campaigns on the carriage of goods and people, to combat offences and conduct 'thematic' campaigns across Europe.

2016:

During 2016, the Traffic Police, as part of the activities organised by TISPOL, the European Traffic Police Network, actively participated in joint European checking and safety campaigns on the carriage of goods and people.

As part of the joint European 'Truck and Bus' campaign, three ‘Truck and Bus’ operations were carried out in Italy in 2016, in February, July and October, during which 3 275 offences were detected relating to driving time, rest breaks and the proper functioning of tachographs in general.

Latvia

2015:

Concerted checks:

·11 roadside checks with Lithuania

·1 road check with Estonia

2016:

Concerted checks:

·9 roadside checks with Lithuania

·1 road check with Estonia

Lithuania

Between 2015 and 2016, 26 joint vehicle-checking exercises were carried out with officials from the Polish and Latvian inspectorates. Joint checks were carried out with Polish officials in the Kalvarija (LT) – Budzisko (PL) border zone, and with officials from the Latvian inspection body in the Saločiai (LT) – Grenctāle (LV), Smėlynė (LT) – Medumi (LV), Obeliai (LT) – Subate (LV), Būtingė (LT) – Rucava (LV) and Kalviai (LT) – Meitene (LV) border zones.

The Inspectorate, together with other Euro Contrôle Route (ECR) member countries, took part in 10 joint freight and passenger vehicle inspections

Luxembourg

2015:

- 2 checks in Sterpenich with Belgium and Netherlands.

- 5 checks in Markusberg and Kaiserslautern with Germany.

- 1 Interregio exercise with Germany

- 3 exercises BENEFRALUX with Belgium, Netherlands and France.

2016 :

- 30 checks on the Dudelange-Zoufftgen route with France.

- 3 checks in Markusberg with Germany

- 3 exercises BENELUX with Belgium, Netherlands and France

- 1 operation in Hazeldonk with Belgium and Netherlands.

Malta

One concerted check was carried out during software training in Poland on the 24th November 2016 with the Polish Authority

Netherlands

8 checks carried out with ECR/TIPSOL partnership.

. Each year between 25 and 30 Dutch inspectors participate in international activities organised by the ECR, such as bilateral and multilateral exchanges of inspectors, workshops and master classes.

The Netherlands also invested heavily in initiating, organising and managing these activities during the reporting period.

In addition, the Netherlands is an active participant in the collaboration within CORTE, which includes work on the development of accepted standardised calculation rules for the calculation of driving times and rest periods on the basis of the applicable EU legislation.

Poland

Road Transport Inspectorate representatives participated in the following coordinated inspection organised by ECR:

2015:

7 concerted inspections

2016:

7 concerted inspections

For both years PL participated at international exchanges on tachograph fraud, passenger transport, secure loading, overloading, social dumping, technical checks of vehicles etc.

PL has also participated at the Master Classes on tachograph as well training workshops on transport of dangerous goods.

Portugal

Portugal has participated in the relevant meetings organised by the competent bodies at Community level.

Romania

2015:

Concerted checks:

7 concerted checks organised by ECR where member state authorities from Austria, Netherlands, France, Belgium, Poland, United Kingdom, Lithuania, Czech Republic, Slovenia, Germany and Romania participated.

Exchange of experience:

3 multilateral events in France, Poland and the Netherlands organised by ECR.

3 workshops in Belgium, Netherlands and Germany.

1 master class in Germany.

1 regional roadside check in Hungary.

2 bilateral roadside checks organised with Hungary.

2016:

Concerted checks:

7 concerted checks organised by ECR with participants from Belgium, Croatia, Ireland, Germany, Netherlands, France, Spain, Austria, Poland, Hungary, United Kingdom, Bulgaria, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Czech Republic, Slovenia and Romania.

Exchange of experience:

4 multilateral events in France, Belgium, Poland and Hungary by ECR.

1 workshop in Belgium organised by CORTE and CVSA USA.

2 master classes organised in Germany by ECR.

4 bilateral roadside checks organised between Romania and Hungary.

Slovakia

Concerted checks:

•    7 checks with the Czech Republic.

•    4 checks with Hungary

•    1 check with Poland.

Slovenia

Concerted checks:

3 concerted checks with Hungary and Croatia.

Exchange of experience:

Slovenia has a status of an Active observer in the ECR organisation. In 2015 and 2016 inspectors participated in Multilateral concerted checks in other ECR member countries.

Spain

Concerted checks:

8 ECR coordinated controls (4 per year each in 2015 and 2016)

6 ECR/TIPSOL coordinated controls (3 per year each in 2015 and 2016)

Sweden

2015:

Concerted checks:

7 different checks with Norway, Denmark, Poland and Romania.

2016:

Concerted checks:

8 different checks with Norway, Denmark, Germany, Hungary and their neighbouring countries.

United Kingdom

2015 and 2016:

Concerted checks:

7 checks each year with ECR members including Ireland, Belgium, Luxembourg, Netherlands, France, Germany, Poland, Austria, Romania, Bulgaria, Hungary Lithuania, Slovenia, Czech Republic and Croatia.

Exchange of experience:

UK hosted an exchange in 2015 involving Great Britain and the Netherlands on remote enforcement and targeting.

In 2016 UK hosted an exchange involving Great Britain, Belgium, Netherlands, Luxembourg, Slovenia, France, Poland and Ireland.

13. Penalties

Article 19 of Regulation (EC) No 561/2006 sets out that Member States shall lay down rules on penalties that are to be effective, proportionate, dissuasive and non-discriminatory. Member States shall notify the Commission of these measures and the rules on penalties. For the current report, the Commission has been notified of the following:

Multiple Member States namely Austria, Bulgaria, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Spain, Ireland, the Netherlands, Romania, Slovenia and the UK have increased fines in 2015 and 2016 for tachograph related infringements – such as fraud, lack of tachograph systems but also relating to the rules for driving and rest times. Denmark for example introduced a general tolerance limit of 5% with anything beyond this number being prosecuted. In addition, drivers who deviate from the maximum driving time or minimum rest time by more than 30% will be disqualified. Similarly, Romania introduced a system where vehicles can be immobilised in order to restore compliance with the driving and resting time rules.

A number of Member States raised the amount of the fines in proportion to the severity of the infringement. These Member States have also indicated that the higher fines have ensured more compliance with the rules and regulations by both undertakers and drivers.

14. Exceptions granted by Member States

According to Article 13 of Regulation (EC) No 561/2006, Member States may grant exceptions from the application of provisions on driving times, breaks and rest periods, provided that certain specific conditions are met and that the overall objectives of the Regulation are not prejudiced. Member States are obliged to inform the Commission of the exceptions granted.

Since the previous report, Romania added the exceptions of (f), (g), (h), (j) – concerning vehicles under 7.5t for gas/electricity, circus and funfair vehicles, milk or animal feed transportation and hub facilities.

The same information is also available on the Commission's website 21 .

National exceptions Regulation (EC) No 561/2006

Austria

Belgium

Bulgaria

Croatia

Cyprus

Czech Republic

Denmark

Estonia

Finland

France

Germany

Greece

Hungary

Ireland

Italy

Latvia

Lithuania

Luxembourg

Malta

Netherlands

Poland

Portugal

Romania

Slovakia

Slovenia

Spain

Sweden

United Kingdom

13.1 a: non-competing public authorities1

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X1

13.1 b: agricultural etc. own activity < 100 km2

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X2

X

X2

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X2

X2

X

X2

13.1 c:agricultural/forestry tractors <100 km3

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X3

X

X

X

13.1 d: <7,5 tons universal services <100 km4

X4

X4

X4

X4

X4

X4

X4

X

X4

X

X4

X4

X4

X4

X4

X4

X4

X

X4

X

X4

X4

13.1 e: operating on islands <2300 square km5

X

X

X

X

X

X5

X

X

X

X

X

X5

X

X

13.1 f: <7,5 t <100 km gas/ electricity6

X6

X6

X6

X6

X6

X6

X

X6

X

X6

X6

X6

X

X6

X

X6

X

13.1 g: instruction/examination driving licence/CPC7

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X7

X

X

X7

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

13.1 h: sewerage/flood protection/water etc8

X8

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X8

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

13.1 i: non-comm. passenger transp. between 10-17 seats9

X

X

X

X

X

X

X9

X

X9

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

13.1 j: circus/funfair10

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X10

X

X

13.1 k: mobile projects for education

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

13.1 l: milk/animal feed from/to farms11

X11

X

X

X

X

X

X11

X

X11

X11

X

X

X

X11

X11

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X11

X

X

13.1 m: transporting money/ valuables12

X12

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X12

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

13.1 n: animal waste or carcasses13

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X13

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

13.1 o: hub facilities14

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X14

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

13.1 p: live animals farms -> markets and vice versa<100km15

X

X15

X15

X15

X15

X15

X15

X15

X

X15

X

X15

X15

X15

X15

X15

X

X15

X

X15

X15

X

1. The following Member State introduced additional restrictions:

a.The United Kingdom: a vehicle does not fall within the description specified unless the vehicle:                                    

(a) is being used for the provision of ambulance services- (i) by a relevant National Health Service (NHS) body, or (ii) in pursuance of arrangements made by or at the request of a relevant NHS body, or made with the Secretary of State or with the Welsh or Scottish Ministers;

(b) is being used for the transport of organs, blood, equipment, medical supplies or personnel - (i) by a relevant NHS body, or (ii) in pursuance of arrangements of the kind mentioned in paragraph (a)(ii)

(c) is being used by a local authority to provide, in exercise of social services functions - (i) services for elderly people, or (ii) services for persons to whom section 29 of the National Assistance Act 1948 (welfare arrangement for physically and mentally handicapped persons) applies;

(d) is being used by Her Majesty's Coastguard, a general lighthouse authority or a local lighthouse authority;

(e) is being used for the purpose of maintaining railways by the British Railways Board, any holder of a network licence (within the meaning of Part 1 of the Railways Act 1993) which is a company wholly owned by the Crown (within the meaning of that Act), Transport for London, any wholly owned subsidiary of Transport for London, a Passenger Transport Executive or a local authority

(f) is being used by the British Waterways Board for the purpose of maintaining navigable waterways

2.The following Member States introduced additional restrictions:

a.Estonia - within a radius of 50 km of the place where the vehicle is usually based, including towns within this area

b.France - only vehicles or combinations of vehicles up to 7,5 tonnes and only within a radius of 50 km

c.Slovenia – within a radius of up to 50 km

d.Spain – agriculture etc. own activity within a range < 50 km

e.The United Kingdom - a vehicle which is being used by a fishery undertaking does not fall within the description specified unless the vehicle is being used:

(a) to carry live fish, or

(b) to carry a catch of fish from the place of landing to a place where it is to be processed

3.The following Member States introduced additional restrictions:

a.Slovenia - within a radius of up to 50 km

4.The following Member States introduced additional restrictions:

a.Belgium, Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Finland, France, Hungary, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia, Spain – within a radius < 50km

b.The United Kingdom – vehicles between 3.5 - 7.5 tonnes used by universal service providers within a 50 km radius of the base of the undertaking require a tachograph

5.The following Member States introduced additional restrictions:

a.France - operating on islands <400 square km

b.Spain – operating on islands < 250 square km

6.The following Member States introduced additional restrictions:

a.Croatia, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Estonia, Finland, France, Hungary, Lithuania, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia, Spain – within a radius < 50km

7.The following Member States introduced additional restrictions:

a.Italy - it refers only to the obligation of equipping and using tachograph

b.Luxembourg - exception only for the (learning) driver, instructor must respect Regulation (EC) No 561/20006

8.The following Member States introduced additional restrictions:

a.Austria:

(a) vehicles used by the regional authorities’ road construction offices and driven by employees of the provinces or municipalities are entirely exempted

(b) vehicles used in connection with sewerage, flood protection, water, gas and electricity supply, telegraph and telephone services, radio and television broadcasting, and the detection of radio or television transmitters or receivers are entirely exempted where driving of vehicles does not constitute the driver’s main activity

(c) vehicles used by household refuse collection authorities are exempted only from the rules on breaks under Article 7 of Regulation (EC) No 561/2006

(d) vehicles used in winter by road construction offices, where not covered by the exemption under point 9 a.(a), are exempted only from the rules on breaks under Article 7 of Regulation (EC) No 561/2006

b.France - for door-to-door household refuse collection and disposal, only within a radius of 100 km

9.The following Member States introduced additional restrictions:

a.Estonia - owner/authorised user of a vehicle with 10-17 seats who is a parent of 4/more children, respective entry made on a registration certificate of the vehicle and the vehicle is used for non-commercial passenger transport

b.France - not for the transport of children

10.The following Member State introduced additional restrictions:

a.Spain - only when own activity

11.The following Member States introduced additional restrictions:

a.Austria - vehicles used to collect raw milk from farms exempted only from the rules on breaks under Article 7 of Regulation (EC) No 561/2006

b.Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania, as of 1/01/2008, mutually apply the exception from Articles 5 to 9 to vehicles used for milk collection from farms,...etc., only in cases where the service radius does not exceed 100 km

c.France - within a radius of up to 150 km of the base of the undertaking

d.Germany – within a radius of 100km

e.Spain – milk/animal feed from /to farms within a range < 100 km

12.The following Member States introduced additional restrictions:

a.Austria – exception only from the rules on breaks under Article 7 of Regulation (EC) No 561/2006

b.Ireland - vehicles specially designed for mobile banking, exchange and saving transactions

13.The following Member State introduced additional restrictions:

a.Germany - within a radius of up to 250 km of the base of the undertaking

14.The following Member State introduced additional restrictions:

a.The Netherlands – on or between hub facilities within a range of 5 km

15.The following Member State introduced additional restrictions:

a.Belgium, Croatia, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Estonia, Finland, France, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, the Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Slovakia, Spain, Sweden – within a radius < 50km

16.Comments and proposals

Some Member States shared their views regarding the Commission’s proposal as part of the Mobility Package I 22 . Finland express its doubts regarding the amendment to Directive 2006/22/EC that would extend the scope of the monitoring requirements to include the Road Transport Working Time Directive 2002/15/EC which could lead to problems to coordinate those in practice. Slovakia also shared its doubts regarding the proposal to amend Regulation (EC) No 561/2006. This related in particular to the provisions on the duration for the regular weekly rest 23 , the total accumulated driving time during any two consecutive week 24 Regulation (EC) No 561/2006 and in particular the provision of Article 8.2 on new daily rest period.

Some Member States referred to the training of enforcers at national level and the importance of joint inspections. The Dutch authorities highlighted that increasingly sophisticated tachograph fraud and manipulation techniques make monitoring and enforcement more difficult and take up a large amount of the available inspection capacity. Professional development training for inspection staff and the expansion and renewal of inspection methods and equipment create significant pressure on the available work force and funds. Therefore, the Netherlands invests heavily in sharing and maintaining the necessary expertise and information within the ECR, TISPOL and Benelux networks in order to keep abreast of developments in the field.
The Czech Republic also flagged out the importance of proactive involvement of Czech representatives in activities on the ECR agenda and that there was desire for a constant deepening of professional knowledge regarding inspection procedures in all specific areas of inspection activity.

Austria authorities also shared the fact that the training programme of their Federal Ministry of the Interior and the Federal Ministry of Labour, Social Affairs and Consumer Protection includes regular courses for the inspection bodies. The training covers social legislation and the detection of manipulation and is based on the TRACE project.

It is worth noting that the Commission is planning on elaborating common criteria for training of enforcers across the EU which would allow for a more consistent approach to enforcement throughout the EU.

17. Interpretation of Regulation (EC) No 561/2006 and Directive 2002/15/EC

In the recent years, the Court of Justice of the European Union shed light on interpretation of Regulation (EC) No 561/2006 by means of the following preliminary ruling:

Judgment of the European Court of Justice of 20 December 2017 in case C-102/16

The case relates to the ban for drivers to take their regular weekly rest period in their vehicle. Regulation (EC) No 561/2006 on the harmonisation of certain social legislation relating to road transport requires drivers to take a regular daily rest period of at least 11 hours (which may, subject to certain conditions, be reduced to 9 hours) and a regular weekly rest period of 45 hours (which may, subject to certain conditions,be reduced to 24 hours). The regulation adds that, if a driver chooses to do so, daily rest periods and reduced weekly rest periods away from base may be taken in the vehicle, as long as it has suitable sleeping facilities for each driver and the vehicle is stationary. The question at stake in this case was whether Article 8(6) and (8) of Regulation No 561/2006 must be interpreted as meaning that the regular weekly rest periods referred to in Article 8(6) of the regulation may not be spent inside the vehicle. The ECJ concluded that the EU regulation harmonising social legislation in the road transport sector clearly prohibits drivers from taking their regular weekly rest periods in a vehicle

Regarding judicial interpretation by national courts, none of the Member States reported any significant national court decisions interpreting Directive 2002/15/EC during 2015-2016.

18. Monitoring and control arrangements of Directive 2002/15/EC in Member States

Member States indicated that they had implemented Directive 2002/15/E. The monitoring of implementation of Directive 2002/15/EC is ensured at national level by different authorities from one Member State to another. Overall and across the EU, the bodies responsible for the monitoring and control arrangements of Directive 2002/15/EC are the labour inspectorate, road transport agency, occupational health and safety authority, road safety authorities and road transport inspections.

19. Issues in relation to enforcement of Directive 2002/15/EC

A majority of Member States did not report having experienced issues in relation to enforcement of Directive 2002/15/EC. Some Member States shared specific issues they face at national level.

In Italy, definitions on “time devoted to all road transport activities” and “periods of time during which the mobile worker cannot dispose freely of his time” cause interpretation issues and Italy feels a need to clarify those definitions. The United Kingdom noted that working time records are not checked at the roadside due to the fact that 17 weeks of records are not required to be held in the vehicle. In Czech Republic, a new work pattern by which one employee (driver) works for two employers (transport undertakings) gave rise to difficulties to implement the Directive. Indeed, such practices were reported as being difficult to prove as only a transport undertaking subject to Regulation (EC) No 561/2006 is required to request a copy of a working-time record from another employer. Slovakia reported its infrastructure as lagging behind considering the expansion of road freight transport and that it was thus working on its motorway network and on building more parking areas.

20. Statistics on working days checks at the roadside and premises

MS

Minimum
checks

(3%) for

2015-2016

Number of working days checked

Total

at roadside

at premises

% at roadside

% at
premises

% of working
days checked

AT

1,409,760

5,059,469

4,300,665

758,804

85%

15%

10.8%

BE

1,620,095

1,626,823

1,120,361

506,462

69%

31%

3.0%

BG

1,955,817

7,330,353

3,034,729

4,295,624

41%

59%

11.2%

HR

666,288

1,114,909

740,369

374,540

66%

34%

5.0%

CY

178,497

220,003

105,836

114,167

48%

52%

3.7%

CZ

1,200,698

3,281,320

2,366,610

914,710

72%

28%

8.2%

DK

660,000

684,287

417,975

266,312

61%

39%

3.1%

EE

224,400

310,946

157,490

153,456

51%

49%

4.2%

FI*

1,110,608

1,657,824

1,084,986

572,838

65%

35%

4.5%

FR

6,704,624

26,486,976

21,627,286

4,859,690

82%

18%

11.9%

DE

7,294,522

27,838,789

23,974,917

3,863,872

86%

14%

11.4%

EL

4,357,200

215,290

159,204

56,086

74%

26%

0.1%

HU

2,042,508

4,661,736

4,072,236

589,500

87%

13%

6.8%

IE

1,147,442

1,833,426

136,826

1,696,600

7%

93%

4.8%

IT

8,444,124

9,771,694

7,669,304

2,102,390

78%

22%

3.5%

LV

478,498

1,627,984

700,391

927,593

43%

57%

10.2%

LT

860,736

883,750

534,045

349,705

60%

40%

3.1%

LU

160,502

191,020

61,045

129,975

32%

68%

3.6%

MT

2,304

2,174

1,092

1,082

50%

50%

2.8%

NL

1,688,507

1,219,695

956,159

263,536

78%

22%

2.2%

PL

4,291,401

9,323,443

6,364,406

2,959,037

68%

32%

6.5%

PT

831,864

1,853,295

1,349,800

503,495

73%

27%

6.7%

RO

2,294,510

5,305,977

2,607,248

2,698,729

49%

51%

6.9%

SK

504,000

605,635

252,132

353,503

42%

58%

3.6%

SL

466,860

660,676

427,606

233,070

65%

35%

4.2%

ES

5,413,406

9,965,513

6,586,653

3,378,860

66%

34%

5.5%

SE

1,029,600

1,636,268

1,057,713

578,555

65%

35%

4.8%

UK

5,839,657

6,287,639

5,031,298

1,256,341

80%

20%

3.2%

TOTAL

62,878,428

131,656,914

96,898,382

34,758,532

74%

26%

6.3%

* These working days checked in FI are in reality much higher as the numbers reported do not include days which were a driver's weekly rest.

21. Statistics on number of working days checked at roadside by country of registration of the vehicle

MS

Nationals

Other EU nationals

non-EU nationals

Total

AT

92,848

160,788

10,411

264,047

BE

36,916

54,168

2,317

53,320

BG

209,717

40,799

45,380

295,896

HR

20,282

3,742

7,272

31,006

CY

6,598

2

-

6,600

CZ

70,156

53,236

4,840

126,766

DK

17,858

9769*

no data

no data

EE

6,854

996

178

8,028

FI**

no data

no data

no data

1,085,486

FR

301,308

514,201

12,873

775,348

DE

757,723

548,554

60,233

2,892,104

EL

33,479

4,560

2,769

40,808

HU

82,241

50,134

13,062

143,210

IE

8,928

424

4

9,361

IT

573,715

86,619

9,428

669,705

LV

15,177

8,604

2,624

26,052

LT

34,110

17,312

14,503

60,898

LU

1,059

1,969

31

3,013

MT

26

13

-

39

NL

14,417

17,737

817

32,971

PL

353,622

90,616

103,420

527,725

PT

68,077

2,354

16

61,666

RO

386,521

29,718

24,057

327,088

SK

6,370

6,840

1,003

13,911

SL

6,787

5,288

8,120

19,334

ES

428,135

49,873

2,661

458,487

SE

21,715

16,787

804

44,704

UK

82,976

97,375

4,779

185,130

TOTAL

3,637,866

1,873,598

334,547

8,162,703

* This figure under other EU nationals includes also figures of non-EU nationals

** These working days checked in FI are in reality much higher as the numbers reported do not include days which were a driver's weekly rest

22. Statistics on checks at roadside by the number of drivers checked, by country of registration and by type of carriage

MS

Total drivers

Nationals

Other EU
nationals

Non-EU
nationals

Carriers of
passengers

Carriers of goods

AT

264,047

92,848

160,788

10,411

2,563

261,484

BE

93,401

36,916

54,168

2,317

7,539

85,862

BG

295,896

209,717

40,799

45,380

54,162

241,734

HR

31,296

20,282

3,742

7,272

2,957

28,339

CY

6,600

6,598

2

-

2,189

4,411

CZ

128,232

70,156

53,236

4,840

6,243

121,989

DK

27,627

17,858

9769*

-

306

26,764

EE

8,028

6,854

996

178

306

7,722

FI

4,316

251

1,120

2,945

no data

no data

FR

828,382

301,308

514,201

12,873

57,690

770,692

DE

1,366,510

757,723

548,554

60,233

35,489

1,331,021

EL

40,808

33,479

4,560

2,769

27,783

13,025

HU

145,437

82,241

50,134

13,062

1,746

143,691

IE

9,356

8,928

424

4

341

9,015

IT

669,762

573,715

86,619

9,428

31,349

638,413

LV

26,405

15,177

8,604

2,624

785

25,620

LT

65,925

34,110

17,312

14,503

5,086

60,839

LU

3,059

1,059

1,969

31

73

2,986

MT

39

26

13

-

-

39

NL

32,971

14,417

17,737

817

2,251

30,720

PL

547,658

353,622

90,616

103,420

117,079

430,579

PT

70,447

68,077

2,354

16

6,283

64,164

RO

440,296

386,521

29,718

24,057

137,604

302,692

SK

14,213

6,370

6,840

1,003

1,606

12,607

SL

20,195

6,787

5,288

8,120

2,084

18,111

ES

480,669

428,135

49,873

2,661

31,236

449,433

SE

39,306

21,715

16,787

804

982

38,324

UK

185,130

82,976

97,375

4,779

10,832

174,298

TOTAL

5,846,011

3,637,866

1,873,598

334,547

546,564

5,294,574

* DK: also includes figures of non-EU nationals

23. Statistics on checks at roadside by the number of vehicles stopped by country of registration and type of tachograph

MS

Total

Nationals

Non-
nationals

Third
nationals

Analogue
tacho

%
Analogue

Digital
tacho

%
Digital

AT

264,047

92,848

160,788

10,411

23,568

9%

240,479

91%

BE

53,320

18,300

33,157

1,863

14,449

27%

38,871

73%

BG

295,896

209,718

40,799

45,379

70,375

24%

225,521

76%

HR

31,006

20,220

3,643

7,143

18,864

61%

12,020

39%

CY

6,600

6,598

2

-

4,759

72%

1,841

28%

CZ

126,766

69,780

52,285

4,701

37,287

29%

89,479

71%

DK

 

 

 

No data

 

 

 

 

EE

8,028

6,853

996

179

3,934

49%

4,094

51%

FI

1,085,486

3,382

81%

785

19%

FR

775,348

297,480

466,650

11,218

115,617

15%

659,731

85%

DE

2,892,104

1,744,896

1,001,779

145,429

523,487

18%

2,368,617

82%

EL

40,808

33,479

4,560

2,769

29,783

73%

11,025

27%

HU

143,210

80,734

47,355

15,121

23,203

16%

120,007

84%

IE

9,361

8,928

429

4

2,293

24%

7,068

76%

IT

669,705

573,669

86,613

9,423

308,395

46%

361,310

54%

LV

26,052

14,824

8,604

2,624

10,258

39%

15,794

61%

LT

60,898

27,926

20,115

12,857

31,188

51%

29,710

49%

LU

3,013

1,045

1,938

30

415

14%

2,598

86%

MT

39

26

13

-

15

38%

24

62%

NL

32,971

14,417

17,737

817

7,248

22%

25,723

78%

PL

527,725

346,020

82,127

99,578

319,046

63%

190,055

37%

PT

61,666

59,527

2,125

14

34,600

56%

27,066

44%

RO

327,088

270,466

33,130

23,492

172,162

53%

154,926

47%

SK

13,911

6,228

6,674

1,009

2,468

18%

11,443

82%

SL

19,334

5,713

5,391

8,230

7,207

37%

12,127

63%

ES

458,487

408,722

47,313

2,452

133,457

29%

325,030

71%

SE

44,704

25,231

18,549

924

8,143

18%

36,561

82%

UK

185,130

82,976

97,375

4,779

72,269

39%

112,861

61%

TOTAL

8,162,703

4,426,624

2,240,147

410,446

1,977,872

28%

5,084,766

72%

24. Statistics on checks at premises by the number of drivers, undertakings and working days checked

MS

Number of drivers checked

Number of undertakings
checked

Number of working
days checked

AT

11,900

1,633

758,804

BE

22,538

4,208

506,462

BG

153,415

10,332

4,295,624

HR

3,636

716

374,540

CY

1,808

796

114,167

CZ

7,545

952

914,710

DK

17,734

1,910

266,312

EE

3,296

249

153,456

FI

14,672

2,257

572,838

FR

95,671

6,921

4,859,690

DE

59,609

6,697

3,863,872

EL

1,739

632

56,086

HU

21,052

844

589,500

IE

925

653

1,696,600

IT

25,716

8,013

2,102,390

LV

4,222

491

927,593

LT

9,210

895

349,705

LU

3,909

221

129,975

MT

4

3

1,082

NL

9,412

962

263,536

PL

33,150

4,421

2,959,037

PT

6,382

954

503,495

RO

17,009

50,229

2,698,729

SK

6,211

868

353,503

SL

1,541

330

233,070

ES

117,390

21,537

3,378,860

SE

11,534

296

578,555

UK

1,795

19,577

1,256,341

TOTAL

663,025

147,597

34,758,532

25. Statistic on types of offences at roadside

MS

Driving
time

Breaks

Rest
periods

28 days
record

sheet

Lack/
availability

of records

for other work

Incorrect
functioning

Misuse and
manipulation

Total
offences

AT

70229

96841

106648

54543

37650

3212

4531

373654

BE

3612

2101

5634

696

239

540

2683

15505

BG

146

417

803

814

172

47

63

2462

HR

808

1568

3145

1961

198

49

2044

9773

CY

111

527

299

222

25

532

0

1716

CZ

6178

9970

13468

28155

1985

815

842

61413

DK

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

EE

258

896

1100

408

376

245

488

3771

FI

154

131

61

87

0

33

8

5461

FR

18623

9702

38507

19397

16381

15715

1206

119530

DE

107027

92051

122780

58170

75845

0

198963

654836

EL

2416

4798

4989

3310

356

694

1215

17778

HU

1463

2430

3406

1179

1272

2466

900

13116

IE

434

1396

863

195

143

1327

273

4631

IT

14650

14010

20226

50426

18035

3251

1698

122296

LV

343

439

972

1594

0

30

45

3423

LT

1426

1298

3361

4070

1170

789

303

12417

LU

308

157

330

1

31

6

50

883

MT

2

8

8

0

2

8

0

28

NL

2941

3630

6082

131

2

2211

2378

17375

PL

23014

17919

56230

17862

14318

6643

68410

204396

PT

4254

5614

6189

9940

2642

2096

5367

36102

RO

10573

10804

18041

3859

142

1198

839

45456

SK

1369

3101

3401

750

39

128

73

8861

SL

1371

3094

3936

738

365

641

880

11025

ES

29948

18903

60341

33087

0

8364

1010

151653

SE

6283

13274

14698

149

164

95

122

34785

UK

4141

5054

18629

14362

4032

41

23183

69442

TOTAL

312082

320133

514147

306106

175584

51176

317574

2001788

26. Statistics on types of offences at premises

MS

driving
time

breaks

rest periods

driving time
records

incorrect
functioning or recording equipment

Manipulation
of recording equipment

Lack/ availability of records for other work

Total of
offences

AT

1414

5783

2571

11

444

18

0

10241

BE

4189

8802

7231

745

90

220

0

21277

BG

239

91

169

256

14

31

7

807

HR

526

2035

3467

30

2

1820

454

8342

CY

554

4167

5662

82

1176

0

477

12118

CZ

2269

3572

3779

13071

68

1054

550

24363

DK

214

1123

1348

291

3

0

0

2979

EE

439

483

1180

122

0

0

0

2224

FI*

4058

16257

12202

273

144

756

230

33981

FR

2491

4195

9911

1078

73

1701

785

22776

DE

71087

197839

124338

0

0

22086

20213

441759

EL

77

4

91

4

0

0

0

204

HU

300

701

2605

101

608

207

159

5314

IE*

1736

10619

5520

164

562

58

42

19351

IT

5619

14299

11588

74204

722

874

230

111064

LV*

No details

271505

LT

1781

767

1524

603

0

252

13

5601

LU

1612

3533

3473

4

6

28

39

8712

MT

4

1

2

0

0

0

0

7

NL

4648

6094

4800

2420

741

7306

0

26014

PL

6529

9285

21538

285654

193

11719

21407

362373

PT

98

54

125

5

0

4

16

313

RO

792

1631

3992

841

28

54

0

7343

SK

3004

5513

7754

161

98

34

7

16973

SL

1410

718

1352

342

42

133

82

4079

ES

6917

3705

9901

4705

343

222

84

25877

SE

980

4406

3597

2693

551

0

10279

7063

UK

474

1540

1198

0

3564

153

128

22506

TOTAL

123461

307217

250918

387860

9472

48730

55202

1475166

* no full breakdown of offences provided.

22. Stakeholders' views on implementation of Directive 2002/15/EC in Member States

Only ten Member States clearly indicated that stakeholders were consulted in the framework of this reporting exercise 25 . This number is stable compared to the last report but still low compared to previous years 26 . In all Member States, this consultation consisted in getting the views of representatives of employers and trade unions. In six out of ten Member States, social partners were consulted but their views did not give rise to a separate section 27 . They were rather incorporated throughout the document or, in a few cases, it was indicated that social partners did not have any comments. Therefore, opinions from social partners cannot be analysed as this does not constitute a representative sample 28 .

(1)

SWD(2017) 184 final from 31.05.2017.

(2)

COM(2017) 277 final and COM(2017) 278 final

(3)

Germany, France and Romania reported together around 17.4 million less working days checked compared to the last report. Germany explained that data of three Länder were missing for this report.

(4)

Ireland explained that this figures does not include members of the police force and solely refers to staff from the Road Safety Authority.

(5)

Poland explained that this figure does not include police officers involved in roadside checks

(6)

Data from Denmark and Finland are missing for these figures as they were not complete.

(7)

Data not available for Denmark

(8)

This does not include data from Denmark and Finland due to their incompleteness.

(9)

Data is not available for Denmark

(10)

Data from Finland was not included to its incompleteness.

(11)

Greece has however only checked 0.1% instead of 3% of the number of working days required.

(12)

All Member States except for Denmark has provided the number of roadside offences.

(13)

Greece has not met the threshold.

(14)

Denmark has not provided data on offences detected at the roadside

(15)

Finland did not provide a breakdown of offences at the road.

(16)

Finland, Ireland and Latvia did not provide a full or no breakdown of total offences at the premises.

(17)

Out of 176 offences at premises reported.

(18)

Out of seven of offences at premises reported.

(19)

Croatia, Cyprus, Finland, Greece

(20)

Austria, Czech Republic, Germany, France, Hungary, Ireland, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Romania, Slovakia, Spain, Sweden, UK.

(21)

  https://ec.europa.eu/transport/sites/transport/files/national_exceptions_regulation_2006_561.pdf

(22)

Proposal for a directive of the European Parliament and of the Council amending Directive 2006/22/EC as regards enforcement requirements and laying down specific rules with respect to Directive 96/71/EC and Directive 2014/67/EU for posting drivers in the road transport sector - COM(2017) 278 final

(23)

Article 4(h) of Regulation (EC) No 561/2006

(24)

Article 6.3 of Regulation (EC) No 561/2006

(25)

Cyprus, Estonia, Finland, France, Ireland, Italy, Lithuania, Poland, Slovenia and Slovakia

(26)

Ten Member States consulted stakeholders for the last reporting period and 16 the reporting period 2011-2012.

(27)

Cyprus, Estonia, Finland, France, Lithuania, Poland,

(28)

Ireland, Italy, Slovenia and Slovakia